HP Doomsday VS Beta Ray Bill

Started by comicfan1114 pages
Originally posted by Zeuodin
No need. Someone already said something about the chest emblems, and every thing that was shown was the conflict in which he died. Doomsday never came back from the dead of Entropy. He was plucked from the time stream before he was destroyed so the only time he could have died in H/P was at Darksied's hands. Now. I have soundly trounced you.

Agreed 😄 😄 😄

Originally posted by carver9
For someone that you have so much faith in durability wise, he has been killed at least 3 times. 😕
No he wasn't 😬

let's go over it one more time for the slow folks.

H/P doomsday never died at the hands of entropy because he was plucked from the time stream just before he was destroyed.

He was shown in count down as dying in the Hunter Prey Story.

Thus the only time he died was at the hands of DS's Omegas.

Is that clear? Ok. Now that we have that discussion finalized.

HP Doomsday

Originally posted by Zeuodin
let's go over it one more time for the slow folks.

H/P doomsday never died at the hands of entropy because he was plucked from the time stream just before he was destroyed.

He was shown in count down as dying in the Hunter Prey Story.

Thus the only time he died was at the hands of DS's Omegas.

Is that clear? Ok. Now that we have that discussion finalized.

he didn't die due to the omegas, though, according to the writer...

i doubt one page in countdown retcons that... did something else?

Originally posted by -Pr-
he didn't die due to the omegas, though...
Yes he did. He didn't die due to entropy. The Countdown showed that he died during that conflict/Story line. It was the omegas.

Originally posted by Zeuodin
Yes he did. He didn't die due to entropy. The Countdown showed that he died during that conflict/Story line. It was the omegas.

even though dan jurgens said he didn't?

Originally posted by Zeuodin
let's go over it one more time for the slow folks.

H/P doomsday never died at the hands of entropy because he was plucked from the time stream just before he was destroyed.

He was shown in count down as dying in the Hunter Prey Story.

Thus the only time he died was at the hands of DS's Omegas.

Is that clear? Ok. Now that we have that discussion finalized.

He died in your opinion you can shout thats it's fact all you want but it isn't 😐

Originally posted by -Pr-
he didn't die due to the omegas, though, according to the writer...

i doubt one page in countdown retcons that... did something else?

The writer was retconned years later when DD was pulled from the entropy. His story was also retconned when countdown was published 15 years later. Two later archs revealed DD died by something else. Not entropy. It was the omegas.

Originally posted by iceman24567
He died in your opinion you can shout thats it's fact all you want but it isn't 😐
And According to Countdown He died. Are you going to argue that? We already know he was pulled from the time stream before entropy killed him. So tell me, what killed him in the story?

Originally posted by Zeuodin
The writer was retconned years later when DD was pulled from the entropy. His story was also retconned when countdown was published 15 years later. Two later archs revealed DD died by something else. Not entropy. It was the omegas.

i seriously doubt one background panel in countdown actually counts.

what other arcs?

Originally posted by -Pr-
even though dan jurgens said he didn't?
Dan Jurgens said Superman was a trillion times more powerful than Thor too. Writer statements equal=Shit.

Originally posted by -Pr-
i seriously doubt one background panel in countdown actually counts.

what other arcs?

It happened in comics. You telling me it doesn't count why? because you don't like it? It happened. It was said. Doomsday was killed in the arch. Now by what? It wasn't entropy. So tell me, WHAT WAS IT THAT KILLED HIM?

Originally posted by Zeuodin
Dan Jurgens said Superman was a trillion times more powerful than Thor too. Writer statements equal=Shit.

he recanted the thor vs superman part.

not the same thing, anyways.

Originally posted by Zeuodin
It happened in comics. You telling me it doesn't count why? because you don't like it? It happened. It was said. Doomsday was killed in the arch. Now by what? It wasn't entropy. So tell me, WHAT WAS IT THAT KILLED HIM?

calm down, first of all.

i asked you what arcs retconned it. it's a fair question.

Wow if he actually said that he must be on crack since he did write over 80 Thor comics. Where did you get this info Zeuodin? any interview links?

Originally posted by kgkg
Wow if he actually said that he must be on crack since he did write over 80 Thor comics. Where did you get this info Zeuodin? any interview links?

http://www.comicboards.com/jurgens-rc.php

Originally posted by -Pr-
he recanted the thor vs superman part.

not the same thing, anyways.

calm down, first of all.

i asked you what arcs retconned it. it's a fair question.


Doomsday was pulled from the time stream I think during the Imperiex Saga. That retconned his death in H/P. Then Count down comes along and says he died in H/P. They show him fighting DS. The only thing left is what is feasable, the Omegas Killed him. It's the only time in DD history that we see him stop moving, stop fighting, stop killing for a prolongued period of time. after he's hit with the Omegas.

Originally posted by Zeuodin
No need. Someone already said something about the chest emblems, and every thing that was shown was the conflict in which he died. Doomsday never came back from the dead of Entropy. He was plucked from the time stream before he was destroyed so the only time he could have died in H/P was at Darksied's hands. Now. I have soundly trounced you.
lol

Chest emblems have little to do with what I said.

He died against an Imperiex Probe then. Because it wasn't just a conflict, it was a war until he finally met Imperiex at the end of countless days or some shit.
Also, I realize that. Brainiac plucked a floating Doomsday from it right before he was erased... not neccisarily dead.

There's also the explanation of that being his first real appearance since DOS as well. Which would be him coming back from the dead anyway, and still fits with the narration.

What the pictures seem to be, are the arcs he died in, or the arcs he came back. To put it simply, and without going into speculation after speculation.

Then there's also what Pauly said, and that Jurgens said Doomsday didn't die by Darkseid.

Originally posted by Zeuodin
Doomsday was pulled from the time stream I think during the Imperiex Saga. That retconned his death in H/P. Then Count down comes along and says he died in H/P. They show him fighting DS. The only thing left is what is feasable, the Omegas Killed him. It's the only time in DD history that we see him stop moving, stop fighting, stop killing for a prolongued period of time. after he's hit with the Omegas.

so we're using the countdown thing, then? that's all i'm asking.

Originally posted by Zeuodin
And According to Countdown He died. Are you going to argue that? We already know he was pulled from the time stream before entropy killed him. So tell me, what killed him in the story?
Oh i am sorry you are absolutely right even though you aren't 😬