Dr. Doom vs Thanos

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Can you be a little more specific buddy on what you're referring to with the high and low?

The high end part was where Thanos absorbed enough energy to destroy the Rot, and effect the universe. Where he was sharing bits of his power, and turning people into high level beings.

Originally posted by Mindset
None of that.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
This again? Only in your warped Thanos addled mind do you think that the fight was anything less than Odin kicking Thanos' ass. I've literally seen you go from "it was a stalemate" to "Odin was lucky the fight ended". And then this whole upgrade nonsense where Thanos pulls off about two feats that you strongly disbelieve that Odin could replicate had the situations/context been reversed. "Oh, he beat Maker." Yeah, he used his guile and attacked when she was vulnerable. It's impressive, but not as impressive as the false implication that Thanos outright defeated her. "Galactus blast." Riiiiight. And Odin can't summon enough power - which can destroy galaxies - to send Galactus flying a great distance only to just piss him off?

Either way, no, I don't want a writer wanking my favorite characters. I'd like them to respect them, but no, I don't want a Bendis/Pak/Jenkins handling them. And lol at "bellyaching". Have you read some of the posts you've made in response to ODG in this thread?

Originally posted by Blanket
Starlin wrote Thor downing Thanos twice with the IG. Wolverine stabbing Thanos with the IG. Pretty much that whole IG issue. I'm pretty sure he wrote Thanos getting one shotted by blasters as well.

The high end part was where Thanos absorbed enough energy to destroy the Rot, and effect the universe. Where he was sharing bits of his power, and turning people into high level beings.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yeah, you're also an incredible debater. I hope you note the sarcasm.

In any event he didn't lose, Odin saluted him midway during the fight and respected him as a great opponent in the end he failed to beat. Yeah, those are facts while the rest if your bias jumping on in.

If you read the entire issue it's obvious these moments were only added there for dramatic effect. They had no chance and he won reather easily while fighting sloppily and depowered.

SO if I salute you and kick your ass that means you are a good match for me?

Your right on this.Thanos said they had a .05% chance to win and the moments where thanos was being beaten(with the guantlet)was just dramatic effect.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I can garuntee he can debate better then you...

SO if I salute you and kick your ass that means you are a good match for me?

Your right on this.Thanos said they had a .05% chance to win and the moments where thanos was being beaten(with the guantlet)was just dramatic effect.

Ps. I am always right.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yeah, you're also an incredible debater. I hope you note the sarcasm.

I don't.

Originally posted by Mindset
Thank you.

I don't.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
I think the key difference is that no Darkseid writer ever retconned him getting warped by Emperor Joker like Starlin retconned (or tried to retcon) the Squirrel Girl incident.

Its fine to retcon an embarrassing defeat or two but when you try to dismiss something that doesn't really require dismissal its stepping into the world of a Pygmalion.

^ wouldn't that make it deadlocked in uncertainty? uatu says it's the true thanos, but thanos (the real one) says his clones are so good they can fool the most keen of senses (note thanos has created a clone more powerful than uatu also)

there is no tipping point here, any point brought up to say he did get beaten by squirrel girl, there is a counter point to say it wasn't.

Originally posted by quanchi112
You don't salute people whose asses you've just kicked hence he didn't salute the Surfer or Drax. You in the end agreed with me and I turned your points into my own. Well done.

Ps. I am always right.

No you didn't.You were right for once.You are only right about 1% of the time and that is not an exaggeration.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
^ wouldn't that make it deadlocked in uncertainty? uatu says it's the true thanos, but thanos (the real one) says his clones are so good they can fool the most keen of senses (note thanos has created a clone more powerful than uatu also)

there is no tipping point here, any point brought up to say he did get beaten by squirrel girl, there is a counter point to say it wasn't.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Odin saluted him and kicked his ass.I just turned your own statement against you.

No you didn't.You were right for once.You are only right about 1% of the time and that is not an exaggeration.

If what you say is true then he should have saluted Drax and Surfer yet he didn't.

Originally posted by King Kandy
That's a good reason why that showing should be discounted...

i'm pretty sure we can all get the fact that she's a gimmick character with off-panel victories against the universe's most difficult cross-over level villains for the sake head scratch laughs...and to piss of fanboys.

c'mon, she beat maelstrom also

Exactly buddy, that is why it's kinda not to be taken seriously. I will say this though... there is a tipping point and I disagree with that part of your assessment. The whole point of a recton is that it inherently overrides the previous showing. It clearly carries more weight than the previous showing and thus clearly is a tipping point. If not, all rectons we have by your theory we could say... ooo well let's not forget the previous it carries just as much weight as the recton. We don't do that because it does carry more weight, in fact, it overrides the previous showing.

thanos

Originally posted by quanchi112
No, kicking someone's else implies you win when he didn't. He looked at Thanos as simply great and in the end was unable to best him.

If what you say is true then he should have saluted Drax and Surfer yet he didn't.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Wow...that might be the dumbest quote I have ever heard.Odin was winning.Odin was kicking his ass.Deal with it.

Odin kicked thanos ass.Deal with it.Given thanos is much harder to put down then drax or surfer but he kicked his all around asgard non the less.

I've already given my opinion about the topic at hand.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Odin kicked thanos ass.Deal with it.Given thanos is much harder to put down then drax or surfer but he kicked his all around asgard non the less.

I've already given my opinion about the topic at hand.

Thanos wins this thread.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
Odin kicked thanos ass.Deal with it.Given thanos is much harder to put down then drax or surfer but he kicked his all around asgard non the less.

I've already given my opinion about the topic at hand.

It's not a fight...thanos can't "win" here.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
It's not a fight...thanos can't "win" here.