If Peter jackson made SW would they be better?

Originally posted by queeq
Actually, the color correction on the entire OT. ANH suffers most from that actually.

Other than the lightsabers why is it so bad? Did they do color correction back in the day when it first came out? Or was it raw?

They chose for a crisp and palish look, to give it a documentary style feel. It's part of the movie that made history, it was different, no one did it like that then. And that historic cinematographical part was ruined. It was no accident it looked like that, it was pure intention.

Originally posted by queeq
They chose for a crisp and palish look, to give it a documentary style feel. It's part of the movie that made history, it was different, no one did it like that then. And that historic cinematographical part was ruined. It was no accident it looked like that, it was pure intention.

Gah it is all ruined now....maybe they did it to save money as well.

Jackson made the second best saga of all time.
Lucas made the best saga of all time.

Why should Jackson take over what Lucas made better ?

There are a lot of things I do not like in Star Wars. I could make a very long list. Still it is the best saga/movie of them all.

I find it much harder to find failure (things I do not like) in LOTR (okay, when i watched them for the second, third time etc. I find all the Frodo stuff a little boring - I didn't when I watch them the first time). Seems that Star Wars is just a better story with stronger characters. Jackson is great, but could he has made Star Wars better. We don't know, but I don't think so.

I have just watched LOTR again. Why didn't they just send an eagle out to throw the ring in the volcano ? The eagle could just carry it in a back or something.

Originally posted by sweersa
Gah it is all ruined now....maybe they did it to save money as well.

No. You should read into the DOP chose the clear look carefully. The only reason they corrected the colors was to make it look similar to the PT, which looks less original.

Originally posted by queeq
No. You should read into the DOP chose the clear look carefully. The only reason they corrected the colors was to make it look similar to the PT, which looks less original.

Oh well. They forgot to call me to fix the pink and Luke's blue lightsaber that looked green.

Actually, they kinda ruined that, it used to look a lot better.

Originally posted by queeq
Actually, they kinda ruined that, it used to look a lot better.

I know. They should have called Sweersa to make everything all better.

They should have stopped Lucas to touch it.

Originally posted by queeq
They should have stopped Lucas to touch it.

Maybe they should have put up one of those little signs in museums that said "Look but don't touch."

Indeed.

Originally posted by queeq
Indeed.

lol You say that a lot don't you?

Of course.

the force is strong thats why

IMHO, this is probably one of the situations in which "the originals are always better than what ifs".

But then again, we would never know, seeing that Peter Jackson will probably never make an SW episode or something...

Originally posted by sweersa
lol You say that a lot don't you?

I do?

Originally posted by queeq
I do?

Of course.

Indeed, er, I mean Inderdaad.

Clever.

Originally posted by queeq
Clever.

Hehe. In school we are learning about alternative energy. We were going to make simple devices that would hold in heat from the sun, my partner and I shaped our box into the Millenium Falcon! Hahaha.

...what score did you guys get?

Oh yeah, I know that experiment. Quite basic though.