X-Men vs. Super Skrull

Started by Boy Blue4 pages

Originally posted by darthgoober
Do you have an example of Scott acting with such reckless abandon without concern for passing aircraft/orbital satellites/ect.?
Scott's blast range is tied into power. The more powerful the blast, the further it goes... and I'm almost positive that Scott's blasts, unless at full power, won't penetrate the atmosphere.

Originally posted by darthgoober
I didn’t answer the question because I wasn’t talking about focused blast. Why does he need to sharp shoot when he can use a large blast like this and fry them all at once...
http://img133.imageshack.us/img133/4554/img008me0.jpg
Because that blast can still be dodged, and NC, Beast and Wolverine all have the feats. Colossus is very fast too, but he's also durable enough to just wade through it.

Originally posted by darthgoober
You’re assuming that the X-Men are going to be moving first and Skrull’s just going to deal with everything as it happens but why would he?
I'm assuming that Scott's gonna beat him to the quickdraw and that Nightcrawler, Colossus, Beast and Wolverine can provide ample follow up.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Skrull’s shield are stronger than IW’s and always have been. I can understand his being barred from feats indicating the range of the FF’s powers because they train with them more so they’ve likely thought of uses that he hasn’t. But when it comes to the magnitude of their powers, anything the FF can do the SS can do because have the enhanced powers of the FF has been his staple from day one.
His shields were stronger at the beginning of his creation, but since then the f4 have grown a LOT more powerful, and no indication that Skrull recieved the same power ups.

Thing went from a Class 5 to a Class 100...

Also, Invisible Woman can concentrate to make her shields more powerful. She always has. Skrull doesn't do the same thing, so he won't be putting out nearly as powerful shields.

Originally posted by darthgoober
And your scenario assumes that SS’s going to stand there and let all this happen The guy has a speed advantage over everybody on the field so the X-Men are going to have to react to him, not vice versa.
Speed advantage? Lolwut?

Originally posted by darthgoober
Super Skrull isn’t a “normal” person though.
What shows that he's got advanced enough reaction times to deal with Nightcrawler?

Originally posted by darthgoober
No PIS is an instance of someone “forgetting” powers that they’ve already shown it to be “in character” for them to use such as Supes not using super speed in a fight.. CIS is limitations that a character imposes on themselves such as Warlock’s reluctance to use the Soul Suck technique. If it’s been established that things like invisibility are “in character” for SS to use via his actually using them they’re fair game. See the frequency of their use is determined by the story the writer wants to tell(and is thus Plot Induced) so if he‘s not using them it qualifies as PIS. You might make a case for the things that we’ve NEVER seen from him(like Torch’s omni directional blast or force bubbles in the brain) qualifying as CIS, but if he’s used it before it falls under the PIS category. That’s why we say that Supes blitzes 10/10 despite the fact that it’s rarely seen in comparison to Supes’s overall appearances.
Super Skrull's personality altered for the purpose of Annihilation... he became much more bloodthirsty and generally more of a brawler.

This is why it was never shown on panel, that he would access his invisibility... because it wasn't in character. He wanted to use all of his powers that hurt and caused pain, and that were major shows of force... when he was deciding to kill traitor responsible for the death of his son, he didn't do fancy stuff with bubbles in brains.

He ripped the limbs off and used Torch's flame to cauterize the wounds.

Whether he used to be different or not, invisibility is not within his character to immediately access as you're insisting. Especially from the get-go, and then flying into the air, so that the smoke and flame from Torch allows him to be traced anyways.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Don’t blame me because I don’t agree with that particular policy as it leads to entirely too many 10/10 shutouts that we’d NEVER see in comics, but that’s the way things stand until the forum rules are revamped. Feel free to bump this then and see how my opinion changes.
If Superman didn't blitz his enemy because he wanted to brawl so that they'd have prolonged suffering, and yet we awarded him 10/10 speedblitz wins anyways, you'd have a point.

Otherwise, in a case like this, it's not the same situation at all.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Oh I was just talking about intensity, I have to problem admitting that SS isn’t likely to use the actual “Going Nova” technique.
Then he won't tag any of the X-Men.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Based on what? I know Surfer was holding back(he always was back then), but how do you see that as being any different than anyone else who fought him during that time period?
Because Surfer was knocked off of his board, was hit by a blast of flame, and didn't destroy the Skrull in one shot.

Originally posted by darthgoober
I’m not being realistic? SS takes shots from guys like Thor and Surfer and takes on entire battalions of alien warships and you think that Colossus or Cyclops are going to be able to put him down if he does anything other than just stand there and let them?
Yes.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Skrull has superior speed and reflexes to everyone on the opposing team and will therefore be acting first in this fight. A single wide area blast will fry most of the team and any but Nightcrawler are easily contained via FF bubble(Scott or Peter could probably break out eventually, but it would take a bit) and all but Wolverine(and possibly Beast) are all but helpless against invisibility.

Superior speed and reflexes? To Wolverine and Nightcrawler? Scans plz.

And I didn't see anything from him that was a particularly wide area blast... nothing that NC, Beast and Wolverine can't dodge.

Also, as you pointed out, they start .5 KM away... how is he going to make a wide blast that far out?

Originally posted by darthgoober
Reed’s powers have proven resistant to Wolverines claws a couple of times now.
But not Skrull's.

Reed's durability needs to be actively controlled.

Originally posted by darthgoober
Why would he focus on using one power to the Max when the combination is more effective?
I'm not talking about using one power to the max... I'm talking about doing more than making his fists glowy and rocky.

Also, lolz at you posting this scan...

http://img133.imageshack.us/img133/4554/img008me0.jpg

Which proves that he doesn't always guard his back, as he was tagged by a low soldier, when these are the friggin X-Men.

Team takes it.

Superskrull One Shots them all. They can't even beat Apoc in a five on one. And SS is seriously at the same level of overall power.

Super Skrull.

Originally posted by fangirl101
IW could beat this team you named by herself. Skrull has her powers, things, reeds, and johnny's, plus HIS OWN. He's High herald level seriously.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Superskrull One Shots them all. They can't even beat Apoc in a five on one. And SS is seriously at the same level of overall power.

haha....nice fail pic

I just noticed Smurph changed his username, again. It's funny, I didn't read his posts because I thought he was the EonBlue (or something like that) guy.

🙁

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Scott's blast range is tied into power. The more powerful the blast, the further it goes... and I'm almost positive that Scott's blasts, unless at full power, won't penetrate the atmosphere.

That makes sense, but when has Scott ever let loose with a wide angle blast into the atmosphere like you‘re suggesting he‘ll do? The way you’re asking for specific examples for SS, I think it’s only fair for the opposition as well.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Because that blast can still be dodged, and NC, Beast and Wolverine all have the feats. Colossus is very fast too, but he's also durable enough to just wade through it.

Right on all counts, but Cyclops DOESN’T and even though Beast, Wolverine, and Nightcrawer could use agility to evade the blast at a distance, I don’t see them doing it when they get within 10 feat or so. And with Cyke gone they loose they’re biggest gun and their teams best tactician.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
I'm assuming that Scott's gonna beat him to the quickdraw and that Nightcrawler, Colossus, Beast and Wolverine can provide ample follow up.

But why?

Originally posted by Boy Blue
His shields were stronger at the beginning of his creation, but since then the f4 have grown a LOT more powerful, and no indication that Skrull recieved the same power ups.

Thing went from a Class 5 to a Class 100...

Also, Invisible Woman can concentrate to make her shields more powerful. She always has. Skrull doesn't do the same thing, so he won't be putting out nearly as powerful shields.

His powers have pretty much ALWAYS been stated as being “the augmented powers of the Fantastic Four”(and the augmentation in question was established right of as enhanced). You might make a case for the more recent appearances if no such thing is being said currently, but I know for a fact that they were still being labeled as such up through the Infinity Crusade, and the Gamma Bomb instance happened during the Infinity War.

And Sue didn’t go through any concentration trials to do it, she had about a seconds notice between the time she noticed the bomb and it blew.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Speed advantage? Lolwut?

What shows that he's got advanced enough reaction times to deal with Nightcrawler?

I think these should amply demonstrate it…

Blocks a blast from Surfer with force field…
http://img159.imageshack.us/img159/4930/silversurfer198902509jx5.jpg

Avoids a bulrush from Surfer with Reed‘s powers(Surfer catches him with the second one but Skrull didn’t realize Surfer could see him)…
http://img177.imageshack.us/img177/8264/silversurfer198902508gh6.jpg

Blocks Surfer’s board with Reed‘s powers(this is from a different fight)…
http://img177.imageshack.us/img177/9140/silversurferannual0112oh2.jpg

Dodges a blast from Surfer with Reed‘s powers(from yet ANOTHER fight, and in this one Surfer WASN’T holding back)…
http://img70.imageshack.us/img70/7110/silversurferv3105p17ec7.jpg

Dodges Thor’s hammer with Reed‘s powers…
http://img46.imageshack.us/img46/4149/thor46513gh5.jpg

Blocking lasers with force field
http://img133.imageshack.us/img133/5509/img013zv6.jpg

Blocking/Dodging lasers…
http://img133.imageshack.us/img133/5509/img013zv6.jpg

Dealing with an opponent who’s sneaking up on him(shows how quickly he can call up his powers since the guy was mid leap)…
http://img402.imageshack.us/img402/6307/img022bd3.jpg

Flying circles around Human Torch…
http://img137.imageshack.us/img137/3446/fantasticfour1810dz3.jpg

Dodges a blast from Torch(also shows off some Pyrokinetic ability)…
http://img261.imageshack.us/img261/6180/fantasticfour1811uw2.jpg

Grabs a boulder from a far off bank to block a shot from Mr. Fantastic…
http://img443.imageshack.us/img443/5145/fantasticfour1813wa6.jpg

Dodges one blast from a fake Human Torch using Reed’s powers and then blocks the next using IW’s force field…
http://img117.imageshack.us/img117/6154/fantasticfourv303715jb8.jpg

Dodges a bull rush and multiple blast from a fake Torch in the same panel using Reed’s powers…
http://img117.imageshack.us/img117/7005/fantasticfourv303716jd8.jpg

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Super Skrull's personality altered for the purpose of Annihilation... he became much more bloodthirsty and generally more of a brawler.

This is why it was never shown on panel, that he would access his invisibility... because it wasn't [b]in character. He wanted to use all of his powers that hurt and caused pain, and that were major shows of force... when he was deciding to kill traitor responsible for the death of his son, he didn't do fancy stuff with bubbles in brains.

He ripped the limbs off and used Torch's flame to cauterize the wounds.

Whether he used to be different or not, invisibility is not within his character to immediately access as you're insisting. Especially from the get-go, and then flying into the air, so that the smoke and flame from Torch allows him to be traced anyways.[/B]

Now you’re relying on supposition to explain why SS fought the way he did but that doesn’t really hold up. Unless it was actually established that his prior techniques are “out of character” for him to use now there’s nothing to actually suggest that they are other than their lack of appearance. SS’s ALWAYS been a bloodthirsty brawler so that excuse doesn’t hold up when the only real evidence of a change in character is a lack of his using his abilities to the extent that he’s previously shown. But you know what, that's pretty much the definition of PIS...

“No Mentioning Events of PIS
Plot Induced Stupidity, or PIS, is when characters don't use their abilities or skills to the fullest extent as shown before, even within their personality ranges, for the sake of the story plotline. It makes lesser powered characters an actual challenge against higher powered characters in the comics. Examples of PIS include Flash stories lasting longer than three panels, or Toy Man as a threat to Superman."

The same logic you're using could be used to say that if Supes goes for 5 or 10 issues or so without a speed blitz(which has happened) it must mean that he’s developed a distaste for the technique so it's no longer "in character" for him to use it.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
If Superman didn't blitz his enemy because he wanted to brawl so that they'd have prolonged suffering, and yet we awarded him 10/10 speedblitz wins anyways, you'd have a point.

Otherwise, in a case like this, it's not the same situation at all.


If you can think of any kind of statement or other indication from SS that indicates some kind of displeasure or aversion to using things like his invisibility YOU would have a point. But right now all the only case you can make is based on a lack of evidence to the contrary and that’s not much different than asking for proof of a negative.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Then he won't tag any of the X-Men.

What makes you think that? You keep on looking to the worst examples and feats for SS, but if we do that then we have to look to the worst examples and feats from the opposition and they’ve all been tagged plenty.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Because Surfer was knocked off of his board, was hit by a blast of flame, and didn't destroy the Skrull in one shot.

How is Surfer not one shotting someone who’s taken on FF and Thor a bad showing? What in Skrull’s history indicates that he SHOULD be one shotted by Surfer?

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Superior speed and reflexes? To Wolverine and Nightcrawler? Scans plz.

Already did.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
And I didn't see anything from him that was a particularly wide area blast... nothing that NC, Beast and Wolverine can't dodge.

You know you keep on asking for feats and scans for SS, where are the scans to support the team?

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Also, as you pointed out, they start .5 KM away... how is he going to make a wide blast that far out?

Because Torch has had that level of power output for a while now and Skrull’s his superior.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
But not Skrull's.

Then again they haven’t fought have they?

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Reed's durability needs to be actively controlled.

And Skrull can do that.

Originally posted by Boy Blue
I'm not talking about using one power to the max... I'm talking about doing more than making his fists glowy and rocky.

What are you looking for exactly?

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Also, lolz at you posting this scan...

http://img133.imageshack.us/img133/4554/img008me0.jpg

Which proves that he doesn't always guard his back, as he was tagged by a low soldier, when these are the friggin X-Men.


How many characters can you think of that HAVEN'T been tagged from behind?

Originally posted by Boy Blue
Team takes it.

Nope.