nah, I prefer Sam Z, he didn't resort to circular logic nor specious reasoning (well, he didn't provide any reasoning, but that's another matter entirely).
umm, you realise you're just dressing up your opinion of Superman (as being the "greatest superhero ever"😉 as some objective fact in relation to characters in all comics everywhere.
also, you clearly haven't read any Hulk for a good few years as Hulk hasn't been a "not very rational" 'brute', for quite some time.
from around the 300s he's been meditating, he's been possessed of an intellect not far off WWH, he's been capable of (and has frequently utilised) transforming into Banner at will and vice versa.
basically you don't know what you're talking about but you do feel it passionately... have you argued with Sam Z in the past?