501st vs. Hogwarts

Started by Rogue Jedi60 pages

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Easily.

With long range sphere-f***ing up AT AT cannons as seen in ATOC.

Dont let the loony ward door hit ya on the way in.... 😛

What part of "ground troops only" do you not understand?

AT-AT's are ground troops, the general term is troop, that includes heavy things like missile platforms and tanks, you're thinking of Infantry, which is strictly foot soldiers, but since it's ground troops, everything restricted to the ground is able to be used, so the long range bombardment is within reason.

I would come up with something witty, but there's no point since you won't regard this anyway.

They were ground forces.

Its WAY more right a statement to make than your "magic is energy/Energy isnt magic/magic blocks blasters, yet blasters cant affect magic" nonsense. 🙂

At least we SEE the shit I just talked about in AOTC.

Whereas you're just making shit up in a vain attempt to save save face in a sitauation where you got unduly arrogant with people when you were wrong and got your ass tanned, accordingly.

EDIT: Exactly, KingD19

Hey Sadako.....High Five.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
What part of "ground troops only" do you not understand?

As we can see above, it is YOU who are lacking, maybe in you understanding of what that entails.

Originally posted by KingD19
Hey Sadako.....High Five.

*High fives*

😉

RJ seems to have vanished, he can't be around people who disagree with him and make valid points.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
They were ground forces.

Its WAY more right a statement to make than your "magic is energy/Energy isnt magic/magic blocks blasters, yet blasters cant affect magic" nonsense. 🙂

At least we SEE the shit I just talked about in AOTC.

Whereas you're just making shit up in a vain attempt to save save face in a sitauation where you got unduly arrogant with people when you were wrong and got your ass tanned, accordingly.

EDIT: Exactly, KingD19

They were round forces? Proof? AT AT means All Terrain Armored Transport, you know.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/At_at

Originally posted by KingD19
AT-AT's are ground troops, the general term is troop, that includes heavy things like missile platforms and tanks, you're thinking of Infantry, which is strictly foot soldiers, but since it's ground troops, everything restricted to the ground is able to be used, so the long range bombardment is within reason.

I would come up with something witty, but there's no point since you won't regard this anyway.

Wrong.

Tanks are vehicles, missile platforms must be transported by vehicles, try again.

Yes and wtf does TERRAIN mean.

Look it up.

And the clones all had to come down via transport also.........duhhhhhhhhhh.....

What....you think this is startrek where you BEAM in...? 🙄

Yes they were ground forces, as we both explained, the term ground forces/troops, encompasses every resource, weapon, vehicle, and soldier limited to the ground, so AT-AT's, AT-ST's, Infantry, hover craft, all of that is ground forces since it is restricted to ground movement only.

You keep thinking of Infantry, Infantry is when you only have soldiers on foot.

Originally posted by KingD19
RJ seems to have vanished, he can't be around people who disagree with him and make valid points.
Oh I'm here, just busy burying your vain attempt to regain control of the thread.

AT AT's= vehicles

Missile platforms= Must be transported by vehicles

Try again?

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Yes and wtf does TERRAIN mean.

Look it up.

Transport is the same as a vehicle. Lum has made it clear that it's the ground troops only, no vehicles. Just the clones advancing on foot.

No AT AT's, no ships, no AT ST's.

Get it?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Wrong.

Tanks are vehicles, missile platforms must be transported by vehicles, try again.

Try again with that try again shit, whilst you continue to ignore my invitation to prove me wrong when I say you are totally full of shit about magic/energy, and just making stuff up to fit your appetite for the juice of SnapeSnake.. 🙂

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Yes and wtf does TERRAIN mean.

Look it up.

And the clones all had to come down via transport also.........duhhhhhhhhhh.....

What....you think this is startrek where you BEAM in...? 🙄

😂 Reaching again I see. No vehicles or ships may be used in the attack on hogwarts. This is Lum's thread, talk to him about it.

I was using a missile platform as an example, and yes, an AT-AT is a vehicle, but it is a strictly ground vehicle, unless it is specifically stated that the 501st is restricted to Infantry(foot soldiers), all ground based forces and vehicles are able to be used.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Transport is the same as a vehicle. Lum has made it clear that it's the ground troops only, no vehicles. Just the clones advancing on foot.

No AT AT's, no ships, no AT ST's.

Get it?

Nah.

If they dont get that then you dont get portkeys.

Still ignoring it, I see.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Try again with that try again shit, whilst you continue to ignore my invitation to prove me wrong when I say you are totally full of shit about magic/energy, and just making stuff up to fit your appetite for the juice of SnapeSnake.. 🙂
Hey, I went by the thread rules and buried the ****ing clones, along with every argument in their favor. If Lum wants to change the conditions, up to him.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Nah.

If they dont get that then you dont get portkeys.

Still ignoring it, I see.

Again, for the umpteenth time, this aint your thread, you cant change the conditions.

Originally posted by KingD19
I was using a missile platform as an example, and yes, an AT-AT is a vehicle, but it is a strictly ground vehicle, unless it is specifically stated that the 501st is restricted to Infantry(foot soldiers), all ground based forces and vehicles are able to be used.

Exactamundo.

S'ok man, RJ thinks he is battling the Federation from Star Trek with their matter transporters, not realising that in order for the Clones to be there, that the Airforces will have to have dropped them off. 🙂