Originally posted by 753
Ha! The girl is jean! I knew it!
Spoiler:according to the Phoenix Handbook she
Nope
Spoiler:
has a grandmother in Alaska. Her real name is Hope Spaulding.
Again as I said before Hope is a mimic. She only has red hair and green eyes because her adoptive mother Hope I had red hair and green eyes. She's as connected to Jean Grey as she is to every other living mutant.
Originally posted by ExodusCloakWhat about this theory?Spoiler:according to the Phoenix Handbook she
NopeSpoiler:
has a grandmother in Alaska. Her real name is Hope Spaulding.Again as I said before Hope is a mimic. She only has red hair and green eyes because her adoptive mother Hope I had red hair and green eyes. She's as connected to Jean Grey as she is to every other living mutant.
Soul connection like Wanda kids? 😛
Originally posted by ExodusCloakThat's nonsense, so what that she has a grandmother? We already knew she was born from a regular woman in alaska.Spoiler:according to the Phoenix Handbook she
NopeSpoiler:
has a grandmother in Alaska. Her real name is Hope Spaulding.Again as I said before Hope is a mimic. She only has red hair and green eyes because her adoptive mother Hope I had red hair and green eyes. She's as connected to Jean Grey as she is to every other living mutant.
We've already seen how her powers work
Spoiler:
and prodigy confirmed it, she has all mutant powers, she doesn't mimic them.She already manifested the PF signature firebird twice since coming back. Emma frost clearly recognized her as phoenix in second coming 2, remembering when jean appeared to her in a dream to save her from the sisterhood.
Originally posted by 753
That's nonsense, so what that she has a grandmother? We already knew she was born from a regular woman in alaska.We've already seen how her powers work
Spoiler:
and prodigy confirmed it, she has all mutant powers, she doesn't mimic them.She already manifested the PF signature firebird twice since coming back. Emma frost clearly recognized her as phoenix in second coming 2, remembering when jean appeared to her in a dream to save her from the sisterhood.
If you're aware of that then you know she's not Jean.
Prodigy called her a voodoo doll but you have no idea how her power works. Does she need to be near everyone to use their powers? Because she's only displayed Bishop and Cable's powers when she was close to them.
So what if she manifested the PF? Other mutants have also manifested it.
Doesn't make her Jean I fail to see how you were right.
Originally posted by ExodusCloak
If you're aware of that then you know she's not Jean.Prodigy called her a voodoo doll but you have no idea how her power works. Does she need to be near everyone to use their powers? Because she's only displayed Bishop and Cable's powers when she was close to them.
So what if she manifested the PF? Other mutants have also manifested it.
Doesn't make her Jean I fail to see how you were right.
Neither do you, there is no reason to assume she needs proximity. There is also the matter of emma's flashback recognizing her. Jean Grey is the default host to pf and she is bonded with it now. The girl's powers and her role in reigniting mutant births, that have already happened since she came back, matches the cosmic role of the phoenix. Jean has been gone for too long and they are physically identical. There are too many signs pointing to it.
She's likely the essence of jean grey merged now with the PF given flesh again to fix the fallout of M-day. Even if it wasn't jean grey's soul the pf forged into this avatar, but just a random mutant, her merging with the force, which I believe was within her from birth, means she's merging with Jean.
Originally posted by 753
[B]Neither do you, there is no reason to assume she needs proximity. There is also the matter of emma's flashback recognizing her. Jean Grey is the default host to pf and she is bonded with it now. The girl's powers and her role in reigniting mutant births, that have already happened since she came back, matches the cosmic role of the phoenix. Jean has been gone for too long and they are physically identical. There are too many signs pointing to it.
Emma recognized the Phoenix Force not Jean Grey. The girl has been alive for 17 years. She was alive when Jean Grey came to Emma Frost in a vision.
The girl also shares the same powers as the Scarlet Witch. The Scarlet Witch has the power to undo her own spell.
The PF's role is to burn away what doesn't work. She is the spitting image of her adoptive mother Hope Summers I.
She's likely the essence of jean grey merged now with the PF given flesh again to fix the fallout of M-day. Even if it wasn't jean grey's soul the pf forged into this avatar, but just a random mutant, her merging with the force, which I believe was within her from birth, means she's merging with Jean.
Hope is just nature fixing itself. The miracle is that she was born to normal people. The Phoenix Force's role is to burn away what doesn't work.
The Phoenix was Jean but Jean wasn't the Phoenix according to Fraction pen anyway.