Originally posted by ScytheThen your opinion holds no water here. If you can't say HOW the Jedi will win, HOW they will counter fiendfyre, HOW they will contend with wizards flying around everywhere at over 100 mph, then you should probably not post.
Yeah, that's neat man. Not going to change my opinion.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Then your opinion holds no water here. If you can't say HOW the Jedi will win, HOW they will counter fiendfyre, HOW they will contend with wizards flying around everywhere at over 100 mph, then you should probably not post.
Why should I script out a huge ass written battle? No one else is. I would think that Jedi training covers shit coming at them at high speeds. Not to mention who knows how many futuristic gimmicks they probably utilize in their training, but hey, we never see any of that, so anything going faster than a thrown object or another lightsaberr in battle would be too much for them. Heh, but fine. They can come as fast as they want, if Yoda could handle a huge pillar using the force, he can shove wizards off their lame ass brooms. Since he's not alone, the rest of the Jedis move in for a kill. For sure several Jedis die, but they still win.
Originally posted by Scythe
Why should I script out a huge ass written battle? No one else is. I would think that Jedi training covers shit coming at them at high speeds. Not to mention who knows how many futuristic gimmicks they probably utilize in their training, but hey, we never see any of that, so anything going faster than a thrown object or another lightsaberr in battle would be too much for them. Heh, but fine. They can come as fast as they want, if Yoda could handle a huge pillar using the force, he can shove wizards off their lame ass brooms. Since he's not alone, the rest of the Jedis move in for a kill. For sure several Jedis die, but they still win.
Firstly, Jedi is already pluralized, there is no "Jedi's."
Secondly, shield charms will block any force spell the Jedi throw at the wizards.
Third, a wall of flame bearing down on the Jedi will make them scatter, easy pickin's for the death spell.
The wizards will be half apparating at breakneck speeds all around the Jedi, and the roof in the Jedi temple is high as hell. No way in hell do they contend with all the wizards can throw at them.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Firstly, Jedi is already pluralized, there is no "Jedi's."Secondly, shield charms will block any force spell the Jedi throw at the wizards.
Third, a wall of flame bearing down on the Jedi will make them scatter, easy pickin's for the death spell.
The wizards will be half apparating at breakneck speeds all around the Jedi, and the roof in the Jedi temple is high as hell. No way in hell do they contend with all the wizards can throw at them.
1. F*ck if I knew, not that big of a SW fan either, though I do love it much more than HP.
2. Jedi utilize spells now, what the hell...?
3. That's your scripted fight.
At this point it doesn't matter because the battle has already been decided by you, good job I guess, so now that it's settled, I won't waste any more time in here.
For the record: You really can't make these threads, RJ. I've read people post how you don't now a few times, but I see it now, more thought needs to be put into threads like these. It's why I don't make any of them. You can't just watch a film/show, get a hard-on, then proceed to open a thread with your favorites already cast into victory.
Originally posted by ScytheNothing scripted about it, just saying that the wizards have waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay too many powers for the Jedi to handle.
1. F*ck if I knew, not that big of a SW fan either, though I do love it much more than HP.2. Jedi utilize spells now, what the hell...?
3. That's your scripted fight.
At this point it doesn't matter because the battle has already been decided by you, good job I guess, so now that it's settled, I won't waste any more time in here.
The Jedi have nothing resembling shield charms.
Originally posted by Scythe
For the record: You really can't make these threads, RJ. I've read people post how you don't now a few times, but I see it now, more thought needs to be put into threads like these. It's why I don't make any of them. You can't just watch a film/show, get a hard-on, then proceed to open a thread with your favorites already cast into victory.
Originally posted by ScytheAw, a tear?
1. F*ck if I knew, not that big of a SW fan either, though I do love it much more than HP.2. Jedi utilize spells now, what the hell...?
3. That's your scripted fight.
At this point it doesn't matter because the battle has already been decided by you, good job I guess, so now that it's settled, I won't waste any more time in here.
For the record: You really can't make these threads, RJ. I've read people post how you don't now a few times, but I see it now, more thought needs to be put into threads like these. It's why I don't make any of them. You can't just watch a film/show, get a hard-on, then proceed to open a thread with your favorites already cast into victory.
I'm going to have to go with the Wizards on this one.
They get prep.
And with Voldemort and Dumbledore on the same team they will be too versatile for the Jedi to handle.
In this scenario, it wouldn't be a "quick draw" battle, like in the other thread (HP vs Sidious), and the Jedi will be defenseless against magic. Likewise Wizards, imo, can't defend against the Force, but their high level magic seems much more versatile and powerful to me. Also, teleportation, and long range attax seals the deal for me.
I'm sure everyone has seen this, but just a reminder of Voldemort's power.
Originally posted by PlacidityIndeed. Not to mention the death eaters and OOTP members, and the Hogwarts staff.
I'm going to have to go with the Wizards on this one.They get prep.
And with Voldemort and Dumbledore on the same team they will be too versatile for the Jedi to handle.
In this scenario, it wouldn't be a "quick draw" battle, like in the other thread (HP vs Sidious), and the Jedi will be defenseless against magic. Likewise Wizards, imo, can't defend against the Force, but their high level magic seems much more versatile and powerful to me. Also, teleportation, and long range attax seals the deal for me.
I'm sure everyone has seen this, but just a reminder of Voldemort's power.
You dont think a shield charm will block a force attack?
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Because Sidious isn't in the fight, not until he decides which side to join.Buh bye now.
He can't decide because he isn't real, it's a Vs thread made by you, where you choose the sides.
Stop being a moron.
You haven't given him a side because if one side says: "He joins forces against Hogwarts.", you say that it's spite. If he doesn't, you win.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Then your opinion holds no water here. If you can't say HOW the Jedi will win, HOW they will counter fiendfyre, HOW they will contend with wizards flying around everywhere at over 100 mph, then you should probably not post.
How can you? YOU don't know how they would react, it's a fantasy fight.
You're not getting how fantasy fights work...STILL. You weigh up powers and you judge accordingly. You don't sit there scripting shit.
Why? Because there are a billion and one ways that a fight could go and scripting it is dumb.
If I say one thin, you can just say: "Nah, they dodge that.". How do you know? You're being ridiculous, as always.
-AC
Originally posted by Alpha CentauriKinda hard to say. On one hand, he has force powers in common with the Jedi. On the other, he uses dark powers like Voldy and the Death Eaters. I suppose we can do it three ways:
He can't decide because he isn't real, it's a Vs thread made by you, where you choose the sides.Stop being a moron.
You haven't given him a side because if one side says: "He joins forces against Hogwarts.", you say that it's spite. If he doesn't, you win.
1. He joins forces with the Jedi.
2. He joins forces with the wizards.
3. He isn't around at all.
If that sounds all right with you guys, of course. I am always open to suggestions on conditions in my threads, adding combatants and such.
How can you? YOU don't know how they would react, it's a fantasy fight.Um.....Yeah, it's really up to the poster to decide how to proceed in a versus thread, unless the thread starter specifies otherwise. There is no golden rule on how to compare powers, other than sticking to onscreen feats. For example if someone and I are doing it the way you describe and you don't like it, you just avoid commenting.You're not getting how fantasy fights work...STILL. You weigh up powers and you judge accordingly. You don't sit there scripting shit.
Why? Because there are a billion and one ways that a fight could go and scripting it is dumb.
If I say one thin, you can just say: "Nah, they dodge that.". How do you know? You're being ridiculous, as always.
-AC