Who among these icons can take the most physical punishment?

Started by Starscream M5 pages

Who among these icons can take the most physical punishment?

The scenario is that they're locked in a small unbreakable room with H/P Doomsday. Who will last the longest?

---

Superman

Hal Jordan (with shields on)

Wonder Woman (with full equipment)

Thor

Silver Surfer

Hulk

It depends do you mean without sustaining injury( being cut with a knife, shot with a gun.. etc) or being able to keep fighting while taking damage(ie getting hit by incredibly strong people but being able to take it and keep going, getting cut but not being put down by it, ...).

If it's a test of pure invulnerability:

Superman
Silver Surfer
Hal Jordan
Thor
Hulk

If it's pure damage soak:
Thor
Hulk
Superman
Silver Surfer
Hal Jordan

Originally posted by Newjak
It depends do you mean without sustaining injury( being cut with a knife, shot with a gun.. etc) or being able to keep fighting while taking damage(ie getting hit by incredibly strong people but being able to take it and keep going, getting cut but not being put down by it, ...).

see my scenario

basically who lasts longest in a cage with HP Doomsday

Originally posted by Starscream M
see my scenario

basically who lasts longest in a cage with HP Doomsday

In that scenario I'm probably going with Surfer actually. His cosmic glaze does give him a nice indestructible body already and he can summon shields.

Superman is next, although if Thor is going plum knockers and is in his say thee nay, break every bone in my body and I'll still get up, mode he may be able to outlast him.

Ummmm Hal Jordan is good but GLs shields are often faulty against pure bricks that simply smash through them. It happens surprisingly often, more than it should.

can they avoid blows, or do they have to just sit there and take a beating?

Originally posted by Galan007
can they avoid blows, or do they have to just sit there and take a beating?
since this is a pure test of durability, they have to just take the blows.

Surfer
Superman
Thor
Hulk
Hal jordan

Surfer

My list:

Superman
Silver Surfer
Hulk
Thor
GL
WW

Silver Surfer
Superman
Hulk
Thor
GL
WW

Originally posted by Starscream M
My list:

Superman
Silver Surfer
Hulk
Thor
GL
WW

i pretty much agree with that.

Originally posted by Starscream M
My list:

Superman
Silver Surfer
Hulk
Thor
GL
WW

Originally posted by Starscream M
My list:

Superman
Silver Surfer
Hulk
Thor
GL
WW

yup...

Silver Surfer

Originally posted by Starscream M
My list:

Superman
Silver Surfer
Hulk
Thor
GL
WW

I would reverse the first pair, but otherwise I agree.

Originally posted by Priest
Silver Surfer
even though Surfer is perhaps at base more durable than Superman, I'd put Superman ahead of Surfer just because it seems Superman can will himself to reach an extra level in the most dire situations

Hulk
Surfer
Superman
Thor
WW
GL

Originally posted by Starscream M
My list:

Superman
Silver Surfer
Hulk
Thor
GL
WW

Hate to sound like a Marvel fanboy, but I'm going with Surfer to take first place and Hulk to take second in this competition.

No one else would last nearly as long. Reason being: H/P DD had poisoneous bone-claws that would have killed Superman had he not had his Motherbox to heal him. Hal's shields would get shattered easily, and neither Thor nor Diana or Superman has the durability to last against him. We are talking about the same guy who KO'd Darkseid in probably under a minute's time.

Surfer and Hulk are immune to poison. Surfer's not only got insane durability (like Supes), but shielding as well. And Hulk has an outrageous healing factor and is just going to get stronger and heal quicker the longer the match lasts.

So, that's my reasoning.

WW. She crosses her bracers and waits for Doomsday to forget what he was doing.