Qui-Gon vs Revan

Started by truejedi4 pages

i'd like to point out again that Malek is also an unknown as we don't know one other opponent that he had fought.

Originally posted by truejedi
i'd like to point out again that Malek is also an unknown as we don't know one other opponent that he had fought. Perhaps his ability to block blaster fire was 0. how could you prove otherwise?

Right; I'm sure the second most powerful being in a dark side organization of hundreds can't even block a blaster bolt. Besides, it's not like we have "Alek" in the KotOR comics fighting numerous times against Mandalorians.

There's caution, and then there's utter stupidity.

Its not bad to err on ther side of caution, but TJ, that's stupidity.

Yeah, ever since the QGJ avatar went, things just haven't been the same...

What do you mean by that?

Originally posted by truejedi
i'd like to point out again that Malek is also an unknown as we don't know one other opponent that he had fought.

Malak also fought and easily defeated Bastilla Shan, who was also a promising Jedi and surely an above average individual in terms of power.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
Malak also fought and easily defeated Bastilla Shan, who was also a promising Jedi and surely an above average individual in terms of power.

Still flittering about with clunky wordplay? No offense, but you remind me of a malfunctioning robot. There's no calm smoothness to your posts. I can only equate it to the sounds of a constipated nerd.

Revan wins via Force.

Originally posted by Gideon
Still flittering about with clunky wordplay? No offense, but you remind me of a malfunctioning robot. There's no calm smoothness to your posts. I can only equate it to the sounds of a constipated nerd.

And you still have a habit of passing unnecessary and silly remarks. If you have a problem with my opinions, than avoid commenting on them. What I said above is true, whether you like it or not.

truejedi asked that what other notable Jedi did Malak faced besides Revan and I mentioned one.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
And you still have a habit of passing unnecessary and silly remarks. If you have a problem with my opinions, than avoid commenting on them. What I said above is true, whether you like it or not.

[b]truejedi asked that what other notable Jedi did Malak faced besides Revan and I mentioned one. [/B]

Didn't say I disagree, did I? Merely commenting that your choice of words aren't very... pleasing.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
And you still have a habit of passing unnecessary and silly remarks. If you have a problem with my opinions, than avoid commenting on them. What I said above is true, whether you like it or not.

[b]truejedi asked that what other notable Jedi did Malak faced besides Revan and I mentioned one. [/B]

Commenting on other's remarks makes up half the fun around here.

If it's justified, that is.

Originally posted by Gideon
Didn't say I disagree, did I? Merely commenting that your choice of words aren't very... pleasing.

His location says Asia...

Once again revans a he. I'd like to know though, why do you like to refer to revan as a she?

The reason is twofold (is that a paradox?): Firstly I have referred to Revan as a she in real life so many times that it has basically just become instinct, like muscle-memory. I can't help myself from initially typing that s. the other reason is that I have a pathological problem with conforming. As in I don't. I was pretty much ostracised as a child and now absolutely HATE anything resembling whats considered 'normal' or 'cool'. You pushing it only exaserbated the issue.
BTW, this could also be why I like to side with Nebaris, its uncool.

Does that answer your question?

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
Malak also fought and easily defeated Bastilla Shan, who was also a promising Jedi and surely an above average individual in terms of power.

Yea Gideon don't forget that Bastilla has shown herself to be an uber combat and really good at killing worthless no name dark jedi. We also can't forget that her gift of B.M. makes her great at one on one combat especially before she turns Sith. 😛

Ahem...Qui Gon Jinn only lost to Maul because he was an OLDER jedi fighting a MUCH younger Sith Lord that was useing a Highly aggressive saber style that Countered Qui Gon's now if Qui Gon was like 13 years younger he would have won. or maby even 5 years younger

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
Yea Gideon don't forget that Bastilla has shown herself to be an uber combat and really good at killing worthless no name dark jedi. We also can't forget that her gift of B.M. makes her great at one on one combat especially before she turns Sith. 😛

Thank you! i don't understand why this is so hard to understand. I'm obviously NOT putting Malak's ability at 0, i'm NOT saying Revan was the worst combatant, i'm saying, THERE IS NO WAY TO PROVE they are better in combat than Qui Gonn, because you only see them fight each other, and SW Legend, we DON'T SEE malak defeat Bastilla. They run off into another room, and a door closes. Maybe he caught her in a grey shield. You can't prove he didn't.
To act like i'm claiming Revan and Malak are combat non-factors is a blatant disregard for what i'm actually posting, which is, there is no way to prove how much of a factor they are. No one in their right minds actually believes that ability is 0, but they can't prove its any certain level, everything they accomplish is too firmly rooted in game-play.

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
The reason is twofold (is that a paradox?): Firstly I have referred to Revan as a she in real life so many times that it has basically just become instinct, like muscle-memory. I can't help myself from initially typing that s. the other reason is that I have a pathological problem with conforming. As in I don't. I was pretty much ostracised as a child and now absolutely HATE anything resembling whats considered 'normal' or 'cool'. You pushing it only exaserbated the issue.
BTW, this could also be why I like to side with Nebaris, its uncool.

Does that answer your question?

See, nonconformity for the sake of being a nonconformist is weird. And stupid.

If you're trying to be an eccentric, stop trying. They're just not like other people, and they don't give a shit. They don't make an active effort to be completely different just because they can be.

Originally posted by Faunus
See, nonconformity for the sake of being a nonconformist is weird. And stupid.

If you're trying to be an eccentric, stop trying. They're just not like other people, and they don't give a shit. They don't make an active effort to be completely different just because they can be.

Amen.

Originally posted by Darth Exodus
The reason is twofold (is that a paradox?): Firstly I have referred to Revan as a she in real life so many times that it has basically just become instinct, like muscle-memory. I can't help myself from initially typing that s. the other reason is that I have a pathological problem with conforming. As in I don't. I was pretty much ostracised as a child and now absolutely HATE anything resembling whats considered 'normal' or 'cool'. You pushing it only exaserbated the issue.
BTW, this could also be why I like to side with Nebaris, its uncool.

Does that answer your question?

Yeah... purposefully being a non-comformist just proves you're yet another conformist trying to be different, when really, you just wanna stand out. The only true non-conformists are those to whom it comes naturally.