Captain Marvel vs Silver Surfer

Originally posted by Ambient

He shrugs off/withstood this elder demon gods mystical attack...

Again withstood mystical attack from Mephisto himself...

Its goin to take more than mystical lightning bolt to take Surfer out, im not too sure that Capt. has got what it takes...

There's been a few whos gone mano to mano against Supes even bloodied him out a bit but thats not necessarily make them his equal..
Feat wise Supes >>>>> a big margin in strength and durability than Capt...

What exactly has this weapon done other than turn things inside out ?????? lol That makes it greater than Surfer ?????

Anyhow Surfer ftw via massive energy discharge/Bfr...

Excellent post. The people in this thread who thinks CM is more powerful than Surfer need their heads seriously examined.

Excellent post. The people in this thread who thinks CM is more powerful than Surfer need their heads seriously examined.

Originally posted by kgkg
Superman has more fans I guess 😉

logically CM should do better against Norrin than Superman since he does not have weakness that can be easily exploited like Superman.

But I don't see CM as = to Superman

well said post..............well said.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
CM stats rival Supes, with no exploitating I don't see SS taking the majority. There about even in speed, to be hoenst I don't remember CM ever useing superspeed in battle much like with SS. In SS defense he can at least initiate blast fairly quick, but I don't think he will output enough power to KO CM. On the other hand, I think magical charged bolts or strikes will do some considerable damage to SS.

stats are not always enough. And to be honest surfer is not physically weak and can take a hit. Surfer beast cap on pure versitility.

Ill never understand with supes fans why they think that stats are enough to qualify you as unbeatable. Stats dont stop magical beings. Cap i think has a better chance then supes here but Ss takes both them down.

ss=6 cap=4

Originally posted by zeel
stats are not always enough. And to be honest surfer is not physically weak and can take a hit. Surfer beast cap on pure versitility.

Ill never understand with supes fans why they think that stats are enough to qualify you as unbeatable. Stats dont stop magical beings. Cap i think has a better chance then supes here but Ss takes both them down.

ss=6 cap=4

You're entittled to that opinion, personally I don't think CM stats are = to supes but at least rival his. At any rate I give CM a 6-7/10 in this match.

welcome back 🙂

Originally posted by Mindset
welcome back 🙂

💃

Originally posted by The Great Galen
You're entittled to that opinion, personally I don't think CM stats are = to supes but at least rival his. At any rate I give CM a 6-7/10 in this match.

Originally posted by Ambient
So you think CM is >> Supes? Based on?

?....no I said supes>CM.

Originally posted by Juntai
Because Supes isn't as weak to magic as people like to think he is.

Originally posted by Leobama
But it does weaken him, right? If so, and cm is his physical equal, cm should destroy him, imo. Cm's strength is magic based, right?

I think it was explained sometime during the PC era that magic bypasses his bio aura...I haven't seen it explained any better than that.

And yes, his strength is magic-based. He's got the strength of Hercules thanks to Shazam's empowerment.

The things that make this battle different from a fight against is that CM doesn't have senses on the level that Superman does nor his diversity.

On the flip side of that there also aren't any weaknesses that SS can try to reproduce. Surfer isn't any more resistant to magic than Supes is. If Caps start laying the magic lightning charged punches. Surfer will be ko'd. This time it's SS who is at the receiving end of weakness exploitation.

The real trick is will SS have time to pull some type of advanced technique when magic laced super strong punches are coming at him?

Originally posted by Avlon
The things that make this battle different from a fight against is that CM doesn't have senses on the level that Superman does nor his diversity.

On the flip side of that there also aren't any weaknesses that SS can try to reproduce. Surfer isn't any more resistant to magic than Supes is. If Caps start laying the magic lightning charged punches. Surfer will be ko'd. This time it's SS who is at the receiving end of weakness exploitation.

The real trick is will SS have time to pull some type of advanced technique when magic laced super strong punches are coming at him?

He's certainly not especially resistant to it.

KMC SS has no weakness.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
KMC SS has no weakness.

Originally posted by Mindset
SS has a weakness to magic now?

Galactus has... To a degree.

-------

The way I see this fight going. I started to think about how it would go down. First I thought they would try to kick each other's asses just by hitting each other with punches and other melee attacks. If it went down to this, I'd wager Captain Marvel would win the majority.

Then I remembered that Silver Surfer's main offense is his powerful blasts, now I don't know how Captain Marvel's magical resistance handles energy based attacks, but I'd say Silver Surfer would eventually take him down. Now, I still think he'd need to keep his distance in order to KO him without getting himself into a fist fight. He'd we able to do this if he avoided Marvel right from the start, but if Marvel would be fast enough I think he could close the gap faster.

So if they both used their powers to the fullest I'd say SS beat classic Captain Marvel for a majority.

If CM has supes level h2h speed I'd say he would easily destroy SS, but to my knowledge he tends to brawl out like a brick.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
KMC SS has no weakness.

Surfer doesn't have weaknesses period (unless you count machinery built to siphon the Power Cosmic), so why would you add KMC?

When he takes on an Elder God that Thanos and Galactus want to use for power, beats Loki, and battles it out with Mephisto more than once, I don't think you can count magic as a weakness.

Originally posted by Avlon
He's certainly not especially resistant to it.