Originally posted by xJLxKing
Isn't she greater?
IMO, the Phoenix Force trumps Galactus. There isn't much on-panel evidence to support that conclusion, though. Rachel beating a starving Galactus and then another time Galactus being able to erase the Phoenix Force from existence, but choosing not to.
*shrug*
Originally posted by Enyalus
You've got conflicting statements in the same arc, even. Uatu said she was the second greatest power in creation (Well, he said that of the Phoenix Force). Then you have Reed saying that her power rivals Galactus, and was increasing as she fed.IMO, the Phoenix Force trumps Galactus. There isn't much on-panel evidence to support that conclusion, though. Rachel beating a starving Galactus and then another time Galactus being able to erase the Phoenix Force from existence, but choosing not to.
*shrug*
Dark Phoenix.
Originally posted by Lord Feron
DP also when did Galactus choose not to erase PF from existence? Like really he would be able to do that? Was it under special Circumstances?
It was when Phoenix willingly gave up to Galactus, so that she would protect her friends. Galactus was trying to absorb and stars began fading. Then Death or Eternity or Roma (I am not sure) came and said Galactus shouldn't do that, because of the role and balance of Phoenix Force. I don't know if he would truly remove her from existence, if he would consume her. I think he would explode, if he would try to finish the process.
Anyway Dark Phoenix wins destroys Aegis.
Those present was Uatu, Death and Roma and all warned Galactus against the act he was about to pursue, they didn't try and stop him only adviced against it. And I don't think that Galactus was going to absorb the Phoenix Force instead he would simply erase it from existance, on another note Galactus hunger have been stated by Reed to be practically limitless, so I doubt that Phoenix could overload Galactus.
Originally posted by Utrigita
Those present was Uatu, Death and Roma and all warned Galactus against the act he was about to pursue, they didn't try and stop him only adviced against it. And I don't think that Galactus was going to absorb the Phoenix Force instead he would simply erase it from existance, on another note Galactus hunger have been stated by Reed to be practically limitless, so I doubt that Phoenix could overload Galactus.
I was close. 🙂
It's just that Galactus wouldn't be able to do that with a force, with a fight, but Phoenix gave herself up.
I call that some BS writing, but it's canon. But still we can still only speculate, if he would truly be able to do it.
Thanks for the heads up I vaguely remember the warning they gave Big G now.
But Idk I think Big G did it he would be consuming more than just planets it would be like universes and galaxies and prob more.
IMO BIg G might be able to do it but he would be full for a pretty damn long time. Also not sure if there will be anything left to eat after he did that.
Also Imagine BIg G with the PF inside him! OH SHIZZLE!
Originally posted by Xplosive
I was close. 🙂It's just that Galactus wouldn't be able to do that with a force, with a fight, but Phoenix gave herself up.
I call that some BS writing, but it's canon. But still we can still only speculate, if he would truly be able to do it.
Yes. 🙂
I have no idea, I'm not familiar with the Phoenix/Rachel Character abilities, and how one Phoenix's feats can be used as arguments for anothers.
Imo it was pretty close to obvious that Galactus was capable of doing it, The stars are going out, the Stars are substained by Phoenix according to Kubik, also the fact that both Roma, Uatu and Death shows up imo speaks for the view that she was going to be erased but that is only what I draw from the scans and I know that you and many draws other conclusions and peace be with it 🙂
Originally posted by Utrigita
Yes. 🙂I have no idea, I'm not familiar with the Phoenix/Rachel Character abilities, and how one Phoenix's feats can be used as arguments for anothers.
Imo it was pretty close to obvious that Galactus was capable of doing it, The stars are going out, the Stars are substained by Phoenix according to Kubik, also the fact that both Roma, Uatu and Death shows up imo speaks for the view that she was going to be erased but that is only what I draw from the scans and I know that you and many draws other conclusions and peace be with it 🙂
People draw the conclusion that he can't from him not being able to, they admonish him and he still goes on with what he is doing, "yet Phoenix lives"
http://www.comicvine.com/myvine/phoenix_of_the_black_throne/all-images/108-49142/excalibur02521ly3/105-636039/
Originally posted by LordKaos
People draw the conclusion that he can't from him not being able to, they admonish him and he still goes on with what he is doing,
You draw that conclusion from the scan that Galactus failed to destroy Phoenix, I draw the conclusion that based on what Galactus had been told and the later conversation between them, he released her.
Originally posted by LordKaos
"yet Phoenix lives"
"For the Present"
^^✅ ... Phoenix's durability is a joke. (proven across several arcs)
Galactus was going to erase the Phoenix Force from existence,
simple and plain.
Whether or not Rachel would've willingly entered his machine makes little difference,
he was going to get her in there one way or another.
That aside,
what that story proves is that Galactus has the hierarchal right,
to erase the PF if he wishes to do so
and nobody can interfere except through advise.
Originally posted by LordKaosPeople draw the conclusion that he can't from him not being able to, they admonish him and he still goes on with what he is doing, "yet Phoenix lives"
http://www.comicvine.com/myvine/phoenix_of_the_black_throne/all-images/108-49142/excalibur02521ly3/105-636039/
That scan represents Galactus releasing the PF.
The PF/Rachel was in the process of being nullified,
definitively proven when the stars were fading.
Originally posted by UtrigitaYou draw that conclusion from the scan that Galactus failed to destroy Phoenix, I draw the conclusion that based on what Galactus had been told and the later conversation between them, he released her.
"For the Present"
Originally posted by Utrigita
she was going to be erased but that is only what I draw from the scans and I know that you and many draws other conclusions and peace be with it 🙂
You are right actually, but it's just awkward the PF could be truly erased.
Originally posted by Mr Master
The PF/Rachel was in the process of being nullified,
definitively proven when the stars were fading.
Definitively proven would be when he would nullify her, although it seems, he would truly be able to do it.