Joker vs Joker

Okay, this is a fight where both of these guys are going at it with fists, not any sort of weapons.

Jack's Joker

VS

Heath's Joker

Who wins?

Jack's Joker. Can't underestimate old man strength 😄

depends which 'type' of joker you prefer. if you like a more zany/funny rendition of 'ol bleach face, then you'd probably like jack's rendition of the character more. if you like a more psychotic/frightening feel [how joker should be, imo] then heath is probably you're man.

in a fight though, jack would have beaten the shit out of heath.

Heath's Joker. He wasn't afraid to get physical. Jack's Joker was.

Jack's Joker didn't even actually fight Batman, Heath's did, and took a pounding & keep laughing. Not only does Heath's Joker not really respond to pain, but he also is a fighter when he needs to be. Jack's Joker was awesome, but fighting wise is a pussy.

Heath's Joker. He managed to outfight that cop that was about to beat him up. and who can forget the magic trick that has to require some strength.

Yeah, that pencil went deep into that guy's face. Oh & not to mention that he delivered some major stomps to Batman. When Jack punched Batman he hurt his own self.

In the interrogation room that cop approached him and the next thing we know Heath had him held as hostage. He beat him! Heath wasn't afraid to get physical with Batman and took quite a beating in the interrogation room.

Yes, he even seemed to thrive off pain & none of it really fazed him. Also, another thing to notice is Heath's Joker wasn't afraid of death, whereas Jack's Joker actually was.

Originally posted by Superherovandal
Heath's Joker. He managed to outfight that cop that was about to beat him up. and who can forget the magic trick that has to require some strength.

Keaton's Batman BatKick's the crazy out of them both! 😎

Jack is the definitive Joker, imo. vulnerable physically, but mentally on a whole other plane of existence... twisted and theatrical, but also outright cowardly at times - goofishness as much as menace.

ledger's joker for sure. besides all the points mentioned already...didn't you see how savagely he was beating batman with that steel pipe? the man is relentless...ledger's joker has no limits, nicholson's does.

Originally posted by janus77
Keaton's Batman BatKick's the crazy out of them both! 😎

Jack is the definitive Joker, imo. vulnerable physically, but mentally on a whole other plane of existence... twisted and theatrical, but also outright cowardly at times - goofishness as much as menace.

Truthfully, Ledger's Joker is closer to the original Batman comics, a Joker who regularly beat the shit out of Batman. 😉 The Joker should not be a coward, he should be some sort of fighter. That's what I like about this Joker, he cracks skulls.

nickolson for the win. i saw both movies and jack still did it better, darknight was a good comic movie and all but kind of a joker wankfest.

oh and....maggie gyllenhaal is ugly as sin. 😐

Heath delved into the role more than Jack. Hell, I love Jack, grew up loving him, but most of the time now Jack is just being Jack. Heath really gave the role his all & as much as I love both Joker's, Jack's ain't touching Heath's performance wise or in a fight.

First of all, Heath's Joker IMO was much better, a vicious psychotic killer, which is what Joker should be.

As for the fight, Heath's Joker was shown to be physically in good form, physically taking a cop hostage who was trying to kick his ass, making that pencil "disappear" lol and even beating the shit outta Batman with pipes. Heath wins the fight.

In a curbstomp, nonetheless. He took hits from Batman & kept laughing, while Jack's Joker wanted to avoid as much pain as possible.

No matter what I can't bring myself to say Ledger beats Nicholson. noway

ok, the pencil feat showed that Ledger Joker has some serious reflexes and strength

he also demonstrated tremendous pain tolerance

I'm not familiar with the Nicholson Joker but what physical feats did he have, if any?

None.