Thor vs Thanos

Started by quanchi11233 pages

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
facepalm

He wasn't far off from Odin in that fight?

Thanos didn't phase Odin and Odin was smacking him around. Thanos was able to pull himself back up, but that's about it.

What direct comparisons?

You yourself just stated he fluctuates and that's true, but in these boards, we use the characters here to their best of abilities and plot induced stupidity is ignored, meaning, Odin caves Thanos' head in.

Odin and Thanos both really didn't phase each other until he got out gungir. Then he still didn't defeat Thanos. Sure, Odin was winning, but he still never put Thanos down.

No, I said writer to writer has different visions of Odin. The one writer who compared the two had them as peers. Odin's words also support me. No surprise really.

Thanos since his upgrade is greater than Odin imo.

Thanos battle with Odin is pure PIS. That fight was like Superman almost getting koed by a gas station. Odin could have beaten Thanos by merely cursing him taking away his powers, or many many other options.

1. Thanos
2. Thanos gets owned hard

Originally posted by h1a8
Thanos battle with Odin is pure PIS. That fight was like Superman almost getting koed by a gas station. Odin could have beaten Thanos by merely cursing him taking away his powers, or many many other options.
Fight is canon. Even though you might dislike it the writers decide what we use not you or me.

1.Thanos(current Thor has done nothing that puts him over Thanos, just seems like everybody is jumping on the bandwagon.
2.Thor.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Odin and Thanos both really didn't phase each other until he got out gungir. Then he still didn't defeat Thanos. Sure, Odin was winning, but he still [B]never put Thanos down.

No, I said writer to writer has different visions of Odin. The one writer who compared the two had them as peers. Odin's words also support me. No surprise really.

Thanos since his upgrade is greater than Odin imo. [/B]

Again facepalm

So you're basing you're opinion on their levels of power, on their one encounter when you as I know that Odin's level of power fluctuates extremely as the story requires, and that based on his higher feats, that fight was utter PIS. Even then, Odin wasn't exactly unleashing his full power on Thanos, and was just surprised that he kept getting up.

Gungir, is just a weapon through which Odin channels his power. Like Odin showed against Absorbing Man, it's rather worthless unless you're Odin. Odin was phasing Thanos before he got out Gungir. Re-read the issue. Odin downed Thanos more than a few times. He just kept getting up, but that doesn't mean Odin cannot put Thanos down.

I thought that in these boards we use the characters are their best, and we exclude writer biased and the other crap that usually affects stories.

The majority of Odin's higher showings support that Odin "WTFSTOMPS" Thanos.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Again facepalm

So you're basing you're opinion on their levels of power, on their one encounter when you as I know that Odin's level of power fluctuates extremely as the story requires, and that based on his higher feats, that fight was utter PIS. Even then, Odin wasn't exactly unleashing his full power on Thanos, and was just surprised that he kept getting up.

Gungir, is just a weapon through which Odin channels his power. Like Odin showed against Absorbing Man, it's rather worthless unless you're Odin. Odin was phasing Thanos before he got out Gungir. Re-read the issue. Odin downed Thanos more than a few times. He just kept getting up, but that doesn't mean Odin cannot put Thanos down.

I thought that in these boards we use the characters are their best, and we exclude writer biased and the other crap that usually affects stories.

The majority of Odin's higher showings support that Odin "WTFSTOMPS" Thanos.

Prove he wasn't exactly unleashing his full power. To say something that ignorant you have to ignore the context of the story and Odin's words.

Odin wasn't visibly having an effect on Thanos until he pulled out gungir. You need to reread it if you think he was really damaging him before hand.

We don't ignore Thanos and Odin's confrontation to support your views. Thanos has been upgraded after this battle as well and you keep refusing to acknowledge that either. 🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
Prove he wasn't exactly unleashing his full power. To say something that ignorant you have to ignore the context of the story and Odin's words.

Odin wasn't visibly having an effect on Thanos until he pulled out gungir. You need to reread it if you think he was really damaging him before hand.

We don't ignore Thanos and Odin's confrontation to support your views. Thanos has been upgraded after this battle as well and you keep refusing to acknowledge that either. 🙂

Odin unleashing his full power will cause him to become weak and enter the odin sleep Odin was not taxed at all from the battle.

He rocked thanos befroe gungir and rocked him more with it. We all know thanos lost get over it.

Originally posted by DarkOdin
Odin unleashing his full power will cause him to become weak and enter the odin sleep Odin was not taxed at all from the battle.

He rocked thanos befroe gungir and rocked him more with it. We all know thanos lost get over it.

No.

Thanos wasn't taxed and fully recovered after this battle on his own.

No, the only time he visibly affected Thanos was after he brought out gungir. He didn't lose he was losing.

Thor shoves a pole up Thanos's ass.

Originally posted by quanchi112
No.

Thanos wasn't taxed and fully recovered after this battle on his own.

No, the only time he visibly affected Thanos was after he brought out gungir. He didn't lose he was losing.

He was losing a battle that ended lol so we will call it a tko maybe 😆

He losed

Odin back handed thanos and blasted before he called gungir and thanos got throw around.

Ya thanos standing up showed he was fully recovered 😆

Originally posted by Philosophía
Thor shoves a pole up Thanos's ass.

The worst that would do is make Thanos moan. uhuh

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Again facepalm

So you're basing you're opinion on their levels of power, on their one encounter when you as I know that Odin's level of power fluctuates extremely as the story requires, and that based on his higher feats, that fight was utter PIS. Even then, Odin wasn't exactly unleashing his full power on Thanos, and was just surprised that he kept getting up.

Gungir, is just a weapon through which Odin channels his power. Like Odin showed against Absorbing Man, it's rather worthless unless you're Odin. Odin was phasing Thanos before he got out Gungir. Re-read the issue. Odin downed Thanos more than a few times. He just kept getting up, but that doesn't mean Odin cannot put Thanos down.

I thought that in these boards we use the characters are their best, and we exclude writer biased and the other crap that usually affects stories.

The majority of Odin's higher showings support that Odin "WTFSTOMPS" Thanos.

To use an extreme example, if he were a Spider-man fanboy he would be saying much the same about the Spider-man/Firelord fight.

Scenario 1-Thanos wins
Scenario 2-Thor/Destroyer wins

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Thor wins in the second scenario.

In my opinion Classic Thor will give Thanos a decent enough fight if Thor went all out. It wouldn't be far fetched to say Current Thor wins the first scenario but that's not to say, Thanos can't win.

Originally posted by Mekrob
The problem with that battle though, is that Thor never beat the fully amped Thanos.
He crushed his power source in the fight, and then smoked him.

While technically he did beat Thanos upgraded, it was the definition of plot induced stupidity to do so.

And if I recall, Thanos was pounding Thor with his power and basically shredded his shield and armor that Odin made for him by the time Thor managed to get close enough to destroy the Stone of Illumination.
Originally posted by Badabing
1. Thor

2. Thor

I pretty much agree with this.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
And if I recall, Thanos was pounding Thor with his power and basically shredded his shield and armor that Odin made for him by the time Thor managed to get close enough to destroy the Stone of Illumination.I pretty much agree with this.

Your saying Thor with amps beating a clone with amps is why you have Thor winning fight no1? Fight no.2 I think all agree Thor wins. However, if you wanna go by past battles Thanos has handled Thor with relative ease in the past. Yes that isn't current Thor but Thanos has also gone through upgrades as well. So, I see nothing that tells me Thor beats Thanos any day of the week. Sure he'll put up a good fight and probably hurt thanos some. However, Thanos's durability and power output will win the day.

Well Destroyer has also easily handled Thor in the past. Current Thor took him out.

Not out of the realm of possibility to say Current Thor wins. I still think Thanos gets the majority, but we really haven't seen Current Thor tested fully yet to know his capabilities/limitations. Thanos 6-7/10.

Destroyer Thor wins 10/10.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Your saying Thor with amps beating a clone with amps is why you have Thor winning fight no1? Fight no.2 I think all agree Thor wins. However, if you wanna go by past battles Thanos has handled Thor with relative ease in the past. Yes that isn't current Thor but Thanos has also gone through upgrades as well. So, I see nothing that tells me Thor beats Thanos any day of the week. Sure he'll put up a good fight and probably hurt thanos some. However, Thanos's durability and power output will win the day.
That's the key point. We're not talking about classic Thor. Thor received an immense increase in power that has so far been tested and proven in a few occasions. The limits of those upgrades have not. I've never seen Thanos' ambiguous increase quantified on any scale. Either way, nobody ever said current Thor beats Thanos any day of the week. But as I said before, it's extremely arguable based on feats, even without relying on the sole fact that he possesses the full Odinpower.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
And if I recall, Thanos was pounding Thor with his power and basically shredded his shield and armor that Odin made for him by the time Thor managed to get close enough to destroy the Stone of Illumination.
I realize that. Thor managed to get close to him while Thanos was trying to destroy the universe, and hitting him with energy with iirc his other hand, or eyes.

However, he only managed to defeat Thanos via Resident Evil glaring weakness. If the dangle wasn't there, Thor would have never won that fight.

Which is the PIS at its best, no?