Will Heath Ledger's Joker top Jack Nicholson's?

Started by Neo Darkhalen7 pages

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
Jack Nicholson's Joker look more evil. Whereas Ledger's looks more psychopath.

Wait till the movie and then we really compare.

great idea.

People hate Batman '89 yet it was the movie that, i think, influenced "Batman: The Animated Series" a.k.a. the best batman series in both the live action and cartoon field, ever. Hell, even the cartoon's theme song used the Batman '89 theme/ending song. The cartoon also has the Tim Burton look and feel to it too.

The Dark Knight will be up against some comp. to me..

Hell, "Batman Begins" (which is playing right now on F/X) took the "I'm Batman" from Batman '89 with the way it went.

With the fearful bad guy asking who or what is he then he goes "I'm Batman" while he has the villain by the collor.

Batman: TAS is the best superhero animated series....just thought I'd throw that out there. As for B('89), I don't really see a lot of hate for it now adays. The movie was pretty good so I don't see how people could hate it anyway.

I don't know how it will be yet for Heath's I will have to experience it first. I have to say that so far mostly because of his appearance and a couple minor things I haven't associated the new Joker as THE JOKER yet in my mind. That's based on the Joker I am used to seeing though through out the years.

I didn't see Batman 1989 till after I saw the animated series growing up and I had no problem reconciling Jack Nicholson as the Joker probably because the animated series one was sort of based after him. He fit to me. He was funny, and yet sadistic and he scared me...and at the same time I found myself rooting for him, even though I wanted Batman to win. His best moments in my mind

1) The mirror scene...I think that is one of the great scenes in 80s cinema PERIOD. Him slamming that mirror down, sobbing and then bursting into that maniacal laughter, smashing that light bulb and lurking up the stairs howling in laughter in the dark...if ever there was a moment that I think perfectly capture the Joker's insanity it was that.

2) Storming the mob meeting and then disposing of Antoine the way he did. And joking with his corpse. Classic.

3) Killing Vinny with the poison tipped feather and quipping about the pen being mightier than the sword with the mimes. That scene always creeped me out as a kid.

4) "I'm melting!" "Boo!"

5) His annoyance with Batman stealing the spotlight from him in general was so completely Joker.

6) The commercial for Smilex was crazy good. "Love that Joker!"

7) The parade scene "go with a smile"

9) "You IDIOT! You made me. Remember, you dropped me into that vat of chemicals. That wasn't easy to get over, and don't think that I didn't try!"

10) Him trying to stomp Batman off the top of the cathedral.

The only things in the movie that I felt were more Jack than the Joker was the bird dance maybe and the phantom of the opera ending but to me not distractingly so. I think what I like so much about the Batman 1989 Joker and the Animated series Joker is they had fun while killing people and causing mayhem. You could see the sheer delight and enjoyment that the characters got for upsetting Batman's world.

The new Joker seems to be more dark and brooding and less like he will be enjoying himself much. But I will have to wait and see. I'm expecting a completely different kind of performance. I don't expect one to be better than the other, contrary to that I expect them to be incomparable because they will be so different.

Will Heath Ledger's Joker top Jack Nicholson's?

How the **** are we supposed to know???????

I hope Heath's Joker's not too serious. Like he seemed angry in one part where he said "C'mon, hit me!". That part, although sick looking, isn't very Joker-like.

In the comics, every other sentence the Joker says is a sarcastic poetry. Even when he's mad he still fools around but'll still kill you..hehe.

Heath's Joker should be hysterically delirious but in an insane way. The way the comics did it. The way Jack Nich did it in Batman '89.

Yeah so far I haven't seen the Joker say anything particularly funny in the released stuff. Hopefully he gets some jokes off.

Even this semi amateur Joker is somewhat funny, lol
http://youtube.com/watch?v=szAp6gleJd4

Let's do some pics:

Jack

Heath

Notice that Jack's eyes are so sinister looking. Whereas Heath eyes are more manical.

Truth be told....even my nightmares are disturbed by both.

Jack's Joker should lend Heath's Joker the number to his stylist and put him in a chemical bath so his make up doesn't run like that.

Jackie

Heathy

Originally posted by SelinaAndBruce
I don't know how it will be yet for Heath's I will have to experience it first. I have to say that so far mostly because of his appearance and a couple minor things I haven't associated the new Joker as THE JOKER yet in my mind. That's based on the Joker I am used to seeing though through out the years.

I didn't see Batman 1989 till after I saw the animated series growing up and I had no problem reconciling Jack Nicholson as the Joker probably because the animated series one was sort of based after him. He fit to me. He was funny, and yet sadistic and he scared me...and at the same time I found myself rooting for him, even though I wanted Batman to win. His best moments in my mind

1) The mirror scene...I think that is one of the great scenes in 80s cinema PERIOD. Him slamming that mirror down, sobbing and then bursting into that maniacal laughter, smashing that light bulb and lurking up the stairs howling in laughter in the dark...if ever there was a moment that I think perfectly capture the Joker's insanity it was that.

2) Storming the mob meeting and then disposing of Antoine the way he did. And joking with his corpse. Classic.

3) Killing Vinny with the poison tipped feather and quipping about the pen being mightier than the sword with the mimes. That scene always creeped me out as a kid.

4) "I'm melting!" "Boo!"

5) His annoyance with Batman stealing the spotlight from him in general was so completely Joker.

6) The commercial for Smilex was crazy good. "Love that Joker!"

7) The parade scene "go with a smile"

9) "You IDIOT! You made me. Remember, you dropped me into that vat of chemicals. That wasn't easy to get over, and don't think that I didn't try!"

10) Him trying to stomp Batman off the top of the cathedral.

The only things in the movie that I felt were more Jack than the Joker was the bird dance maybe and the phantom of the opera ending but to me not distractingly so. I think what I like so much about the Batman 1989 Joker and the Animated series Joker is they had fun while killing people and causing mayhem. You could see the sheer delight and enjoyment that the characters got for upsetting Batman's world.

The new Joker seems to be more dark and brooding and less like he will be enjoying himself much. But I will have to wait and see. I'm expecting a completely different kind of performance. I don't expect one to be better than the other, contrary to that I expect them to be incomparable because they will be so different.

How about an issue of the comic book? Did you ever read the comic book? How about graphic novels and anthologies of the character? Did you ever see those?

Originally posted by SelinaAndBruce
Jackie

Heathy

Both look incredibly creepy but in the long run I'd choose Heath Ledger's Joker's look because it looks more gritty.

God, I want to vomit when I see Jack's half-ass joke of The Joker...truly ridiculous.

Originally posted by Il.Mozalini
God, I want to vomit when I see Jack's half-ass joke of The Joker...truly ridiculous.

Half ass? LMAO his Joker at least has the decency to have on full make up and his hair combed 😆

Originally posted by Devil King
How about an issue of the comic book? Did you ever read the comic book? How about graphic novels and anthologies of the character? Did you ever see those?

Yes I've read Batman comics including the Killing Joke and I still think Heath's Joker looks like crap and I am sure there are other people who like the Joker and have been exposed to him in all mediums who feel the same way as well 😉

Originally posted by SelinaAndBruce
Half ass? LMAO his Joker at least has the decency to have on full make up and his hair combed 😆

Sorry if I wasn't clear enough, I meant his acting. Seeing his ugly mug reminds of his half-ass acting.

Ah, well I thought his acting was pretty good but different strokes I guess 😄

No. Jack's Joker will likely never be topped

But they both have two completely different approaches to the character. Like everything that has been said above, Jack took more of a sinisterly jestful path while Heath takes it more artfully and tries the sadistic, disturbing, almost feral approach.