Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Yeah that be good.Yeah I thought the Rorschach stuff was great. I thought it was other bits like the squid etc that were the source of most dissatisfaction.
Roschach was quite good indeed, certainly worth a movie on its own. But on the whole, it all felt a little unbalanced and, prolly not the right word, uninspired. Snyder had the tendency to copy a lot of book one on one... and not really let his director's eye (if he has one) discern what this was about. Some scenes worked wonderfully, others felt out of place, and the missing squid was no gripe for me frankly. I could easily have turned out as quite ridiculous (but maybe that was the point, hehehe). And I definately hated his choice of music: cheesy, unimaginative, crude and easy. Now, those were things the graphic novel certainly was not.