Superman's Hardest Punch vs Thor's Hardest Mjolnir Slam

Started by ColossusGrundy50 pages

Superman has caught Thor's hammer swing before. Thor swung Mjolnir and Supes caught it and proceeded to deck Thor afterwards, he would NOT have caught another Superman's punch........period.

Supes' Punch >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Mjolnir strike.

Originally posted by ColossusGrundy
Superman has caught Thor's hammer swing before. Thor swung Mjolnir and Supes caught it and proceeded to deck Thor afterwards, he would NOT have caught another Superman's punch........period.

Supes' Punch >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Mjolnir strike.

More like ">=" IMHO

Originally posted by Spire
Only that you did lie and you failed to understand that I feel that they are about the same barring a godblast so...
How are they the same? Can you name me one thing that he has done that's impressive as some of Thor's feats with his fists?

You don't even understand what a godblast is.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Oh I don't deny it. Though the page before the first scan Superman was attacked by Solaar and Radioactive man, they used Kryptonite Radiation and Red Sun Radiation to "drive out the juice out of Superman" Vision sacrified himself to charge Superman with his remaining solar energy (from his cells he was badly damaged). This gave Clark the chance to defeat them.

So when you look at just one more page, which quan forgot to mention 😉, you see that it was an depowered superman who tried to break the wall. Mjolnir wasn't depowered, though thor was hurt. So yes an "healthy" Mjolnir did the greater work 😉.

Though I have to give Quan some respect. Showing scans out of context to prove an point is quite cunning 😄.

Thanks for the cue.

Superman was just recently powered back up and was also using Cap's shield to aid in the entire time. It's on the very same page,lol that he gains his power back.

I guess you can't stand the fact Supes needed a marvel character's aid, a marvel character's shield, and Thor's hammer to do what he did.

Originally posted by quanchi112

Superman was just recently powered back up and was also using Cap's shield to aid in the entire time. It's on the very same page,lol that he gains his power back.

I guess you can't stand the fact Supes needed a marvel character's aid, a marvel character's shield, and Thor's hammer to do what he did.

So you think that an damaged Vision can restore superman to 100% with the rest energy he has in his solar cells? Quan, is this what you are trying to tell? 😬

Not recently, seconds before he got the hammer. He was depowered.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
So you think that an damaged Vision can restore superman to 100% with the rest energy he has in his solar cells? Quan, is this what you are trying to tell? 😬

Not recently, seconds before he got the hammer. He was depowered.

I think the remaining solar energy definitely brought Superman back into the fight because he was shot full of solar energy. He was re-energized and that's what the panel supports. You leaving this part out in your post is hilarious. It happened on the very same page. Without Vision he was a goner.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I think the remaining solar energy definitely brought Superman back into the fight because he was shot full of solar energy. He was re-energized and that's what the panel supports. You leaving this part out in your post is hilarious. It happened on the very same page. Without Vision he was a goner.

Quan we agree here. Superman was depleted and at the mercy of his enemies, the sacrifice of Vision just gave him enough power to defeat his tormentors but surely not enough to restore him to full health. He was battered and depowered, means not in his best state.

Originally posted by quanchi112
How are they the same? Can you name me one thing that he has done that's impressive as some of Thor's feats with his fists?

You don't even understand what a godblast is.

What are these feats?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor has affected much more powerful beings with his hammer than Zeus. He also went toe to toe with Zeus before with neither side able to gain the edge.
no. zeus was just playing with him realy. while thor did all out blast and everything.
and who has thor taken down who is greater than zeus? that would be pis

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Quan we agree here. Superman was depleted and at the mercy of his enemies, the sacrifice of Vision just gave him enough power to defeat his tormentors but surely not enough to restore him to full health. He was battered and depowered, means not in his best state.
There's no proof he wasn't restored back to full health. I think he was, but there isn't proof either way. You assuming he was depowered and leaving out the part where Vision juiced him up is purposely leaving out the context.
Originally posted by Spire
What are these feats?
Hurting Galactus is one. Now please name something that compares and I'll proceed.

Originally posted by quanchi112
There's no proof he wasn't restored back to full health. I think he was, but there isn't proof either way. You assuming he was depowered and leaving out the part where Vision juiced him up is purposely leaving out the context. Hurting Galactus is one. Now please name something that compares and I'll proceed.

I wrote "the sacrifice of Vision just gave him enough power "

before that in my very first statement
"Vision sacrified himself to charge Superman with his remaining solar energy (from his cells he was badly damaged). This gave Clark the chance to defeat them."

I never left Vision out of this. I just stated that he was not in his best health.

So you think that it is arguable that the energy in the cells of an almost "dead" Vision ("internal damage...can't...stay...active"😉 is enough to restore superman. Almost "dead-Visions energy cells = the power of an sun`? Wow, just wow.

Originally posted by quanchi112
There's no proof he wasn't restored back to full health. I think he was, but there isn't proof either way. You assuming he was depowered and leaving out the part where Vision juiced him up is purposely leaving out the context. Hurting Galactus is one. Now please name something that compares and I'll proceed.

Actually, name some more.

You have been reading comics right?

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
I wrote "the sacrifice of Vision just gave him enough power "

before that in my very first statement
"Vision sacrified himself to charge Superman with his remaining solar energy (from his cells he was badly damaged). This gave Clark the chance to defeat them."

I never left Vision out of this. I just stated that he was not in his best health.

So you think that it is arguable that the energy in the cells of an almost "dead" Vision ("internal damage...can't...stay...active"😉 is enough to restore superman. Almost "dead-Visions energy cells = the power of an sun`? Wow, just wow.

Ah, my bad I didn't see you wrote the part about Vision.

I think it restored him back to full health.

Originally posted by Spire
Actually, name some more.

You have been reading comics right?

I knew you couldn't name anything. You never do. I guess I win the debate with one feat. That was pretty easy.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I knew you couldn't name anything. You never do. I guess I win the debate with one feat. That was pretty easy.

So you haven't been reading comics?

You should start. Start with Thor too so you can get back to me before 4 months.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Ah, my bad I didn't see you wrote the part about Vision.

I think it restored him back to full health.

Nevermind, just a game 🙂. Opinions differ.

Originally posted by Spire
So you haven't been reading comics?

You should start. Start with Thor too so you can get back to me before 4 months.

I asked you for feats and your response is begging for info. What a brilliant maneuver. It means you concede as you really have no clue. You should read some Superman every once in a while. I'll tell you what leaf through the respect thread and get back to me.
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Nevermind, just a game 🙂. Opinions differ.
Do you honestly feel that Superman's punches are equal to Thor's hammer?

Originally posted by quanchi112
I asked you for feats and your response is begging for info. What a brilliant maneuver. It means you concede as you really have no clue.

No, I'm asking if you have another feat.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Do you honestly feel that Superman's punches are equal to Thor's hammer?

Yes. Honestly. Superman has great feats with his punches. Almost destroying the moon when he punched the Black Racer, Punching through the imperiex probes etc.

But not all versions of Superman, of course. Some are weaker some are stronger.

Byrne Superman was weaker then Thor for example.

OWAW had Loeb on his side. He was quite uber. Funny to read but ridiculous. FC Superman was a great read, powerwise in his PC days though this time with an good story.

PC supes was ridiculous.

All-Star Superman was like PC Supes though again with an great story.

Don't get me wrong. Though i do think that Superman is a little bit stronger then thor and faster. Thor has enough powers to win 50-50 against Superman IMHO.

Originally posted by Spire
No, I'm asking if you have another feat.
I asked you for one feat. You can't even do that. Then you countered and I gave you one awesome feat from Thor to contend with. Your response give me another Thor feat. That's called dodging.
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Yes. Honestly. Superman has great feats with his punches. Almost destroying the moon when he punched the Black Racer, Punching through the imperiex probes etc.

But not all versions of Superman, of course. Some are weaker some are stronger.

Byrne Superman was weaker then Thor for example.

OWAW had Loeb on his side. He was quite uber. Funny to read but ridiculous. FC Superman was a great read, powerwise in his PC days though this time with an good story.

PC supes was ridiculous.

All-Star Superman was like PC Supes though again with an great story.

Don't get me wrong. Though i do think that Superman is a little bit stronger then thor and faster. Thor has enough powers to win 50-50 against Superman IMHO.

You really feel like almost destroying the moon means he's equal to Thor?

This is new earth superman as well.

Originally posted by ColossusGrundy
Superman has caught Thor's hammer swing before. Thor swung Mjolnir and Supes caught it and proceeded to deck Thor afterwards, he would NOT have caught another Superman's punch........period.

Supes' Punch >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Mjolnir strike.

not canon sleep1

Originally posted by Philosophía
He doesn't 'take it as canon'. It is canon. Forum rules and it actually being non-canon are two different things.

👆