Originally posted by quanchi112You're reasonable, so I know you think Odin wins. There has been no comparison between Odin and Galan until just now from your post. But they would both beat Thanos.
No, Odin loses and what Galactus can do to thanos isn't relevant to Odin since he's a lot less powerful.
Originally posted by MindsetI'm very reasonable I am glad you picked up on this. I wish you would be reasonable and agree Thanos wins. You do that and I will let you walk away with no mental scars. How does that sound ?
You're reasonable, so I know you think Odin wins. There has been no comparison between Odin and Galan until just now from your post. But they would both beat Thanos.
Originally posted by quanchi112You don't have to be greater than Galactus to wear down Thanos' shields. DP Tyrant did it. Heck, PG Champion was on the cusp of doing it. PG Thor did it. PG Champion and PG Thor were less powerful than Odin.
He drains too much energy and needs to nap unless you claim Odin is greater than galactus. You've gone this far why not just keep going.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0This is kmc where they fight at their best. So you wanting to ignore his best shields is typical of you.
^ Your puerile reasoning fails in the face of DP Tyrant, PG Champion and PG Thor wrecking Thanos' shields. None of those three are near the power of well-fed Galactus. Time to face reality. Particularly when Odin did the same in their on-panel fight.
^ There is nothing to ignore. You have presented no evidence that Thanos didn't use his best shields against DP Tyrant, Odin, PG Champion or PG Thor. This is a failure of argumentation on your part.
Holding out your utter lack of evidence in your hands and trying to pretend that I have to make your argument for you is an ignorant form of debating.
DP Tyrant, PG Champion and PG Thor wrecked Thanos' shields. So did Odin. Pointing out Galactus changes nothing.
Originally posted by OneDumbG0So you're saying those shields equaled the shield he used against Galactus ? Really ?
^ There is nothing to ignore. You have presented no evidence that Thanos didn't use his best shields against DP Tyrant, Odin, PG Champion or PG Thor. This is a failure of argumentation on your part.Holding out your utter lack of evidence in your hands and trying to pretend that I have to make your argument for you is an ignorant form of debating.
DP Tyrant, PG Champion and PG Thor wrecked Thanos' shields. So did Odin. Pointing out Galactus changes nothing.
When did Thanos use a shield against Odin. When did Tyrant also ?
Pg can wreck through any shield also as it has infinite energy. Hahaha. Thanos didn't use his best shield against power gem Thor but anyways it's pg and has no limits unlike Galactus.
Originally posted by quanchi112You are saying that they were different. With no evidence. There is no counter-argument necessary to make when you've not made an argument. Insisting that there's a difference does not prove there's a difference. I've pointed out several examples that counter your assertion that only a well-fed Galactus could wreck Thanos' shelds. You can try to prove otherwise with evidence.
So you're saying those shields equaled the shield he used against Galactus ? Really ?When did Thanos use a shield against Odin. When did Tyrant also ?
You haven't proven that Thanos purposefully suspended all shielding. Thanos wouldn't get slapped around if he could help it. He obviously used shields. This argument has already played itself out: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=525557&pagenumber=15
Originally posted by quanchi112Not every blow swung by a PG wielder is backed by infinite energy. Don't be foolish with your use of false absolutes. You're becoming exceedingly reckless with your use of them. We already know Odin was more powerful than PG Thor. And PG Thor shattered Thanos' shields. As PG Champion was on the verge of doing. As DP Tyrant and Odin did when they tooled Thanos whose shielding meant nothing.
Pg can wreck through any shield also as it has infinite energy. Hahaha. Thanos didn't use his best shield against power gem Thor but anyways it's pg and has no limits unlike Galactus.
You've once again provided no evidence that Thanos used sub-par shielding or did not use shielding at all. Trying to draw me into making your own arguments for you or have me prove a negative hasn't changed the merits of either of our argumentative postures. Your's simply doesn't have any merit here.
Re: Odin vs. Thanos
Originally posted by Black bolt z
I want to get this settled once and for all.Odin is 182 after odin sleep and is at half power.
If there are any threads that need to be merged with this(I don't think there are I checked)please do that.
1:Thanos with no prep
2:Thanos with 5 days prep.Fight in neutral territory
odin 10/10 in both. This is spite thread
Originally posted by OneDumbG0So are you saying all his shields are similar and denying his best shields for the purposes of debating ?
You are saying that they were different. With no evidence. There is no counter-argument necessary to make when you've not made an argument. Insisting that there's a difference does not prove there's a difference. I've pointed out several examples that counter your assertion that only a well-fed Galactus could wreck Thanos' shelds. You can try to prove otherwise with evidence.You haven't proven that Thanos purposefully suspended all shielding. Thanos wouldn't get slapped around if he could help it. He obviously used shields. This argument has already played itself out: http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=525557&pagenumber=15 Not every blow swung by a PG wielder is backed by infinite energy. Don't be foolish with your use of false absolutes. You're becoming exceedingly reckless with your use of them. We already know Odin was more powerful than PG Thor. And PG Thor shattered Thanos' shields. As PG Champion was on the verge of doing. As DP Tyrant and Odin did when they tooled Thanos whose shielding meant nothing.
You've once again provided no evidence that Thanos used sub-par shielding or did not use shielding at all. Trying to draw me into making your own arguments for you or have me prove a negative hasn't changed the merits of either of our argumentative postures. Your's simply doesn't have any merit here.
I never stated it was but unlike Galactus there's no limit and it can keep tapping into it and eventually the forcefield goes down whereas Galactus had to tax himself to do so.
I don't have to it's easy to see you are saying all shields are created equal despite common sense slapping you right between the eyes.