A tough one. Thor is not easily taken down, even by very powerful beings. Hal has the willpower of a god, and the ability to make that will manifest. Thor has good defenses. So does Hal. Thor can dish out the whoopass. So can Hal.
Hal has the edge in versatility.
Thor is one of the toughest to take down, and still has some versatility to compliment that.
Fate of the universe at stake...
I'll tentatively go with Thor, 5.5/10, but it really is close; his edge is marginal in this case.
Originally posted by Omega VisionI think his experience and skills will do him well and good by doing what comes natural with his hammer. If Thor goes warrior madness Hal dies very quickly.
Warrior Madness you mean? Doesn't that also count as an intelligence debuff? All in all Thor is better off fighting a GL without WM.