Best saber duelists

Started by Red Nemesis13 pages

I can live with that.

Thank you.

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
I never said it wasn't a factor, at ALL. I don't know why you guys keep reading so much into it. But to say that Anakin, Dooku, Maul, etc were prodigies but the most powerful Jedi Master before Luke/having the 2nd highest midichlorian count [b]ISN'T is a little ridiculous don't you think? [/B]
Unfortunately, I never said that either. I think we just got our wires crossed.

At least you didn't get your tubes tied.

not since i was younger... wait... what?

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
I've never even remotely implied Yoda's age had nothing to do with his skill. I dont expect TJ to know how to read but subjekt and RH come on. It was also a response to Marvel who said he had skill ONLY because of his skill. And don't pay any attention to Tj, he is just mad he got his ass kicked.

thats... not what I said.

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
and all im saying is that experience stacks with time thus it makes sense that someones skills would only improve with time unless they sit on their arse and not work on those skills at all.

😐

Top 10 in no real order, not including unknowns

Luke
Yoda
Sidious
Mace
Dooku
Obi Wan
Bane
Kas'im
Anakin
Caedus

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
thats... not what I said.

😐

Actually, what you said was this:


hows that dumb? anakin is the most inherently skilled duelist of the mythos. yoda is only where he is because he had 900 years to hone his abilities. if anakin or luke had half that time they would be literally gods without any peer or competition what so ever. id say the same for mace and kas'im.

Owned

how does that translate to:

he had skill ONLY because of his age

?

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
how does that translate to:

?

Are you serious? Must I teach you English?


yoda is only where he is because he had 900 years to hone his abilities.

I italicized "only".

yeah... all that means is hundreds of years of refinement has made him at the level that he is. that doesnt mean he isnt skilled. 😬

::😖igh::: Once again. Here is the last thing you said

and all im saying is that experience stacks with time thus it makes sense that someones skills would only improve with time unless they sit on their arse and not work on those skills at all.

Claiming that's what you originally stated. Here's what you originally stated:
yoda is only where he is because he had 900 years to hone his abilities.

That implies Yoda is ONLY where he is because of age. Please don't deny saying something you obviously said. IT insults my intelligence, especially when it's right there in front of me.

yoda IS where he is because of his age. but that does NOT mean he isnt inherently skilled regardless. 😬

Yoda probably reached his peak in terms of raw power quite a while ago.

I have a Q: Is Yoda from the OT as powerful as PT yoda?

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
yoda IS where he is because of his age. but that does NOT mean he isnt inherently skilled regardless. 😬

Oh jesus. I give up. Reading Comprehension for dummies.

because you are going to tell me the intentions of my own posts... 🙄

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
because you are going to tell me the intentions of my own posts... 🙄

Yes, because I showed you your contradictions and you still didn't get it.

or perhaps youre just seeing contradictions that dont exist. 😐

Right. You're done.

'kay.