Thor vs Superman

Originally posted by marvelprince
Actually in terms of Supes going intangible he still would be susceptible to energy attacks (if we're applying real life physics then he's affect4ed even moreso). Its just physical attacks that he would be safe from

http://img378.imageshack.us/img378/...rmanfast3ar.jpg

Son of a monkey! 😠 Why aren't they working??? Well, in this pic, it shows Superman vibrating through Doomsday's lightning/fire breath w/o even getting scratched. Acutally, I think snoopdogg had a post of it somewhere in here...

heheh. good job debating, bd. nice to be involved in a civil discussion/debate. well done to all who took (are still taking??) part. 😉

Thats pretty cool(i'm assuming cause I can't see it) but how long can he keep something like that up?

I had said what I did before based on other heroes who go intangible yet get disrupted by energy, specifically lightning. Person like Vision, Manhunter and even Flash have been done in by electricity when they were intangible. Its simple physics really

Originally posted by leonidas
heheh. good job debating, bd. nice to be involved in a civil discussion/debate. well done to all who took (are still taking??) part. 😉

Thanks! 😄

Originally posted by marvelprince
Thats pretty cool(i'm assuming cause I can't see it) but how long can he keep something like that up?

I'll try and find snoopdogg's picture of it...

I edited my earlier post. Read up

Originally posted by snoopdogg
Are you saying this is not a feat?

Don't make me laugh.

This is on page 101 or 102. It has the pic in it if you are interested in seeing it. 😄

Originally posted by marvelprince
I edited my earlier post. Read up

Look at snoopdogg's picture. 😉 Simple physics??? When something goes intangible (which is impossible) it's definitely NOT simple physics.

I love it this has come down to debating who has the slight edge in maybe a 5.5 margin of victory that means that this has been argued very thoroughly.

lol. I meant simple application of physics. When someone goes intangible their molecular structure resembles that of a gas, and depending on the amount of free electrons, can conduct electrical charges

Originally posted by marvelprince
lol. I meant simple application of physics. When someone goes intangible their molecular structure resembles that of a gas, and depending on the amount of free electrons, can conduct electrical charges

Well, yes but how could you even fathom what their molecular structure would be since turning intangible is impossible??? It's just an educated guess really. Even if that was true, Superman must not have a large amount of free electrons in his molecular structure. Take a look at the picture that snoop posted, I'm begging you! It shows Superman turning intangible and phasing right through Doomsday's fire/lightning breath.

I saw the pic and understand that its a nice feat but im not convinced. Intangiblity is impossible, but the concept of intangiblity is not. Its like how light speed is impossible but scientists can still predict what could/will happen to an individual undergoing lightspeed travel. Look at it this way, you can move your hand through steam but if you send an electric charge through you can dissociate the water into hydrogen and oxygen(thus affecting it)

Originally posted by marvelprince
I saw the pic and understand that its a nice feat but im not convinced. Intangiblity is impossible, but the concept of intangiblity is not. Its like how light speed is impossible but scientists can still predict what could/will happen to an individual undergoing lightspeed travel. Look at it this way, you can move your hand through steam but if you send an electric charge through you can dissociate the water into hydrogen and oxygen(thus affecting it)

You seem to think that Thor could block Superman's laser vision and yet you don't think that Superman could dodge lightning which is at best half the speed of light (Superman is MANY times faster than that)?

I wasn't debating Superman's abilty to dodge either. In fact I don't recall saying that Thor will dodge Superman heat vision. All I was saying was that I don't think Superman going intangile would help him against Thor's lightning. I wasn't debating anyone's ability to dodge anything and I'm sorry if that impression you got my agrument. My bad

Originally posted by marvelprince
I wasn't debating Superman's abilty to dodge either. In fact I don't recall saying that Thor will dodge Superman heat vision. All I was saying was that I don't think Superman going intangile would help him against Thor's lightning. I wasn't debating anyone's ability to dodge anything and I'm sorry if that impression you got my agrument. My bad

I still think that the intangibility would work. He can also vibrate himself invisible too. But about the dodging thing, it was newjak that said Thor would block Superman's heat vision with his hammer thus absorbing it's power. So acutally, MY bad. 😮

Np. You made some great points. I respect your opinions. I'm out for now though

Plus, has Thor shown the kind of fighting speed Superman has? Nope.

Has he shown the kind of flying speed Superman has? HELL no. Superman flew Darkseid from earth to the sun in seconds and it takes light 8 minutes.

Has he shown the kind of strength Superman has? Nope. Superman once held a black hole in the palm of his hand. He even flew out of a double black hole which light cannot even escape.

I hate when people don't give Superman his due credit for the stuff that he's done. I'm not saying you are Marvelprince, it's just that some people have in the past on this thread. 😉

Originally posted by batdude123
I still think that the intangibility would work. He can also vibrate himself invisible too. But about the dodging thing, it was newjak that said Thor would block Superman's heat vision with his hammer thus absorbing it's power. So acutally, MY bad. 😮

Originally posted by marvelprince
Np. You made some great points. I respect your opinions. I'm out for now though

Alright, man. See ya! 🙂

Originally posted by newjak86
Yes your bad 😛
I did say but I don't know if Thor can hit SS flying right into him then his speed and relexes can't be so bad that he can't keep up with Supes somewhat.

Well, first of all, that's basically the only good reflex feat that Thor has. Second of all, SS was fighting stupid, if he was smart, he should have been weaving all around Thor. Kinda like this: http://img370.imageshack.us/img370/9203/pics0017bn.jpg