Darth malak and revan vs NJO luke

Started by darthsith194 pages

Originally posted by Janus Marius
So let me formulate what I believe is your position:

Luke has an established series of movies and books and is pretty impressive by most people's standards.

Ergo he destroys two notorious and powerful Sith lords in single combat.

You find that perfectly acceptable, huh?


You really want to debate, huh? Well I'm not feeling up to it, sorry dude. You're too good for me anyways, but I'm sure Lightsnake or Gideon will come around sometime.

Actually Marius, all i know is that it worked amazingly with the vong

You're sometimes better than you give yourself credit for, and quite frankly you've weathered a lot of harsh debating all these years rather well, so I respect if you try. If not, I'm fine with that. I just want to put the challenge out there for those who will take it up. I'm very interested in seeing Luke's powers and feats put into context because I have not been able to read up on him lately.

Originally posted by skywalker833
Actually Marius, all i know is that it worked amazingly with the vong

Me too, which is why I'm not convinced it works on dark siders.

Thank you. But, I'm not feeling up to it right now. I'm not really an expert on Luke. What I know about Luke after DE is pretty much just what I've heard from people here, and what I've read on Wookieepedia.

a great place to look is wookiepedia, if you have the time. of course you probably already know about it.

I thought about reading it, but sometimes Wookiepedia is biased.

True.

About Luke's "Instakill" lightning. All I know about it is didn't it kill like 7 Vong in 1 second? Assuming it works the same on Vong as Force Lightning works on humans, and all other species, Revan and Malak would be f*cked, I think. Yoda was barely able to block Sidious's lightning, and Sidious's lightning was about to rip Mace's lightsaber right out of his hands (the novel states that Mace had no strength left in him, and that his blade bent so close to his face that he was choking on ozone, and Mace admitted to Anakin that Palpatine was too strong for him - that's when the lightning attack ceased). Luke's lightning, stronger than Sidious's, would be unstoppable for Malak or Revan, then, unless it can be proved that they are enough stronger physically than Mace that they could block it with their lightsaber. Neither of them could block it with the Force, either, since Yoda is stronger than either of them (it was stated in the ROTS novel or something that he was the strongest Jedi ever up to that point). So if Luke can take even one of them out quickly, the other one would be a goner.

That's all I've got. It didn't really show all of his powers and feats, though, just talked about his lightning.

Exactly, and not many guys out there are stronger physically than Mace. Luke has won this one. Anyone have an argument?

Why doesn't it work on darksiders again Janus? The Vong weren't outside of the force, they were on another level. It's a more powerful version of force lightning so remind me why it wouldn't work..

They were on another level? I don't remember hearing that . Please explain.

He's just spewing nonsense. Don't mind him.

At this point, Luke is able to feel Vong in the Force, and IIRC, he uses the ability on Kiliks...there's no reason he should lose this. He's faster, stronger, more powerful, with far more force mastery and skill

Originally posted by Janus Marius
He's just spewing nonsense. Don't mind him.

One could say the same about all of your pointless rants on this forum. Just because they couldn't be felt in the force doesn't mean they existed outside of the force. They were on another level of the force. I believe it was either Vergere or somebody else who stated that the Jedi couldn't sense the Vong because of their perception of the force.

Originally posted by darthsith19
About Luke's "Instakill" lightning. All I know about it is didn't it kill like 7 Vong in 1 second?
It killed one. Luke did the rest with his lightsaber.

And LS, when did he use it on a Killik?

I could be wrong, but didn't he use it in the Swarm War?

And the Slayer very obviously died when Luke zapped it...it's described as toppling like a tree...nothing mentions Luke dispatching it with his saber from there

people are strange and aggresive here. its not their fault. this forum tends to bring out the worst in them. i would suggest star wars prequell for freindly discussion. queeq and general g can get quite entertaining...

Originally posted by Lightsnake
I could be wrong, but didn't he use it in the Swarm War?
I don't know; I only read a few passages from those books. That's why I was asking, as I've heard people mention it before, but no one's ever cited a direct source or posted the passage.

And the Slayer very obviously died when Luke zapped it...it's described as toppling like a tree...nothing mentions Luke dispatching it with his saber from there
That's what I said. I was pointing out to darthsith that Luke only killed one of the slayers with the lightning, and killed the rest with his lightsaber. He thought that Luke killed seven in one second with the attack, or something like that.

You'll understand if I never want to look at Dark Nest again, myself...I read it once and never read it again.

And sorry, Faunus...thought you implied that Luke killed the Slayer he hit with EL with his saber, misunderstood