Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
No, I answered your question with another question.Kirk wont be able to see the wizards, he will likely enter the atmosphere looking for them, Voldy will see him, apparate aboard, pwn them. Kirk will NOT raze the planet, so dont even bring that up.
No, you dodged it and now you're catering a scenario where you little favorites can win. Silly, but to be expected of you, just how you operate in these threads, ZERO objectivity.
Having the Enterprise enter the atmosphere, looking for an opponent they can't see (according to your logic) isn't a fight, now is it. Why would it enter the atmosphere, it can do more from orbit/space.
Originally posted by RobtardHows it gonna see the wizards, Rob?
No, you dodged it and now you're catering a scenario where you little favorites can win. Silly, but to be expected of you, just how you operate in these threads, ZERO objectivity.Having the Enterprise enter the atmosphere, looking for an opponent they can't see (according to your logic) isn't a fight, now is it. Why would it enter the atmosphere, it can do more from orbit/space.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Hows it gonna see the wizards, Rob?
It couldn't because of magic, which is beyond the restrictions of science.
So again, why would the Enterprise enter the atmosphere looking for something it can't see, when it can scan the entire planet just the same from space?
To have a fight like this, we have to assume the Enterprise has means to "see" the wizards/Hogwarts, if that is the case, it obliterates them from orbit. This is yet another stupid match-up.
Originally posted by RobtardWouldnt that be gimping the wizards?
It couldn't because of magic, which is beyond the restrictions of science.So again, why would the Enterprise enter the atmosphere looking for something it can't see, when it can scan the entire planet just the same from space?
To have a fight like this, we have to assume the Enterprise has means to "see" the wizards/Hogwarts, if that is the case, it obliterates them from orbit. This is yet another stupid match-up.
Originally posted by dadudemonHow do you think the wizards keep muggles from finding Hogwarts castle? There is a spell that keeps it hidden.
So, lemme get this straight.You are introducing a trait in the wizards that doesn't exist without the invisibility cloak?
You do know that wizards are not invisible, right?
I think you're confusing Dementors for wizards.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
How do you think the wizards keep muggles from finding Hogwarts castle? There is a spell that keeps it hidden.
It's not invisibility, though. It's pocket realities.
And, even if it's just a plain ol' invisible castle, someone in the UK would have eventually run into it. The UK is not some massive barren wasteland.
So, it points to a pocket reality, just the same as that hidden train platform, Diagon Alley, and #12 Grimmauld Place.
Originally posted by dadudemonWell, from what I gather, it's like this:
It's not invisibility, though. It's pocket realities.And, even if it's just a plain ol' invisible castle, someone in the UK would have eventually run into it. The UK is not some massive barren wasteland.
So, it points to a pocket reality, just the same as that hidden train platform, Diagon Alley, and #12 Grimmauld Place.
If a muggle nears the castle, they are kinda "shooed" away. They suddenly remember they have somewhere important to be, or they get the feeling that they shouldn't be there, and they leave.