Mickey the Pikey versus Mike Tyson.....

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
The birds and air were obviously already there in the first place.

So now you are suggesting that it was a contained biosphere? Complete with its own weather patterns? It rained, it snowed, the wind blew, animals came and went as did people. The light shown etc etc. In other words things got in and out. The only thing that had issues was an entity that was a specific enemy of the occupants of Hogwarts. As such having wards against it makes sence. The same can not be said for having wards against Clone Troopers they have never encountered.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Look at the scenes in the castle. You see any electrical sockets? Any TV's? PC's? Anything electric powered? [/B]

No, but that doesn't mean such things wouldn't work their. Simply that by and large the wizards chose not to use them. Though as I said earlier they did have indoor plumbing which suggests a certain level of technology does work and while it could be a completly mechanical system. Their is also a chance that it has electrical components to operate the water tanks/pumps etc. Again a locomotive puffing away steam like one would expect from an external combustion engine came with in eye site of the castle, flash bulbs on cameras worked, not to mention I think we say lighting from time time. Suggesting once again that electricity was still functioning on the premises.

Originally posted by Riot-Gear
So now you are suggesting that it was a contained biosphere? Complete with its own weather patterns? It rained, it snowed, the wind blew, animals came and went as did people. The light shown etc etc. In other words things got in and out. The only thing that had issues was an entity that was a specific enemy of the occupants of Hogwarts. As such having wards against it makes sence. The same can not be said for having wards against Clone Troopers they have never encountered.

No, but that doesn't mean such things wouldn't work their. Simply that by and large the wizards chose not to use them. Though as I said earlier they did have indoor plumbing which suggests a certain level of technology does work and while it could be a completly mechanical system. Their is also a chance that it has electrical components to operate the water tanks/pumps etc. Again a locomotive puffing away steam like one would expect from an external combustion engine came with in eye site of the castle, flash bulbs on cameras worked, not to mention I think we say lighting from time time. Suggesting once again that electricity was still functioning on the premises.

Well, Dumbledore did say it was designed to keep "dark forces" out. Clone troopers out to kill wizards woud certainly fall under this category.

Magically powered, dude, magically enchanted, you do know what that means, right? And Hogwarts was lit by candles.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Well, Dumbledore did say it was designed to keep "dark forces" out. Clone troopers out to kill wizards woud certainly fall under this category.

Yet Draco Malfoy - a death eater planning on murdering Dumbledore, and allowing other dark wizards entry onto school grounds, was able to walk around with ease.....

HMMMMMMMMM..........CURIOUS......

Oh also, shut up about the electrical thing. goblet of fire - they use like a record player, and a whole band plays electrical instruments at the Yule Ball.

Also Lee Jordan does commentary for the quidditch matches on his little radio thing.

Originally posted by Quincy
Yet Draco Malfoy - a death eater planning on murdering Dumbledore, and allowing other dark wizards entry onto school grounds, was able to walk around with ease.....

HMMMMMMMMM..........CURIOUS......

Oh also, shut up about the electrical thing. goblet of fire - they use like a record player, and a whole band plays electrical instruments at the Yule Ball.

Also Lee Jordan does commentary for the quidditch matches on his little radio thing.

Draco was granted passage because Filch allowed it.

All magically enchanted shit, dude.

Originally posted by Quincy
Yet Draco Malfoy - a death eater planning on murdering Dumbledore, and allowing other dark wizards entry onto school grounds, was able to walk around with ease.....

HMMMMMMMMM..........CURIOUS......

Oh also, shut up about the electrical thing. goblet of fire - they use like a record player, and a whole band plays electrical instruments at the Yule Ball.

Also Lee Jordan does commentary for the quidditch matches on his little radio thing.

Oh oh! RJ just got rectally probed by Dr.Quincy MD.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Oh oh! RJ just got rectally probed by Dr.Quincy MD.

Nah, pwned back like Trapper John md:

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Draco was granted passage because Filch allowed it.

All magically enchanted shit, dude.

Not exactly pwned.

Your blanket non-trump card fails.

There were electric amplifiers and power for all the backline, the PA dont run on magic mate.
Ive known a few magicians over the years.
And none of them have ever been able to fuel any band ive ever been in's live rig.

So all this "No electricity" bollocks can stop right now.

Without in-movie confirmation, you are speculating that the band's gear is powered by a very verrrrrry vague "Enchanted spell".

Occum's razor dictates that we simply accept that some good old fashioned 240 volt supply was active. 🙂

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Not exactly pwned.

Your blanket non-trump card fails.

There were electric amplifiers and power for all the backline, the PA dont run on magic mate.
Ive known a few magicians over the years.
And none of them have ever been able to fuel any band ive ever been in's live rig.

So all this "No electricity" bollocks can stop right now.

Without in-movie confirmation, you are speculating that the band's gear is powered by a very verrrrrry vague "Enchanted spell".

Occum's razor dictates that we simply accept that some good old fashioned 240 volt supply was active. 🙂

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
You do realize that you are comparing reeal life magicians (which is bullshit BTW) to a fictional movie (which, despite my insistance to the contrary is ALSO bullshit)? Are you really that desperate? Wait a second, I'm late for my masturbators anonymous meeting, ****!!!

Fixed for you, see...?
And yes, as you can see, I am. Although there is no desperation.
For they will be as much good as each other when it comes to facing off with the empire.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Fixed for you, see...?
And yes, as you can see, I am. Although there is no desperation.
For they will be as much good as each other when it comes to facing off with the empire.

That mustve been the shit you were talking into them. 🙂

Or sumthin......

Actually it was the 1st thing. 🙂

Or sumthin......

somethin':

Being the pile of effluence you so readily produce for us here in keystroke form..?

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Or sumthin......

Just as I suspected.

Sure, why not.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Well, Dumbledore did say it was designed to keep "dark forces" out. Clone troopers out to kill wizards woud certainly fall under this category.

Except that Filch, Draco, Snape. Were all able to come and go and they all meant harm to Hogwarts. Further unlike Death Eaters, Clone Troopers are not evil per se.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Magically powered, dude, magically enchanted, you do know what that means, right? And Hogwarts was lit by candles. [/B]

You have evidence that electronics/technology don't work, right? Because if you don't your assertion is mere speculation that runs counter to a host of on screen evidence.

As far as my mention of light. I was speaking of exterior light, not the candles inside, you know light given off by the sun and the moon. That like air and animals. Has no problem breaching the shield charm. In fact so far the only thing that has bounced off the shield charm is a Death Eater. The very being the shield would have been put up, to keep out.

Not realy the best evidence that it'll keep out everything. So now that we have established that the shield charm is to specific to help and their is no evidence of an anti-tech spell in effect. It comes down to the respective fire power and skill of the two groups in question.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Sure, why not.

The "Why not" that you have failed to explain is the "why Harry and co will not be slaughtered by the minions of Palpatine.

And youve failed repeatedly.
As do your spite threads normally.

😮‍💨