Superman Vs Thor vs SS vs Marvel Who's more Durable

Originally posted by carver9
Where was it said WWH tried to take Wolverine out quickly?

He also says he 'CAN'T' kill Wolverine, literally says it. Says he can't do this all day, he had other things to do.

He repeats this later:

Originally posted by Stoic
Holding back. Not wanting to kill Wolverine or anyone for that matter. He could’ve gotten off of the stone ship and went planet kill before visiting anyone.

Even if he wanted to, he can't. Hulk literally says that he can't, lol.

And again, why not give him concussion in 1 or 2 or 3 punches? Answer: he is unable to. He NEEDS to do it multiple times, because he is unable to do it in 1/2/3 punches.

That doesnt mean he was rushing. He did have things to do. He could've just BFRd Wolverine if he wanted to do it quickly.

Originally posted by carver9
That doesnt mean he was rushing. He did have things to do. He could've just BFRd Wolverine if he wanted to do it quickly.

Was waiting for this 'argument', lol. He tried to BFR Wolverine earlier:

Didn't take.

He tried to BFR Rockslide, Monet and Juggernaut lmao. He was trying to end things as quickly as possible, he just couldn't do it with Wolverine. I like how you ignored his statement that he can't kill Wolverine, though - is that hyperbole ? 😂

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Was waiting for this 'argument', lol. He tried to BFR Wolverine earlier:

Didn't take.

He tried to BFR Rockslide, Monet and Juggernaut lmao. He was trying to end things as quickly as possible, he just couldn't do it with Wolverine. I like how you ignored his statement that he can't kill Wolverine, though - is that hyperbole ? 😂

What im saying is, he couldve threw Wolverine to Jersey like he did against one of the members in the Xmen roster. No one can physically kill Wolverine just by punching him, so I agree with Hulk. He obviously wasn't punching him with punches that split NY city in half...

We have two conclusions here. Wolverine can take a punch better than Superman since he handled a hit from a more powerful character than Superman did against Mongul, or Hulk was holding back. I'm good with either. I think Hulk was holding back since he literally one punched almost everyone.

One punch She Hulk...

One punch Ares...

One punched Doc Sampson...

One punch Thing right after taking a Nova from HT and an ongoing blast from Storm...

And one punch your favorite, Sue...

Hulk failing to kill and knowing he cannot kill Logan, and failing to give him concussion in a few punches, means nothing regarding Mongul and Superman, lol. They're four different characters. So your first statement is just nonsense. Him holding back makes no sense either, as he explicitly says he can't kill him, and explicitly says he wasn't there to waste time. And he even tried BFRing people, INCLUDING Wolverine.

This assumes it wasnt just crappy writing, of course

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Hulk failing to kill and knowing he cannot kill Logan, and failing to give him concussion in a few punches, means nothing regarding Mongul and Superman, lol. They're four different characters. So your first statement is just nonsense. Him holding back makes no sense either, as he explicitly says he can't kill him, and explicitly says he wasn't there to waste time. And he even tried BFRing people, INCLUDING Wolverine.

This assumes it wasnt just crappy writing, of course

WWH strength>>>>>Mongul strength. The same Mongul who casually knocked Superman out and boasted above his body. It has a lot to do with it. Wolverine handled a punch from a FAR more powerful character versus Superman. Its just that simple. This incude Damage as well who made Supes body go limp and took some panels for him to show back up with a busted lip. Based off fts and common sense, Hulk is more powerful than both Mongul and Damage. If Wolverine can endure a punch better than Supes against opponents that is weaker than the one he's faced, his durability is>>>. Thats if we look at it in your attempt at always trying to lowball. Also, it's good that you also feel that Wolverine durability >>>> Sue shields.

Mongul KOing Superman in a punch is somehow relevant to WWH failing to do so to Wolverine in multiple punches? Ok, lmao.

Using your logic, Batman (who took Damage's punches) is above Superman in durability. I must save this.

Again, your entire 'logic' assumes it's good writing.

I'm saying it's not. So ...no, none of your statements hold, as the' feats' are a result of bad writing lmao.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Mongul KOing Superman in a punch is somehow relevant to WWH failing to do so to Wolverine in multiple punches? Ok, lmao.

Using your logic, Batman (who took Damage's punches) is above Superman in durability. I must save this.

Again, your entire 'logic' assumes it's good writing.

I'm saying it's not. So ...no, none of your statements hold, as the' feats' are a result of bad writing lmao.

Wait, Batman took a punch better than Superman as well? Kinda similar to Wolverine taking "all out punches" from WWH better than anyone else during the WWH. The same showing you're trying to use to justify Superman surviving 20 punches from an all out WWH. Yeah, you can save that.

Youre literally the one that mentioned Wolverine withstanding WWH punches, so that means Superman can endure them as well. Not mentioning that if we take that as Wolverine surviving an all out punch from WWH, he performed better than Sentry, Hercules, She Hulk, amped Doctor Strange who was harnessing Zom power, Ares, Thing, amped Ironman, and Sue Storm. Imagine that. I think Hulk is stronger than Mighto as well and Mighto did this with less than 20 punches...

We can compare fts if you want.

Carv is back trolling again, Quan style.
He matches his characters high feats with Superman's low feats.
He doesn't bother mentioning Superman's high feats at all, only his low ones.

Trolling at its finest

Originally posted by carver9
Wait, Batman took a punch better than Superman as well? Kinda similar to Wolverine taking "all out punches" from WWH better than anyone else during the WWH. The same showing you're trying to use to justify Superman surviving 20 punches from an all out WWH. Yeah, you can save that.

Youre literally the one that mentioned Wolverine withstanding WWH punches, so that means Superman can endure them as well. Not mentioning that if we take that as Wolverine surviving an all out punch from WWH, he performed better than Sentry, Hercules, She Hulk, amped Doctor Strange who was harnessing Zom power, Ares, Thing, amped Ironman, and Sue Storm. Imagine that. I think Hulk is stronger than Mighto as well and Mighto did this with less than 20 punches...

We can compare fts if you want.

So is the Wolverine scan not valid or is it? I know I'm the one mentioning it, are you saying it shouldn't be considered?

Hulk's admission that he can't kill Logan, is that hyperbole or something?

Originally posted by h1a8
Carv is back trolling again, Quan style.
He matches his characters high feats with Superman's low feats.
He doesn't bother mentioning Superman's high feats at all, only his low ones.

Trolling at its finest

Lol... so Dark mentioning WWH not being able to take out Wolverine quickly isnt trolling?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So is the Wolverine scan not valid or is it? I know I'm the one mentioning it, are you saying it shouldn't be considered?

Hulk's admission that he can't kill Logan, is that hyperbole or something?

Is the scans I posted above valid? I can accept the Wolverine scan if you can accept what I posted above.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol... so Dark mentioning WWH not being able to take out Wolverine quickly isnt trolling?

He repeatedly stated that it was poor writing. I agree that WWH should one-shot Wolverine, since adamantium doesn't absorb impact. A megaton-level punch would liquefy Logan's brain, and it would likely take him about an hour to fully regenerate.

Originally posted by h1a8
He repeatedly stated that it was poor writing. I agree that WWH should one-shot Wolverine, since adamantium doesn't absorb impact. A megaton-level punch would liquefy Logan's brain, and it would likely take him about an hour to fully regenerate.

It should have never been mentioned.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Logan took 20 of them.

Thats what started this debate.

Why should it not have been mentioned?

Originally posted by carver9
Is the scans I posted above valid? I can accept the Wolverine scan if you can accept what I posted above.

So a question with a question, as always.

Just answer it, it's not that difficult to do so, is it?

You skipped my response. I'll wait for you to answer that first.

Your response wasn't an answer, though.

It's ok if you say no. I think they were PIS and don't count, but do YOU? Or will you only answer once I have lol, because you're a coward who can't stand up for himself?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Your response wasn't an answer, though.

It's ok if you say no. I think they were PIS and don't count, but do YOU? Or will you only answer once I have lol, because you're a coward who can't stand up for himself?

Your response isnt making sense because you brought it up to counter Stoic. I don't think it's an invalid showing. My argument this entire time is, Hulk used a sufficient amount of power for every situation. Enough to get the job done. You do know this was said in the comic, right? So no, it's not PIS, but it's not the epitome of WWH power either.