Tattoos N Scars
Modern Day Drifter
Originally posted by Robtard
This is true.In regards to the Old Testament, there is good reason to believe the Jews borrowed from older surrounding cultures like the Egyptians and Assyrians. But that has nothing to do with this thread.
Indeed, I've read many books and articles comparing the Bible's events with other similar events in Egypt and Mesopotamia. Was Noah's story taken from Gilgamesh, or other similar stories which preceded it? I can see the argument. Obviously, I believe Noah's story is original and I believe a worldwide flood did occur in the past. However, I can't prove that with real world evidence, so I will not attempt to do so. However, it is a fact that the Genesis account and Gilgamesh are rooted in the same geographical region. I will also state that there is evidence for vast local flooding in that area, from the Euphrates overflooding its banks.
The Hebrew people trace their origins to Ur, in modern day Iraq. The Hebrew people would experience the same localized flooding as the individual who wrote the epic of Gilgamesh. With that said, was Noah a ripoff of Gilgamesh? I wouldn't think so. It could be an account of the same story, not an attempt at plagiarism.
However, the problem with these Flood stories is that they occur in every culture around the world. Many of these cultures were isolated from other cultures with similar stories. So, how do you harmonize these occurences? It could be argued that these stories occured randomly, by chance. That is plausible, but not very likely. It could be argued that the flood events were all localized to that culture's area. That is even more plausible. However, most of those accounts were too devastating to be only "localized" events. Most of these stories imply a much larger area of devastation, than just a local river exceeding its banks. Also, like most cultures, these flood events were said to occur in an ancient time...and nothing like it has never been witnessed again. How do you harmonize that with every Deluge story, unless there was a worldwide flood? Not an easy question to answer. That is my only "proof" of a worldwide flood...however, it can not be proved by science.
Getting back to Noah vs Gilgamesh, I believe Noah's account was not plagiarized, but a witness to the same account as Gilgamesh. If that argument doesn't hold water, then I would argue that all cultures have a unique Deluge story. Why should the Hebrew account be any different?