GL Hal Jordan vs Silver Surfer

Started by quanchi11281 pages

Originally posted by The Great Galen
I simply stated that if it was supes at his full potential(PC Supes,Supes 1m,AS Supes) he might have a better shot then peeps think. If its current supes i agreed Odin would win...you're the one who doesnt admit Odin was holding back on Thanos.
Yet surprisingly there is no proof to that claim.

Hmm..possibly because Odin even admitted he was fighting at his full power. He didnt see him as a thread, afterall Squirrel girl was to much for him.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Hmm..possibly because Odin even admitted he was fighting at his full power. He didnt see him as a thread, afterall Squirrel girl was to much for him.
Sg isnt canon and if you want to count it no one has beaten her. 😂

Oh and Tyrant beat him,Drax...theres lots more that r under Odins level who beasted him so we kno Odin was holding back.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Oh and Tyrant beat him,Drax...theres lots more that r under Odins level who beasted him so we kno Odin was holding back.
Tyrant is above Odin. So again you have no point.

not by much though, so Odin could have oneshotted Thanos if he wanted.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
not by much though, so Odin could have oneshotted Thanos if he wanted.
No I mean where do you get that, he oneshotted the Surfer though but Thanos was far to powerful.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
not by much though, so Odin could have oneshotted Thanos if he wanted.

Like he did surfer?
Even when he though his son was hurt/dead?
That makes perfect sense.

Odin isnt a killer, he doesnt kill for no good reason. He didnt see Thanos a threat and was toying with him, he even said so.

Originally posted by Inhuman
Like he did surfer?
Even when he though his son was hurt/dead?
That makes perfect sense.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Odin isnt a killer, he doesnt kill for no good reason. He didnt see Thanos a threat and was toying with him, he even said so.

He didnt see thanos as a threat? lol that proves you havent read the story🙂
In the end of the fight he had to be convinced that Thnaos & Surfer were not villains.
Plus he kept calling Thanos villain over and over.
But you would have known that if you read the story.

Originally posted by Inhuman
He didnt see thanos as a threat? lol that proves you havent read the story🙂
In the end of the fight he had to be convinced that Thnaos & Surfer were not villains.
Plus he kept calling Thanos villain over and over.
But you would have known that if you read the story.
Its obvious the Great Galen will say things over and over again even when he knows hes wrong.

Originally posted by Inhuman
Like he did surfer?
Even when he though his son was hurt/dead?
That makes perfect sense.

You obviously didn't read the comic.

Odin was the one who wanted to solve it by killing Thor...

Originally posted by llagrok
You obviously didn't read the comic.

Odin was the one who wanted to solve it by killing Thor...

Post it.

Plus i doubt that you believe that odin was going easy on surfer and thanos in that fight. Like "Odin could have 1 shoted thanos"
If this is the case then, I would like to know why🙂
Which is why this is being discussed in the first place.

Originally posted by Inhuman
Post it.

Plus i doubt that you believe that odin was going easy on surfer and thanos in that fight. Like "Odin could have 1 shoted thanos"
If this is the case then, I would like to know why🙂
Which is why this is being discussed in the first place.

You didn't read the comic then.

Odin asked if Thanos gave up? If you're trying to kill some someone, do you pause and ask if they give up?

Originally posted by llagrok
You didn't read the comic then.

Odin asked if Thanos gave up? If you're trying to kill some someone, do you pause and ask if they give up?

Actually my interpretation of "Do you yield villain"
Was Odin realizing that he couldn't put thanos down even after hitting him with practically all hes got. Even getting gungir out, blasting thanos with it. Thanos absorbing the second blast and taking it while walking towards odin, and eventually getting a hold of it.
After all that, Odin was surprised than thanos was still standing. He even commented that he had not been in battle of this caliber in ages. But since you know the comic so well you should know this.
One thing I do agree is that if they fought for a longer time, eventually thanos would fall. But Odin would have to be hitting him full power like he was previously.
I don't agree how some interpreted that fight though. Didn't see Odin taking it easy one bit.
To each his own barker

Which is ridiculous.

Odin had been killed a couple of years earlier.

Thanos >> Surtur?

Originally posted by llagrok
Which is ridiculous.
Odin had been killed a couple of years earlier.
Thanos >> Surtur?

Aperantly according to Odin ermhappy

LMAO, of course Odin was taking it easy...there is no reason he couldt have oneshotted Thanos aside from lame writing.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
LMAO, of course Odin was taking it easy...there is no reason he couldt have oneshotted Thanos aside from lame writing.

The only thing that supports your view is fan speculation. Shitty-writing doesn't make it any less canon.