Who among these icons can take the most physical punishment?

Started by Zack Fair5 pages

Originally posted by Starscream M
My list:

Superman
Silver Surfer
Hulk
Thor
GL
WW

QFT

Superman

Wonder Woman

Hulk

Thor

Silver Surfer

Hal Jordan

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Superman

Wonder Woman

Hulk

Thor

Silver Surfer

Hal Jordan

hysterical

Originally posted by psycho gundam
hysterical

Wonder woman has those ubber braclets, don't really see whats wrong with this.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Wonder woman has those ubber braclets, don't really see whats wrong with this.
since you asked, i'll dissect this.

for one. (accepting all pretenses of coarse (such as ww being invulnerable with the bracelets up etc) and her being ALLOWED TO USE THEM)

- going by this logic, diana is the clear winner since her shield (via bracelets) allow her to deflect the combined assault of a pantheon, fangirl loves putting up that scan in efforts ad nauseum.... how superman beats her in this is .... weird.

and hal jordan shouldn't be dead last since he can create shields and other phenomena to at least delay a beating longer than say superman can.

-----------------------------------now considering the actual rules of this thread-----------------------------

two.

- yeah, she's not allowed to use the bracelets so by default she is lower than thor, hulk, superman, and norrin whom are all totally bulletproof. wonder woman is not, hence the bracelets.

doomsday would slaughter her with his bone spiked knuckles without her being able to block.

three.

-your list is way off since without being de-powered, norrin has only been cracked from physical blows, from galactus level beings no doubt. against a brick like doomsday/hulk, norrin is invulnerable from harm.

Hal can use his ring, but Thor can't use his hammer?

Originally posted by Bada's Palin
Hal can use his ring, but Thor can't use his hammer?
lulz @ the hypocrisy.

Originally posted by Bada's Palin
Hal can use his ring, but Thor can't use his hammer?
Fine, take away Hal's ring... 😐

Originally posted by psycho gundam
since you asked, i'll dissect this.

for one. (accepting all pretenses of coarse (such as ww being invulnerable with the bracelets up etc) and her being ALLOWED TO USE THEM)

- going by this logic, diana is the clear winner since her shield (via bracelets) allow her to deflect the combined assault of a pantheon, fangirl loves putting up that scan in efforts ad nauseum.... how superman beats her in this is .... weird.

and hal jordan shouldn't be dead last since he can create shields and other phenomena to at least delay a beating longer than say superman can.

-----------------------------------now considering the actual rules of this thread-----------------------------

two.

- yeah, she's not allowed to use the bracelets so by default she is lower than thor, hulk, superman, and norrin whom are all totally bulletproof. wonder woman is not, hence the bracelets.

doomsday would slaughter her with his bone spiked knuckles without her being able to block.

three.

-your list is way off since without being de-powered, norrin has only been cracked from physical blows, from galactus level beings no doubt. against a brick like doomsday/hulk, norrin is invulnerable from harm.

Norin has been knocked silly by Thanos, his durability is overated IMO. Not that I think he is a slouch, but suggesting that he wasn't KO'ed by T&A shouldn'i conclud that is the only level of power that can harm him lol.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Norin has been knocked silly by Thanos, his durability is overated IMO.
Or you underrate Thanos... no couldn't be that... 😐

Originally posted by ultimatethor
Surfer
Superman
Thor
Hulk
Hal jordan

^^^ what he said.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Norin has been knocked silly by Thanos

Several upgrades ago. By the same token, Superman has been "knocked silly" by an exploding gas station.

Originally posted by Red Hulk
Or you underrate Thanos... no couldn't be that... 😐

Thor has faired better agaisnt Thanos and to my knowledge has never been KO'ed by him. In fact Thor has a better record agaisnt ubber beings then SS IMO.

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Thor has faired better agaisnt Thanos and to my knowledge has never been KO'ed by him. In fact Thor has a better record agaisnt ubber beings then SS IMO.
He's only had like one panel fights with Thanos... and was two shotted against the weakest version of Thanos.

Thor has a mallet to deflect tons of attacks (and Surfer has good showings against uber beings as well), and what does Thor have to do with what I quoted?

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Thor has faired better against Thanos and to my knowledge has never been KO'ed by him. In fact Thor has a better record agaisnt ubber beings then SS IMO.
well, to thor's credit, his mother is an elder god and his father odin is the strongest of all earth's sky-fathers
since he is the gestalt of three sky-father level beings. (odin + villi + ve = current odin)

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Thor has faired better against Thanos and to my knowledge has never been KO'ed by him. In fact Thor has a better record agaisnt ubber beings then SS IMO.
well, to thor's credit, his mother is an elder god and his father odin is the strongest of all earth's sky-fathers
since he is the gestalt of three sky-father level beings. (odin (his brother's) + villi + ve = current odin)

Originally posted by The Great Galen
Thor has faired better against Thanos and to my knowledge has never been KO'ed by him. In fact Thor has a better record agaisnt ubber beings then SS IMO.
well, to thor's credit, his mother is an elder god and his father odin is the strongest of all earth's sky-fathers
since he is the gestalt of three sky-father level beings. (odin + villi + ve (his brother's) = current odin)

Originally posted by psycho gundam
well, to thor's credit, his mother is an elder god and his father odin is the strongest of all earth's sky-fathers
since he is the gestalt of three sky-father level beings. (odin + villi + ve = current odin)
Originally posted by psycho gundam
well, to thor's credit, his mother is an elder god and his father odin is the strongest of all earth's sky-fathers
since he is the gestalt of three sky-father level beings. (odin (his brother's) + villi + ve = current odin)
Originally posted by psycho gundam
well, to thor's credit, his mother is an elder god and his father odin is the strongest of all earth's sky-fathers
since he is the gestalt of three sky-father level beings. (odin + villi + ve (his brother's) = current odin)

You're really rubbing it in, aren't you? 😕

oops

Originally posted by Red Hulk
He's only had like one panel fights with Thanos... and was two shotted against the weakest version of Thanos.

Thor has a mallet to deflect tons of attacks (and Surfer has good showings against uber beings as well), and what does Thor have to do with what I quoted?

http://i38.photobucket.com/albums/e101/Soujaboy/Thor%20Feats/ThorvsSurferfirstbattle10.jpg

IMO that is when marvel decided to to shocase Thor>SS.