Anakin Skywalker (ROTS), Galen Marek, and Luke Skywalker (ROTJ) vs. Darth Sidious
The three great apprentices vs. the master of the Dark Side. Who wins? This is Darth Sidious full power from Revenge of the Sith when he was fighting Yoda.
1. Saber
2.Force
3.All Out
My bet is on the Light Siders. It would be a tough battle, but the Force would be on their side.
I don't know how weak Luke actually was during ROTJ. Think about this. At the beginning of ESB, he was barely able to pull his lightsaber from the snow. He goes, spends some time with Yoda, and his power increases by massive amounts. He is able to partially lift his X-wing, which would have been thousands of times more difficult than pulling out his lightsaber. Plus, he trains more with Yoda before leaving for Cloud City. Yeah, he had FAR less time to train, but at the Jedi Temple most of the training went towards diplomacy skills and common knowledge (like math and how to write). Yoda and Obi-wan were creating a weapon to destroy Vader and the Emperor. In any case, I think Luke was not nearly as weak as everyone seems to think by ROTJ.
I think the Lightsiders win.
No sir. They didn't only learn math and writing. When OB1 went to talk to Yoda when he was training the younglings, he wasn't teaching them their times tables. They were blocking remotes with their lightsabers. I don't recall seeing desks and blackboards. Yes, of course the younger ones had to learn these things as well, but that was the point in time when the Jedi thrived and were the most combat effective and most powerful with the force.
Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Prove "were the most combat effective and most powerful with the force."Edit: BTW, that ignores the fact that Luke's power was actually pretty significant after his training with Yoda.
I am really unsure who wins. I do know that one powerful gout of lightning from Sidious, and Luke's dead. I don't even see how Anakin survives.
Also: If we use the dark side ending of The Force Unleashed as a "what if", then Galen is really no match for Sidious. I am not sure how that works though.
Originally posted by Darth_GlentractThe fact that we GL says that the Jedi we see in the PT is the "Jedi in their prime," says enough. That would be their prime in all facets.
Prove "were the most combat effective and most powerful with the force."Edit: BTW, that ignores the fact that Luke's power was actually pretty significant after his training with Yoda.
I know you don't like when the creator says something that goes against what you want, but you have to remember Lucas>>>>>>>>>Glentract
This is a tough one, Galen in the game at least, looked like he was on a level of a more powerful version of Sidious, so by that you could say that with the help of 2 more combatants the team would win, although i didn't read the book, how did the fight in the book went, was Galen like equal to Sidious in the book as well?