Superman Vs Thor vs SS vs Marvel Who's more Durable

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Logan took 20 of them.

Sentry didn't. No one here is surviving 20 all out punches from WWH. It was literally stated in the comic that WWH intentions wasn't to kill. This thread is a different ball game, though.

So Logan > Sentry. Good point.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So Logan > Sentry. Good point.

Naah, Logan and Sentry speed is >>>>> Doomsdays though (remember, even when Superman upped his speed to keep up with Doomsday, Lois eas fast enough to stand by them and have a conversation). Now THAT is a good point.

😂

We are talking about who in Marvel took punches from WWH. Please stay on topic lmao. If you can't address it without whataboutism, fair enough.

Logan took multiple punches from WWH when he was explicitly trying to cause as much damage as quickly as possible, in the shortest possible time.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
😂

We are talking about who in Marvel took punches from WWH. Please stay on topic lmao. If you can't address it without whataboutism, fair enough.

Logan took multiple punches from WWH when he was explicitly trying to cause as much damage as quickly as possible, in the shortest possible time.

WWH wasn't trying to kill Logan. There's literally zero proof of that. Mongul has literally one punch koed Superman. 🤣 There's no way you think Mongul is stronger than WWH who split New York in half just by fighting amped Ironman. FYI, next issue, Superman admitted Mongul knocked him TF out. Is that on topic?

A single punch from Damage made his body go limp and busted that lip. Based off previous debates with you, Damage loss to a gorilla and is weaker than Poison Ivy...

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
That's the feat you're going with, not Lex in Superman's body shaking the cosmos? Lol.

Originally posted by carver9
WWH wasn't trying to kill Logan. There's literally zero proof of that. Mongul has literally one punch koed Superman. 🤣 There's no way you think Mongul is stronger than WWH who split New York in half just by fighting amped Ironman. FYI, next issue, Superman admitted Mongul knocked him TF out. Is that on topic?

Originally posted by carver9
A single punch from Damage made his body go limp and busted that lip. Based off previous debates with you, Damage loss to a gorilla and is weaker than Poison Ivy...

They can all be KOd. It’s not a low ball to show their lowest durability feats or their highest. That will actually give us a median range to work with. Depending on what we are talking about, each one of these guys excel above the others. Thor can tank more mystical damage, surfer can survive being cut into cubes and Superman has the best physical resistance. They all have vulnerabilities. Things that would outright kill Thor and Superman would be resisted by the Surfer.

Overall;
Superman would rate 80 on the physical durability scale, 30 on the metaphysical durability scale, and 40 for damage soak that can be healed naturally.
Thor with Mjolnir rates 65 on the physical durability scale, 50 on the metaphysical durability scale, and 50 on the damage soak than can be healed over the quickest amount of time.

The Surfer rates 70 on the physical durability scale, 45 on the metaphysical durability scale, and 90 on the damage-soak healed over time.

In my honest opinion Superman does better at most durability tests than most Heralds out there or most characters in general, but suffers greatly when it comes to mitigating exotic magical assaults.

Superman has a slight lead, and is as of now immune to Kryptonite poisoning.

Superman 80
Surfer 75
Thor 70-75

Originally posted by abhilegend
Twenty years on this site and you're still doing this nonsense, aren't you ashamed of yourself?

What nonsense? The same nonsense of WWH going all out against Wolverine? Is that what you're referencing?

I never said he was trying to kill Logan, good strawman lmao. Quote me where I said this in my last few posts. If you can't, then shut up about it 😂

He was trying to end things as quickly as possible. Explicitly said in the comics.

So he wasn't there to waste time, yet couldn't stop Logan with 1 hit. Or even 2. If I am trying to not waste time and get things done as quickly as possible, I wouldn't use several hits when one suffices.

Unless I am unable to put someone down in 1/2/3 hits.

Let me quote myself lol.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
I never said he was trying to kill Logan, good strawman lmao. Quote me where I said this in my last few posts. If you can't, then shut up about it 😂

He was trying to end things as quickly as possible. Explicitly said in the comics.

Let me quote myself lol.

Gotcha. So he wasn't going all out (and had zero reasons to go all out against Logan). Here, he is going for the kill. Something that he didn't do against Wolverine, Sentry, Ironman, Fantastic Four, etc... 20 punches from this version of Hulk (or any Hulk) should wreck anybody. Superman doesn't survive.

Wait who is Marvel? Blue Marvel? Captain Marvel Shazam, Captain Marvel Danvers? Did not read OP.

Okay old thread. Billy is up there! He may just be the overall tankiest ov average but it’s pretty close.

Originally posted by carver9
Gotcha. So he wasn't going all out (and had zero reasons to go all out against Logan). Here, he is going for the kill. Something that he didn't do against Wolverine, Sentry, Ironman, Fantastic Four, etc... 20 punches from this version of Hulk (or any Hulk) should wreck anybody. Superman doesn't survive.

He was trying to end things as quickly as possible.

And still couldn't do it in one/two/three punches. If he could, he would've.

It doesn't take all of his strength to end things quickly, lol. He wasn't hitting him with New York splitting in half power. But yes, Wolverine durability>>>Superman durability since Wolverine endured punches that are more powerful than what Mongul could ever dream of. WWH>>>>Mongul.

So he's trying to end it as efficiently and as quickly as possible.....but had to do multiple punches? Why not in 1, or 2 punches?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So he's trying to end it as efficiently and as quickly as possible.....but had to do multiple punches? Why not in 1, or 2 punches?

Where was it said WWH tried to take Wolverine out quickly?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So he's trying to end it as efficiently and as quickly as possible.....but had to do multiple punches? Why not in 1, or 2 punches?

Holding back. Not wanting to kill Wolverine or anyone for that matter. He could’ve gotten off of the stone ship and went planet kill before visiting anyone.

Originally posted by carver9
What nonsense? The same nonsense of WWH going all out against Wolverine? Is that what you're referencing?