Originally posted by BoratBorat
Keep it mind that it was what would have happened.
Same as Red Skull would have shot Spiderman? Or Logan would have KO'ed Silver Surfer with a brick?
What-If's are not canon. What happens in them isn't counted.
Originally posted by BoratBorat
Sidious, luke, caedus?
Exactly. That's just three guys. See what I mean by "there aren't many who surpass him"?
Originally posted by Red Nemesis
Skywalker, Dooku, Maul, Vastor, Thul, Jaina, Horn, Revan, N, Kas'im, Plo Koon?
Some of those are highly dubious and I suspect are just jokes (Plo Koon?) But even with the legitimate ones, that's still not a lot.
There was not a single name bounded by the first question mark that I would not endorse. As for your charge of insufficient quantity, I'd like you to come look over the list of threads on the board and tell me how many people couldn't beat him. I listed just about all of the major players in our matches. (I forgot Kun because I've never read his material. The only people I'd put Marek above are Kenobi, Grievous (because Marek lieks 2 ragdoll foolz) and the myriad of no-names that nobody cares about.)
Originally posted by chilled monkey
Some of those are highly dubious and I suspect are just jokes (Plo Koon?) But even with the legitimate ones, that's still not a lot.
There are plenty missing from there too. Mace, Yoda, Kyp, Jacen, Katarn, Malak, Exar, Ulic, and then of course the Ancient Sith like Ragnos, Sadow, Ludo, Freedon Nadd, ect. The list is already plenty long.
Originally posted by chilled monkeyNo, still the SW databanks prove that your precious galen marek is no match for emperor palpatine. I suggest you deal with it hun.
Same as Red Skull would have shot Spiderman? Or Logan would have KO'ed Silver Surfer with a brick?
The book even makes it clear that sidious wasn't even engaging starkiller in a pure duel.
The non canon ending was to simply show that sidious is capable of overwhelming galen, canon or not the fact remains that sidious > galen seeing its backed up by so many sources.
ok nothing from a vidio game is relvent galen shuold kill any body with one lightsaber strike (exept the malordians because of malordion armor)and sidious was just trying to turn luke not blast him to kingdom come plus he can redrect a star destroyer but not smush a clone troper like tin foil? (wtf) in the movies he was never using the full extent of his streangh ( pluss it is theriosed that he was using force batle meditaion or somthing like that) while he was killing luke yoda might trump alll of them in light saber skills but in the force he gets powned bye the( garreck can also use mallstorm) here is what i think .
darth bane/darth sidius>garen>yoda (sidius is more power full on large scale ablities so if you give him a minute before the fight he kills plus bane had the liotel bug guys on him (i forgot their name) that puts him in itense pain and anger an lets not forget childrren that totaly gets dark side users more powerfull)