Originally posted by Nephthys
I'm sure it will for the two people who've used it. But no, its element of surprise effect is useless.
The two people? Dude, all the death eaters can do it, the entire OOTP can do it, Voldy and Dumbles can do it, where have you been? And it's not useless, get off that. The wizards that can do it will be all over the place, everywhere at once, jumping around like Nightcrawler in the oval office.
Not really. Give a scenario.
Death eaters half apparating around wreaking havoc, casting spells as they go, you know, pretty much obliterating everything in their path.
I think you mean fallible but whatever, precog is at least enough to tell where everyone is, it only gets overwhelmed when your trying to predict the paths of around 8-10 blaster bolts at a time, a threat the size of Voldemort or Dumbledore is not going to be missed if its going to appear right in front of you. Not to mention that jedi precog was being weakened throughout the movies by Sidious darkening the Force. So in scenario 2 at least it will be alot stronger.
And where was Lukes precog when Palpy zapped him? Where was Palpys when Vader tossed him? Where was it when Mace got pwned?
Shown in film? By whom?
Hermione, THBP.
Wouldn't have any effect, Jedi can fight blindfolded as you've been told before. Also about your thoery that they'd be 'put off', Jedi don't actually use their eyes for the fighting most of the time. Considering they fight by waving a highly focused light right in front of their faces, that would be a little counter-productive.
Just saying, it certainly wouldn't help matters.
Anakin has used it before he became Darth Vader and there is the point that he wasn't shown or in a position to be taught it after becoming Vader, so logic dictates that he would have had it before that time. Unless you're saying no as the thread-starter?
I am saying that Vader is not in this thread. I am saying that the force scream is a Vader feat. Also it would probably take out several Jedi as well.
Fine.
Good.
EU is not bullshit. I'll accept that the feats cannot be shown (which was why I put them in brakets, so as not to be actually seriously be trying to use them), but the stuff that supports on-screen feats such as speed, mentality etc. That I'm using. It doesn't contradict the facts on screen in any way.
No, I love the EU too, it's just that it is not allowed here. All we can use is what is shown onscreen, that's the new rule Impediment imposed.
I never said he was.
You said he was shown in TPM, I was merely saying that this thread is about ROTS, nevermind.
Force Speed. If Voldemort or Dumbledore triy to use that long ass spell then someones going to feel it, run up to him and stab him in the face, or precog it and stab him, or snap his neck, or crush his head.
Voldemort can camp out on the roof of the Temple, casting the spell far out of reach of the Jedi. If he was on the ground, and a Jedi came at him, he simply apparates away and repeats the spell.
There is no escaping the fiendfyre, man. The few Jedi that TK it away from them, IF they can, will be death spelled. Voldemort controls the fiendfyre as if it were an extension of him, as does Dumbles, doubtful that TTK will affect it. The wizards can do much more than the Jedi, there's no use trying to figure on a Jedi victory here.