501st vs. Hogwarts

Started by Rogue Jedi60 pages
Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by Luminatus
....

I'm speechless.

Okay a couple things.

1. Yes the clones adnd Vader know where Hogwarts is. I know very much about the concealing spells. That and the whole anti-tech field Hermione mentions in Book 4 are not in play here. They aren't in play at all in the films anyway IIRC.

2. No magical creatures. I purposefully left things like Dementors and Giants out of this because they're kinda wanky.

3. Appirition must have a limit. Otherwise it's a no limits falllacy. Plus, just for fun, in Book 7 Voldemort has to fly to get to a spot so he's close enough to appirate back to Malfoy Manor.

Finally, being a fan of Harry Potter is just fine. Even if the films do suck balls, the books ar egood.

What about the wizards? Are they taken by surprise here, or do they have knowledge of the upcoming battle?

WO Polaski Don't wanna die...

what rj is asking is do the wizards have prep.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by WO Polaski
what rj is asking is do the wizards have prep.
No, what I am asking is if they are like "oh shit, clone troopers"

WO Polaski Don't wanna die...

if they know the troopers are coming before they get there then that means they have prep time... because they have time to prepare before they get there.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by WO Polaski
if they know the troopers are coming before they get there then that means they have prep time... because they have time to prepare before they get there.
And if the troopers know the location of Hogwarts beforehand and advance undetected, thats prep time for the troopers.

WO Polaski Don't wanna die...

uh..yeah. Yeah it is. the thread starter has already established that.

so?

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by WO Polaski
uh..yeah. Yeah it is. the thread starter has already established that.

so?

So one side gets prep, the other doesnt? Yeah, thats fair.

SPITE.

WO Polaski Don't wanna die...

its not fair. but its not spite either. if you looked at other vs. forums youd see that.

Sadako of Girth Extreme Mode

The only peaceful way out for the Hogwartsians would be death by cyanide.

Nice and quick.

Better than having your balls blown off by blaster rifle shot or being partially crushed by rubble, or force choked, or burned, or.....

Nephthys The Gr8est!!!!!!!!

How about we just say that the troopers start right at the edge of the grounds and the wizards have till they get to the building to prep? That seems like a fair and logical compromise.

Sadako of Girth Extreme Mode

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
So one side gets prep, the other doesnt? Yeah, thats fair.

SPITE.

Not really, when you claim the wizards to be so powerful. 🙂

No good stamping your feet about it.
Threadstarter rules. 😮‍💨

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by WO Polaski
its not fair. but its not spite either. if you looked at other vs. forums youd see that.
It's spite and you know it. If I snuck up on Mike Tyson and clocked him with a baseball bat, he'd be KO'd.

Sadako of Girth Extreme Mode

Maybe not, back in the day.....

And even then, if that 1st shot doesnt do it, hes gonna destroy you in 3 seconds and maybe even eat some of you whilst you sleeping.

WO Polaski Don't wanna die...

its not spite youre just crying because youve lost. again. whatever dude think what you want i and everyone else on this forum see the truth. if you want to delude yourself feel free.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by WO Polaski
its not spite youre just crying because youve lost. again. whatever dude think what you want i and everyone else on this forum see the truth. if you want to delude yourself feel free.
And what if the wizards were to sneak up on the clones as the clones were eating lunch? If the wizards were fully prepped and primed for battle? It's be a clone slaughter.

Sadako of Girth Extreme Mode

Sok WO.

He just loves the sound of that word or something.

He says it to me all the time.....then goes and sets up a SUV thread from McClane "spite".

Spite Spite Spite Spite Spiteyspiteyspiteyspitespite.

Spite.

The clones eat lunch on the destroyers.
They arent shown eating anywhere else.

No sense in asking "what if" the wizards had blah blah warnings blah blah etc

Thread rules state otherwise.
😛

WO Polaski Don't wanna die...
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
And what if the wizards were to sneak up on the clones as the clones were eating lunch? If the wizards were fully prepped and primed for battle? It's be a clone slaughter.

then id say the clones lose and move on with my life. i wouldnt cry spite and try to change the scenario so the clones have a chance.

if it bothered me that much id make my own thread with my own conditions.

Rogue Jedi Restricted

Originally posted by WO Polaski
then id say the clones lose and [b]move on with my life. i wouldnt cry spite and try to change the scenario so the clones have a chance.

if it bothered me that much id make my own thread with my own conditions. [/B]

You'd say the clones lose, as would I, and I'd say clone spite.

WO Polaski Don't wanna die...

of course youd say its spite. because you like to cry. its not spite. no one here thinks its spiite except for you.

Luminatus Restricted

What would the wizards do with prep anyway? They aren't techno geniuses or military leaders...
But fine. They get 2 hours to prepare for the 501st's arrival.

And the 501st has no prep. They never did. They're just attacking.