Originally posted by h1a8
I don't like to use ABC logic unless it applies so
IMO I don't think Dark Phoenix can take a Celestial. No way in hell.
Yet Big G can take several of them if sufficiently fed. So it does depend on how well Galactus is fed.
When did Galactus defeat several Celestials? And only time when Galactus and Phoenix actually fought, he wasn't a match for her. It was actually quite an easy win for the Phoenix.
Dark Phoenix isn't WPOTC and is limited, but I still think she would be able to take him down.
Originally posted by Xplosive
When did Galactus defeat several Celestials? And only time when Galactus and Phoenix actually fought, he wasn't a match for her. It was actually quite an easy win for the Phoenix.
Dark Phoenix isn't WPOTC and is limited, but I still think she would be able to take him down.
I agree, as I said the normal Phoenix brought him to his knees. And while he was feeding, he wasn't starving.
Also to the poster that said she fled afterwards, that was because he pointed out that she had destoryed an entire star system before and she was ashamed. She won the battle of power, he won the battle of logic. And when did Galactus take on Celestials? Was it a "What if?" comic?
Originally posted by h1a8
So let me get this straight. You guys don't think that a fully fed Galactus can take on a few Celestials? Isn't he supposed to be equal to Eternity when fully fed?If you guys think dark phoenix can take on a fully fed Galactus and win then you shouldn't be discussing at this forum.
Thats your opinion. Has Galactus on panel ever taken on a celestial? And everyone has an opinion, we don't need to insult them over it.
Originally posted by h1a8
So let me get this straight. You guys don't think that a fully fed Galactus can take on a few Celestials? Isn't he supposed to be equal to Eternity when fully fed?If you guys think dark phoenix can take on a fully fed Galactus and win then you shouldn't be discussing at this forum.
It's different what we/you think. You said that he can take on several Celestials? Where did he do that?
Galactus wins. Atleast he has somekind of reason for the being weak at times (not eating). Rachel / Jean powers varie between being a alpha mutant and being as powerful as eternity.
Put if it just part of Phoenix Force then Galactus wins if he is well fed. On a bad day even the X-men can hurt Dark Phoenix.
Also Phoenix Force should be weaker than Galactus and Galactus should be stronger than one Celestial. Should be ... but isn`t necessarily.
Originally posted by Lostedge
Galactus wins. Atleast he has somekind of reason for the being weak at times (not eating). Rachel / Jean powers varie between being a alpha mutant and being as powerful as eternity.Put if it just part of Phoenix Force then Galactus wins if he is well fed. On a bad day even the X-men can hurt Dark Phoenix.
Also Phoenix Force should be weaker than Galactus and Galactus should be stronger than one Celestial. Should be ... but isn`t necessarily.
He recently owned Rulk...
Originally posted by Lostedge
Galactus wins. Atleast he has somekind of reason for the being weak at times (not eating). Rachel / Jean powers varie between being a alpha mutant and being as powerful as eternity.Put if it just part of Phoenix Force then Galactus wins if he is well fed. On a bad day even the X-men can hurt Dark Phoenix.
Also Phoenix Force should be weaker than Galactus and Galactus should be stronger than one Celestial. Should be ... but isn`t necessarily.
Why should the Phoenix Force be weaker? It's brought him to his knees before.
Originally posted by Xplosive
It's different what we/you think. You said that he can take on several Celestials? Where did he do that?
Superman has never taken several human dogs yet it is clear he can.
It's been stated Galactus can destroy the universe 10x over when fully powered. It also has been stated that he is equal to Eternity when at full power. The problem is that Galactus is almost never at full power when we see him. Thus we judge him based off seeing a non potentialized version. There is no evidence anywhere to support that a couple of Celestials combined with Dark Phoenix can destroy the universe 10x over.
Originally posted by h1a8
Superman has never taken several human dogs yet it is clear he can.
It's been stated Galactus can destroy the universe 10x over when fully powered. It also has been stated that he is equal to Eternity when at full power. The problem is that Galactus is almost never at full power when [b]we see him. Thus we judge him based off seeing a non potentialized version. There is no evidence anywhere to support that a couple of Celestials combined with Dark Phoenix can destroy the universe 10x over. [/B]
Originally posted by Xplosive
It's different what we/you think. You said that he can take on several Celestials? Where did he do that?
????
Originally posted by h1a8
Superman has never taken several human dogs yet it is clear he can.
Not a good comparison and still didn't do it. I do think Galactus is more powerful than a Celestial though.
Originally posted by h1a8
It's been stated Galactus can destroy the universe 10x over when fully powered. It also has been stated that he is equal to Eternity when at full power. The problem is that Galactus is almost never at full power when we see him. Thus we judge him based off seeing a non potentialized version. There is no evidence anywhere to support that a couple of Celestials combined with Dark Phoenix can destroy the universe 10x over.
A small portion of the Phoenix Force was able to collapse the Multiverse.
Originally posted by Xplosive
Not a good comparison and still didn't do it. I do think Galactus is more powerful than a Celestial though.A small portion of the Phoenix Force was able to collapse the Multiverse.
This is Dark Phoenix and not the Phoenix Force. Also, I don't believe the Phoenix Force can collaspe a multiverse or a universe. Sorry. 🙁
Originally posted by h1a8
This is Dark Phoenix and not the Phoenix Force. Also, I don't believe the Phoenix Force can collaspe a multiverse or a universe. Sorry. 🙁
Dark Phoenix is Phoenix Force. It is limited though, but so is portion of the Phoenix Force.
Yeah, you don't believe it, but that doesn't matter, since it was already on the way and also Roma stated that.