Revan Vs Starkiller (at his awesome prime)

rules of thread:
No noobaris
No fanboyism towards galen, only towards revan.
Take it seriously, but don't be bastards/flamers towards each other during the debate.

1. Sabers
2. Force
3. All out

Both are at the crest of their power.

Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
rules of thread:
No noobaris
No fanboyism towards galen, only towards revan.
Take it seriously, but don't be bastards/flamers towards each other during the debate.

1. Sabers
2. Force
3. All out

Both are at the crest of their power.

Hey man if your going to allow Revan fanboyisim you should at least allow Galen fanboysisim I mean fair is fair right?

Oh and Galen wipes the floor with Revan; that is my statement of opinion.

I was wondering about this match up the whole time I played the game I think its pretty close both have great power with the force Starkiller probably has more power but Revan most likely has more control and knowledge.

In saber I am leaning towards Starkiller because he has some feats but it will in no way be a curb stomp.

All out I cant really say I probably could come up with an answer once I read TFU novel but until then I cant decide on a definitive answer.

What happened to the 'no unknown' rule?

it got lost back there. didn't you get the memo?

Okay.

1. Sabers, Galen - 6/10.
2. Force, Revan - 9/10.
3. All Out, Revan - 7/10.

For no apparent reason.

mainly because revan has awesome force powers, all galen has is tk and lightning. Nothing special, they just ramped it way up for gameplay mechanics.

I'm glad someone understands that. Even if it is coming from you.

what do you mean "coming from me"?

Originally posted by Lord Knightfa11
Nothing special, they just ramped it way up for gameplay mechanics.

Though there's no way to tell how ramped up, so it hardly matters.

what force powers can you prove Revan has? (hate to be the devil's advocate here, but it CONTINUES to be a good point)

he has... um... the thought bomb... and... stuff. and... a lot of sith holocrons that give him cool stuff... ya. and a cooler outfit. Hes in a better game IMO.

and that's in addition to tk and lightning.

Originally posted by truejedi
what force powers can you prove Revan has? (hate to be the devil's advocate here, but it CONTINUES to be a good point)

Force Lightning Storm.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Force Lightning Storm.

was that in the holocron bane found? I definitly concede the thought bomb, but then again, at the time of his death, Lord Kaan could also be credited with having a thought bomb.
and tk? where can we know that he uses tk?

Revan wins. Why, because I say so.

Originally posted by Kotor3
Revan wins. Why, because I say so.

Originally posted by truejedi
was that in the holocron bane found? I definitly concede the thought bomb, but then again, at the time of his death, Lord Kaan could also be credited with having a thought bomb.
and tk? where can we know that he uses tk?

What he found in Revan's holocron in addition to the Thought Bomb was Force Storm (climate version).

Ok, now seriously, it's a tough fight. About saber skills, it's hard to say about revan, however I think it's safe to assume he was the best of his time.

I think this is proof enough to say that revan's skills with the lightsaber were superior to malak's ones and probably the best of his time as well. As for galen's lightsaber skills, he was at least on the level from vader, so that's something. When it comes to the force contend, both have great feats as well, both with lightning (galen's lightning seems quite strong, and revan's force storm was able to even kill young rancors acording to the one) and TK (galen stopping the star destroyer and revan killing a man with force choke in less then 3 seconds).

I don't, personally I see galen's force power as probably even higher then revan's one, however I think revan's force knowledge is higher. As for saber skills, I think they shouldn't be that far from each other. I think in the end it's all but a fight from coolness lol.

I say 50/50 perhaps.

Galen's Force Lightning feats involved getting it throw back by Rahm Kota and not being able to injure the Emperor at all with it. His lightning blows.

For anyone saying, "LOLZ BUT TEH STORMTOPERS EN!" Dooku managed to char/disintegrate a large number of clone troopers at once with his Force Lightning. Yet, his Lightning gets blocked by AOTC Obi-Wan's saber and casually deflected back by Yoda.

Killing expendible troops who have no defense against it doesn't equal powerful Force Lightning.

Revan has him by a mile in Force Knowledge (and probably thereby Force Mastery).

I'd say the saber skills are about equal, as is their raw power.