Darth malak and revan vs NJO luke

No problem.

Hopefully we all can learn from this insane yet hilarious event.

Yeah. And by the way, I think we're going a little off topic! lol

Well I think we all agree that Luke would win, so lets just let this die, okay?

Wait! I never agreed that Luke would win!!!! XD

Luke is good enough to take on two Sith Lords at once, huh?

Yeah, lets call it dead.

I was still looking for the definitive proof.

Sorry...

....! Yeah, even though I hate to admit it, Luke is.

Well, I guess we could always just post opinions and call it productive.

Malak and Revan win.

Exactly, i think most people on this thread said luke would win, anyone not agree?

Janus disagrees, but I'm not going to debate with him. But Janus, are you being serious?

Me. I think such a sweeping statement begs for proof. I'm not saying that Luke won't win, but I am saying that we should be better than this. We should post why either side would win and make it convincing. Otherwise, we're just wasting time and bandwidth.

Now, anyone here have a good argument for Mr Skywalker?

I'm not getting into this...

Me neither, but on the other hand, are there any good arguements for Revan and Malak? If we all agree that Luke would win, I don't see what the point debating it would be. If we want to debate, we should debate about something that is disagreed upon.

No, I didn't expect you would. Everyone's entitled to an opinion, but to be convinced, some of us require decent arguments. Again, Luke may very well carry the day, but I for one would like to see something in his favor other than opinions and blanket statements.

Originally posted by darthsith19
Me neither, but on the other hand, are there any good arguements for Revan and Malak? If we all agree that Luke would win, I don't see what the point debating it would be. If we want to debate, we should debate about something that is disagreed upon.

So let me formulate what I believe is your position:

Luke has an established series of movies and books and is pretty impressive by most people's standards.

Ergo he destroys two notorious and powerful Sith lords in single combat.

You find that perfectly acceptable, huh?

Ok, here goes. Luke could take one out with his instakill. Then defeat the other one.

What "instakill?" Substantiate how it works and why it will kill a Sith Lord, beings who typically specialize in using the dark size offensively?