Will, magic comes from wizards. The wizard casts his/her spell, and it can only be undone by magic. The spell around Hogwarts is designed specifically to keep it's location hidden from muggles. Anything that is around Hogwarts that relies on or is based on electricity is useless, it goes haywire.
Blasters, clones vehicles, lightsabers, sensors, they will be rendered useless and there is nothing the clones can do about it.
So that means Hogwarts exists in a pocket dimension. Magic is shown to power up based upon the willpower of the user, therefore a group mentality or culture could create enough magical energy to barrier themselves from electronics. The SWG is far beyond what we have now, and may be able to negate the field which allows magic.
Originally posted by RobtardJK Rowlings words, not mine.
Yes, my comment on your barrel scraping and ever increasing rediculous attempts to pull some win in this thread was indeed accurate.Most people would have quit after their fourth or fifth "fail-safe" scenario-gimp blew up in their face, but you are one persistent SOB.
Seriously, the "but except for radios, because they're magic" doesn't make you laugh, at just how ridiculously childish HP is? Tesla and Marconi would shit themselves.
The fiendfyre attack was being challenged by saying Voldemort would be picked up on sensors. The sensors dont work at Hogwarts, nor do blasters, lightsabers or their vehicles, at least not efficiently.
If the clones are on the edge of the forbidden forest, they are practically unarmed.
You call it barrel scraping, I call it acknowledging the full extent of a wizards power.
You call me a HP fanboy, I say you have an insatiable hatred towards anything HP related.
Originally posted by Robtard
Then we're gone full circle, if the 50st can't find Hogwarts because of that "muggle clause", then this thread can't exist, logically.Why you try to bring this up again after it's been laid to rest for the sake of the fight, well, it isn't a mystery you silly sore loser.
Then the wizards win before the clones even get there. Or the clones are disarmed and killed easier than pie. Thanks for playing.
Cant go giving the clones the power to overcome the protective power, now can we?
And nice to see you are back to form, throwing insults around like that.
Originally posted by Dr Will HatchNo one in the SW universe can wield magic the way a wizard does, therefore they cannot lift the spell, therefore as they approach Hogwarts their weapons and vehicles are rendered useless.
So that means Hogwarts exists in a pocket dimension. Magic is shown to power up based upon the willpower of the user, therefore a group mentality or culture could create enough magical energy to barrier themselves from electronics. The SWG is far beyond what we have now, and may be able to negate the field which allows magic.
Big bad men with guns does not always equal victory, you know.
Thread starter already specified that the clones can see Hogwarts, despite their supposed "muggle" status. For obvious and logical reasons.
Taking away their weapons and making them completely defenseless is the saddest of sad gimping attempts.
You are a sore loser, ie you just can't accept that your beloved Harry Potter loses here. If you're going to try and twist what I said as me calling you a "loser in life overall", then you are indeed that kind of loser too.
Originally posted by Rogue JediThey can perform reconnaissance on the wizards biology.
No one in the SW universe can wield magic the way a wizard does, therefore they cannot lift the spell, therefore as they approach Hogwarts their weapons and vehicles are rendered useless.Big bad men with guns does not always equal victory, you know.
Originally posted by RobtardSad to acknowledge that magic is almost limitless? Spells are their weapons, just as blasters are the Clones weapons. I am merely saying that the wizards will use said spell as a weapon and defeat the clones.
Thread starter already specified that the clones can see Hogwarts, despite their supposed "muggle" status. For obvious and logical reasons.Taking away their weapons and making them completely defenceless is the saddest of sad gimping attempts.
You are a sore loser, ie you just can't accept that your beloved Harry Potter loses here. If you're going to try and twist what I said as me calling you a "loser in life overall", then you are indeed that kind of loser too.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Sad to acknowledge that magic is almost limitless? Spells are their weapons, just as blasters are the Clones weapons. I am merely saying that the wizards will use said spell as a weapon and defeat the clones.
Nothing of the sort has been acknowledged and making a thread where one side can't win is silly, so concessions are made. Might as well make a 'HP Wizards Vs Stromtroopers on Tatooine', but then say their wizards don't get their spells because they're not on Earth.
You're also ignoring the 'common neutral fighting area' rule, where powers/abilities etc. work across the board, despite the playing field. So, you're wrong in assuming the clones gear won't work. It does, end of story.
Not that, that really matters, as Jaden proved you wrong with the "electricity" aspects of Hogwarts and the distinct nature of SW power sources.
Originally posted by Robtard
And making a thread where one side can't win is silly, so concessions are made. Might as well make an 'HP Wizards Vs Swagger', but then say their wizards don't get their spells.You're also ignoring the 'common neutral fighting area', where powers/abilities work across the board, despite the playing field. So, you're wrong in assuming the clones gear won't work.
Not that, that really matters, as Jaden proved you wrong with the "electricity" aspects of the wizards spell and the distinct nature of SW power sources.
I didnt choose the battleground, did I?
Electricity is electricity, energy is energy, man. You haven't a leg to stand on when saying SW power sources are immune to the wizards protective barrier. That's like saying the fire in Yoda's hut is different than fire here on Earth. Or that the water is wetter in Kamino's oceans than in the pacific.
Originally posted by Robtard
And making a thread where one side can't win is silly, so concessions are made. Might as well make an 'HP Wizards Vs Stromtroopers on Tatooine', but then say their wizards don't get their spells because they're not on Earth.You're also ignoring the 'common neutral fighting area' rule, where powers/abilities etc. work across the board, despite the playing field. So, you're wrong in assuming the clones gear won't work. It does, end of story.
Not that, that really matters, as Jaden proved you wrong with the "electricity" aspects of Hogwarts and the distinct nature of SW power sources.
And to bring up another point, isn't the Force the sum of everything that exists in the universe? So by definition, Anakins Force powers would outstrip magic.
Originally posted by Rogue JediNo it doesn't, it means that the SWG found more efficient and useful power sources. Magic doesn't interrupt certain tech, like the Hogwarts Express which runs on mechanics. If it only interrupts electricity, it means that it is illogical and perhaps based on the will of magic users.
I didnt choose the battleground, did I?Electricity is electricity, energy is energy, man. You haven't a leg to stand on when saying SW power sources are immune to the wizards protective barrier. That's like saying the fire in Yoda's hut is different than fire here on Earth. Or that the water is wetter in Kamino's oceans than in the pacific.
Originally posted by Dr Will HatchTwo different universes here, man. The force has limits, magic almost no limits, ergo magic trumps the force.
And to bring up another point, isn't the Force the sum of everything that exists in the universe? So by definition, Anakins Force powers would outstrip magic.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I didnt choose the battleground, did I?Electricity is electricity, energy is energy, man. You haven't a leg to stand on when saying SW power sources are immune to the wizards protective barrier. That's like saying the fire in Yoda's hut is different than fire here on Earth. Or that the water is wetter in Kamino's oceans than in the pacific.
No you didn't, but the rule stands either way. All powers, abilities etc work, even playing field, son.
The protective barrier is designed to negate human technology of the day, cars, toasters, planes, everything except for radios, because they're magic (LOLZx10). The clone weapons and gear doesn't function of 120-240 volts, obviously. They're also not powered by a couple of 1.5v DD batteries. Not that is matters much, as the rule of an even playing field takes precedent.
Do keep crying and breaking the rules about this gimp you want, it's funny.
Originally posted by Dr Will HatchDude.....Hogwarts express:
No it doesn't, it means that the SWG found more efficient and useful power sources. Magic doesn't interrupt certain tech, like the Hogwarts Express which runs on mechanics. If it only interrupts electricity, it means that it is illogical and perhaps based on the will of magic users.
http://harrypotter.wikia.com/wiki/Hogwarts_Express
In striking contrast to the rest of the British Rail system, the Hogwarts Express takes the form of a large red steam engine. It is a magical device, like the Ministry cars, the Knight Bus, and Wizarding Wireless Network. It borrows its form and its intended function from real steam trains, but not the technology.
The passenger carriages contain compartments set off a corridor, allowing each compartment to function as a self-contained stage within the larger train. During the long journey to Hogwarts, students may enjoy treats from a trolley, such as Pumpkin Pasties and Chocolate Frogs. There are usually no adults aboard the Hogwarts Express except the witch with the tea trolley and the driver, and possibly the fireman, who is needed to shovel coal into a locomotives boiler to keep it running. However, The Train would probably be bewitched to refuel itself. Occasionally new teachers (namely, Remus Lupin as well as Horace Slughorn can be found aboard the train as well.
So the SWG has more efficient energy sources, it's still energy, nothing changes there.
Originally posted by RobtardThe barrier is designed to disrupt energy, period. The SW weapons all rely on energy to function, this energy will be going haywire, the weapons useless. No rules are being broken here, I am just stating facts about the barrier spell and what it would to the clones.
No you didn't, but the rule stands either way. All powers, abilities etc work, even playing field, son.The protective barrier is designed to negate human technology of the day, cars, toasters, planes, everything except for radios, because they're magic (LOLZx10). The clone weapons and gear doesn't function of 120-240 volts, obviously. They're also not powered by a couple of 1.5v DD batteries. Not that is matters much, as the rule of an even playing field takes precedent.
Do keep crying and breaking the rules about this gimp you want, it's funny.