Darth malak and revan vs NJO luke

An all out fight.in the Jedi council chamber. who wins?

Revan . . . alone

Luke. Easily

I fail to see how luke wins this easily unless you're insinuating that Jacen>Revan and Malak, or hell, even Jacen>Revan.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
I fail to see how luke wins this easily unless you're insinuating that Jacen>Revan and Malak, or hell, even Jacen>Revan.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but haven't you been praising Luke's abilities as the "most powerful Force-user" ever? That would put him in excess of the likes of Darth Sidious and upper tier Force users, who would most certainly manhandle Darth Revan (who is lesser than Yoda) and Darth Malak (who is on par with Count Dooku).

I would say that Skywalker takes this comfortably; Count Dooku vs. Obi-Wan and Anakin in Attack of the Clones seems an apt measurement.

Yes I have but that got me thinking, if Luke can take those two comfortable, then by some measure Jacen must be more powerful than either of them and possibly than both of them combined. That would make no sense seeing as how their dark side knowledge are beyond Jacen's, as should be Revan's force mastery.

Originally posted by Darth Sexy
Yes I have but that got me thinking, if Luke can take those two comfortable, then by some measure Jacen must be more powerful than either of them and possibly than both of them combined. That would make no sense seeing as how their dark side knowledge are beyond Jacen's, as should be Revan's force mastery.

Just because Person X can withstand Person Y, that doesn't mean Person X can withstand Person Z, even if Person Z is inferior to Person Y.

We can blame this all on writer's fiat, but Jacen's raw strength in the Force likely acts as a multiplier, and it's clear that his raw abilities are well in excess of Revan's and Malak's. It's the reason why Anakin Skywalker, despite much lesser accumulated time and training, was superior to his master even as of Attack of the Clones.

Well I guess that's one way of putting it. If I'm arguing out of ignorance it's because of the LOTF authors.

Next time skywalker833 makes a "Luke vs." thread, lets all say that Luke would lose just to piss him off and shut him up.

WTF? I dont know what your problem is, but im just trying to put some threads with luke in after i noticed that there arent many with him. I can post some other threads in or something, just tell me what im doing wrong and i will try to correct it. you dont have to get all mad.

You're posting a extreme amount of threads.
There, is that clear enough for you?

Im just trying to get some on in my first days here, than i'll lay low, so lay off.

Why? A majority of your thread's combatants are literally random.
With some people fighting other people that may be leagues away from their own "Power" category.

OK, first of all, do you have something against me? I havent done anything to you. Pretty much all of my threads are good, so back off.

Dude, you're the one who needs to back off. Nobody here likes you. Because you keep making stupid threads and you keep bumping old threads. And then, when people try to tell you nicely to stop, you get snotty with them. So just stop, okay? Before everybody gets on your case.

First of all, people arent asking anything nicely. Just remember, i'm a kid who is new to this whole thing, i dont want to make any enemies.

Are you paranoid or something? We asked you nicely first. But you kept doing it.

Originally Posted by darthsith19
Hey new guy, quit bumping old threads, okay? Bumping old threads will make people here hate you, and definitely don't bump an old thread just so you can say "Luke pwns" when clearly nobody here disagrees...

That was the first time I warned you, and the first time anybody tried to help you out that I know of. While I wasn't extremely nice there I don't see how I was mean, either. I was just straight-forward with you.

ok,ok,ok. I'll back off. I dont see what im doing wrong but you've been here longer, i respect that and i should probably take your advice.

The thing is, people don't like it when:
- Somebody makes a whole bunch of threads at once. Just try to make threads in moderation, okay?
- Somebody bumps an old thread. If you say disagreed with what most people said in the old thread and are ready to debate your points, fine. But don't just bump an old thread to repeat what everybody else has said, okay?

Do you understand that these things can be annoying? I also bumped a fair number of old threads over the course of 2-3 days when I first came to this section. It aggravated people.

Yeah, i kinda see why that is a little anoying. Thanks for telling. And at first it seemed like there were tons of threads and i wanted to make some myself. I think im rushing this whole thing. Thanks alot for the advice.