If Peter jackson made SW would they be better?

I don't think they would have been better. They were written in whole or in part by Lucas, and there in lies the problem. The prequels would have sucked no matter who directed them because they were written by George Lucas. I love the original trilogy, but I grew up with them. I'm sure that the generation that comes after me will and do love the new films; because that's who they were written for.

Lucas wouldn't even have let Jackson direct the way he'd like to.

Originally posted by queeq
Lucas wouldn't even have let Jackson direct the way he'd like to.

Thank goodness. We would have shots of Force sensitive trees taking out Clone Troopers. lol

Hmmm... sounds interesting.

at least peter never changed the same films ten times like sw.

The thing is that most of if not all of Peter Jackson's most well-known movies were stories written by other people. (For example: King Kong, which was originally a movie that used claymation and Lord of the Rings, which was a trilogy of novels written by J.R.R. Tolkien)

Not to mention that he is working on the Hobbit (By J.R.R. Tolkien) and is supposedly working on Halo (Game by Bungie) again.

At least Star Wars was an original work.

Originally posted by coolmovies
at least peter never changed the same films ten times like sw.

True, but they still aren't original works.

Originally posted by coolmovies
at least peter never changed the same films ten times like sw.

LOTR hasn't been out long enough to justify any changes with newer technology.

Not that it would ever need too. Nothing in that movie looked fake imo.

And I was watching ESB last night and god damn, those were graphics were excellent, even by today's standards.

Originally posted by Final Blaxican
Not that it would ever need too. Nothing in that movie looked fake imo.

And I was watching ESB last night and god damn, those were graphics were excellent, even by today's standards.

I agree, I watched some of it on spike , but I wouldn't have used such extreme language to describe it...

REPORTED.

Originally posted by Final Blaxican
I was watching ESB last night and god damn, those were graphics were excellent, even by today's standards.

Agree 100%. ESB is my favorite of all 6 films.

I think ESB is a tad overrated. I love all SW films but I would have to say my personal favorites are ANH and ROTS. (I can't decide which one I like more.)

The only sw movie i have is EMPIRE 😄

Originally posted by coolmovies
The only sw movie i have is EMPIRE 😄

Hehehe. That is the only one I didn't buy of the OT for the limited edition DVDs. I figured it had the least changes.

Still, ESB always looks nice to watch.

Originally posted by queeq
Still, ESB always looks nice to watch.

Yes, yes, we all know you love what they color correction did to Hoth. 😛

Originally posted by sweersa
I think ESB is a tad overrated.

WHAT!!! Some one strike that boy!

Originally posted by Nactous
WHAT!!! Some one strike that boy!

I like Episode IV, III and VI more.

Originally posted by coolmovies
If Peter jackson made SW would they be better movies?? I think he would turned it into a 7 part saga filling in the big gap between EP 3 and 4.

He's done an outstanding job with LOTR he could of done the same for sw

I'd think if you'd stop posting these forums would be better

Originally posted by OB1-adobe
I'd think if you'd stop posting these forums would be better

Oh man. Ouch.

Originally posted by sweersa
Yes, yes, we all know you love what they color correction did to Hoth. 😛

Actually, the color correction on the entire OT. ANH suffers most from that actually.