Wizards vs Mutants

Started by omgchos40 pages

Originally posted by Mindset
Scooby Doo, Monsters Island.

Wgo the hell is that? And why does it negate the voldemort argument?

Originally posted by Mindset
This is a forum where we discuss fights, on the forum when the body dies that counts as a loss.

Tell me you understand this.

IF this is true, than that is a loss for Voldemort.

If not, you've never answered my question.

How long does it take him to possess someone, and has he ever shown the ability to kill someone immediately upon possession.

And Xavier has never been shown mind raping a wizard, nor has DP been shown disintegrating a wizard. See how stupid that sounds?

Originally posted by omgchos
Wgo the hell is that? And why does it negate the voldemort argument?
It doesnt, he's reaching for straws.

Originally posted by Mindset
This is a forum where we discuss fights, on the forum when the body dies that counts as a loss.

Tell me you understand this.

IF this is true, than that is a loss for Voldemort.

If not, you've never answered my question.

How long does it take him to possess someone, and has he ever shown the ability to kill someone immediately upon possession.


If one of his powers is to NOT DIE and turn into a being who can posses people, than why can it not be used. Just because his body dies does not mean HE dies. Tell me you understand THIS. When he attempted to enter harry he almost killed him, the only thing keeping harry alive, as said by Dumbly, was the magic protection his mother gave him.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
And Xavier has never been shown mind raping a wizard, nor has DP been shown disintegrating a wizard. See how stupid that sounds?
Are you intentionally being dense?

Those are in no way similar to my questions.

facepalm

Originally posted by Mindset
Are you intentionally being dense?

Those are in no way similar to my questions.

facepalm


His point is that a wizard has many magical ways of protection. So we can never say with certainty that the wizards will not just block the desintigration.

Originally posted by omgchos
If one of his powers is to NOT DIE and turn into a being who can posses people, than why can it not be used. Just because his body dies does not mean HE dies. Tell me you understand THIS. When he attempted to enter harry he almost killed him, the only thing keeping harry alive, as said by Dumbly, was the magic protection his mother gave him.
Way to completely miss the point that this is a forum fight that has its own restrictions.

At least you were smart enough to answer simple questions, unlike someone.

So Voldemort is able to immediately upon death possess and kill anyone of his choosing?

Originally posted by omgchos
His point is that a wizard has many magical ways of protection. So we can never say with certainty that the wizards will not just block the desintigration.
Who is talking about disintegration?

And if they have never shown it, for the sake of this vs. match they have no defense.

Btw, Palpatine was in the Star Wars movies, since you didn't recognize I was joking earlier.

Originally posted by omgchos
His point is that a wizard has many magical ways of protection. So we can never say with certainty that the wizards will not just block the desintigration.
Exactly.

Originally posted by Mindset
Way to completely miss the point that this is a forum fight that has its own restrictions.

At least you were smart enough to answer simple questions, unlike someone.

So Voldemort is able to immediately upon death possess and kill anyone of his choosing?


Look these are the things we know from the movie.
1: Voldy dies and becomes something that can posses people, we know this because he posses Quirrel.
2: He says he uses the persons life force to help him stay alive. Tho he is able to leave the body and still not die.
3: he attempted to posses harry, but the protection thwarted that attempt. Tho it still rendered him injured and unconcious.

So we can ascert from these facts that he can posses people and since he is using their life force like a leech we can also ascert that he can take as much of their life as he wants to.

Originally posted by Mindset
Who is talking about disintegration?

And if they have never shown it, for the sake of this vs. match they have no defense.

Btw, Palpatine was in the Star Wars movies, since you didn't recognize I was joking earlier.


That's a very blunt way of looking at it. We, by that logic, can say this fight could not possibly take place, because we never see mutants fighting wizards. The spell protego is a barrier of magic. What logic dictates that a mutants ability would penetrate that if another spell cannot?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Exactly.
So your point was about a topic that was not even being discussed?

Nor is there any proof to back up what you were saying?

Cool.

Originally posted by omgchos
That's a very blunt way of looking at it. We, by that logic, can say this fight could not possibly take place, because we never see mutants fighting wizards. The spell protego is a barrier of magic. What logic dictates that a mutants ability would penetrate that if another spell cannot?
It appears you do not understand how this forum fight works, nor have you read the rules.

Did they use protego in the movies?

Originally posted by Mindset
It appears you do not understand how this forum fight works, nor have you read the rules.

Did they use protego in the movies?


Plenty of times. And if there is a rule that says if someones body dies, but they themselves aren't dead, it counts as them dying, please post or get imped to clear it up. If he is still on that is.

Originally posted by omgchos
Look these are the things we know from the movie.
1: Voldy dies and becomes something that can posses people, we know this because he posses Quirrel.
2: He says he uses the persons life force to help him stay alive. Tho he is able to leave the body and still not die.
3: he attempted to posses harry, but the protection thwarted that attempt. Tho it still rendered him injured and unconcious.

So we can ascert from these facts that he can posses people and since he is using their life force like a leech we can also ascert that he can take as much of their life as he wants to.

You need to be able to prove that he can take as much life force as he wants, when he wants.

You're just making an assumption.

Originally posted by omgchos
Plenty of times. And if there is a rule that says if someones body dies, but they themselves aren't dead, it counts as them dying, please post or get imped to clear it up. If he is still on that is.
If you read the rules then you know they are only allowed abilities they have shown in the movies.

I was going of of the impression that Nepth actually knew what he was talking about.

There's the probably that he was wrong, which is why I did not hinge my entire stance on that fact.

Originally posted by Mindset
You need to be able to prove that he can take as much life force as he wants, when he wants.

You're just making an assumption.


Well since harry almost died, than its a valid assumption.

Originally posted by Mindset
So your point was about a topic that was not even being discussed?

Nor is there any proof to back up what you were saying?

Cool.

You got any proof that Xavier can mind rape a wizard? That DP can kill a wizard? Hmm? Didnt think so.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
You got any proof that Xavier can mind rape a wizard? That DP can kill a wizard? Hmm? Didnt think so.

Wizards protect themselves with occulmency, so that means w/o it the'r minds are not protected, I don't even have to go into the fact that there is not a telepath as strong as Xavier in HP movies, but regardless...

Wizards can be hurt by physical means, so yea, there's proof DP can kill them...

Anything else, sport?

Originally posted by Mindset
Wizards protect themselves with occulmency, so that means w/o it the'r minds are not protected, I don't even have to go into the fact that there is not a telepath as strong as Xavier in HP movies, but regardless...

Wizards can be hurt by physical means, so yea, there's proof DP can kill them...

Anything else, sport?


I am still of the opinion that human mutations cannot match up against magic, in any way shape or form.