Originally posted by quanchi112
Can you prove they are stronger than him?Top tiers like Thor and Hulk have been treated as nonfactors against Thanos. Surfer's blasts don't even phase him.
lol i asked you first , and there was that example i gave of CM lifting that infinte weight...
is thanos thor's physical superior?
what hulk was this/was he mad ?
i though it was prof hulk and thing he manhandled , who both are pretty weak
CM helping SM lift the book of knowledge is an abstract feat at its best no matter what the writers try to pass it off with saying it had infinite weight...
but if you want to accept it as a physical feat then Hercules also lifted the heavens by himself....
and thanos still smacked him and his avenger buddies down.
Originally posted by ankur29
lol i asked you first , and there was that example i gave of CM lifting that infinte weight...
Originally posted by ankur29
is thanos thor's physical superior?
Originally posted by ankur29
what hulk was this/was he mad ?
i though it was prof hulk and thing he manhandled , who both are pretty weak
Thanos doesn't have to worry about their speed. His omnidirectional blast has one-shot killed Classic Warlock w/ the Soul Gem, a bonafide herald leveler. One-shot Heimdall. One-shot Classic Drax. One-shot Morg. One-shot Thing (something Champion couldn't do), one-shot Captain Marvel, etc...all with energy blasts.
Originally posted by ankur29That was an alternate reality version of Marvel anyways. Thanos doesn't have uber strength feats on their own but has pwned characters with them.
lol i asked you first , and there was that example i gave of CM lifting that infinte weight...is thanos thor's physical superior?
what hulk was this/was he mad ?
i though it was prof hulk and thing he manhandled , who both are pretty weak
What does strength matter anyways in these versus battles. Thanos is powerful enough to destroy the Surfer and laugh off blasts while most would argue he is more powerful than either Marvel or Adam or in the same league rendering them scrubs to him.
Thanos takes on guys who could oneshot either of these like Odin or Tyrant.
Originally posted by EnyalusNicely done and since it is magic then infinite weight doesn't even apply. Great job, seriously.
It wasn't 'infinite weight'. It had 'infinite pages' in it. Which, for something magical that doesn't have to follow the rules of physics, says nothing for its weight.[/b]
Obviously.It was Professor Hulk who supported the weight of the 100 billion ton mountain range in Secret Wars...
Thanos doesn't have to worry about their speed. His omnidirectional blast has one-shot killed Classic Warlock w/ the Soul Gem, a bonafide herald leveler. One-shot Heimdall. One-shot Classic Drax. One-shot Morg. One-shot Thing (something Champion couldn't do), one-shot Captain Marvel, etc...all with energy blasts. [/B]
Originally posted by Enyalus
It wasn't 'infinite weight'. It had 'infinite pages' in it. Which, for something magical that doesn't have to follow the rules of physics, says nothing for its weight.
If those magical pages wouldn't have a weight, then everyone should be able to lift it, or better said, why not ask Zatanna to lift it, it has no weight after all, only magic prevents you from lifting it duryes.
More probably, the writer wanted to make this an feat, an strength feat that is quite impressive without giving the artist an headache. 🙂
FC is full of tasks worth remembering.
Infinite weight is impossible but then again those are comics, those are heroes and Morrison wanted to entertain us, he did.
Originally posted by Batman-PrimeIn the same comic Thanos was toying with them. If you knew anything about the power gem alone you'd realize knocking apg user back is only knocking them back.
Masterson beat him almost to death 🙂. And Thor showed he can affect or hurt Thanos.
Thanos gave them far less than a 1 percent chance of victory while he depowered them so they would have a shot. You continue to speak about comics you haven't read or even read the scans I have put up.
Thor with the power gem showed he can bloody his nose after increasing his strength and going through a team which consisted of Surfer, the Infinity Watch, and classic Strange.
Originally posted by quanchi112
In the same comic Thanos was toying with them. If you knew anything about the power gem alone you'd realize knocking apg user back is only knocking them back.Thanos gave them far less than a 1 percent chance of victory while he depowered them so they would have a shot. You continue to speak about comics you haven't read or even read the scans I have put up.
Thor with the power gem showed he can bloody his nose after increasing his strength and going through a team which consisted of Surfer, the Infinity Watch, and classic Strange.
Yeah right that's why he had to turn Thor to glass to survive. He toyed and saw that it's not a game anymore, he had to cheat. 🙂
Thor restrained Thanos before. The PG Thor hasn't tapped into the Gems power very good. Drax with the Power Gem was defeated by Thor via physical force.
Originally posted by Batman-PrimeHe had to cheat? he had the ig and actually depowered it so they would even have a chance.
Yeah right that's why he had to turn Thor to glass to survive. He toyed and saw that it's not a game anymore, he had to cheat. 🙂
Thor restrained Thanos before. The PG Thor hasn't tapped into the Gems power very good. Drax with the Power Gem was defeated by Thor via physical force.
He killed Thor because he opposed him. He could turn any of them into glass at any time and thought of creative ways to kill them.
You don't even grasp the power gems abilities to suggest something as ignorant as Thor almost killed thanos there.
Thor got the power gem out of his stomach and prior to Thor couldn't beat him with physical force. They actually cited he couldn't as long as Drax tapped into it.
You are so ignorant it's not even funny.
Originally posted by quanchi112
He had to cheat? he had the ig and actually depowered it so they would even have a chance.He killed Thor because he opposed him. He could turn any of them into glass at any time and thought of creative ways to kill them.
You don't even grasp the power gems abilities to suggest something as ignorant as Thor almost killed thanos there.
Thor got the power gem out of his stomach and prior to Thor couldn't beat him with physical force. They actually cited he couldn't as long as Drax tapped into it.
You are so ignorant it's not even funny.
Depowered parts of it and get his ass handed to him till he used it's power.
You can disagree with the comic and the writer all you want, but Thanos was going to die. Comics and writer > your biased opinion.
I grasp more then you ever will, that's a moot point.
Thor beat the Power Gem out of Drax, physically. It's not like he reached into Drax mouth and took it, he punched him. We agree here.
You don't read comics, you already said that, but you still argue, so i dunno why you keep misinterpreting them and disagreeing with the writers, on purpose i guess.
Originally posted by Batman-PrimeHe won. He showed off and still won. That's called Thanos coming out on top and giving them a chance.
Depowered parts of it and get his ass handed to him till he used it's power.
You can disagree with the comic and the writer all you want, but Thanos was going to die. Comics and writer > your biased opinion.I grasp more then you ever will, that's a moot point.
Thor beat the Power Gem out of Drax, physically. It's not like he reached into Drax mouth and took it, he punched him. We agree here.
You don't read comics, you already said that, but you still argue, so i dunno why you keep misinterpreting them and disagreeing with the writers, on purpose i guess.
No, it isn't. If you knew anything about the power gem you'd know Thor can't kill him.
The only reason Thor beat Drax was because he knocked it from his belly. The other time when he couldn't just get it off of him he couldn't hurt him. I guess you agree with me. Without removing the power gem you can't ko them.
Says the guy who doesn't know what he's talking about yet again. Name a power gem user who has been killed when tapping intot he power gem.
Originally posted by Batman-Prime
If those magical pages wouldn't have a weight, then everyone should be able to lift it, or better said, why not ask Zatanna to lift it, it has no weight after all, only magic prevents you from lifting it duryes.
Originally posted by EnyalusI agree though now that it makes since it wasn't infinite weight which makes the perfect sense now when wrapping our minds around this feat.
When did I claim they didn't have a weight? I just said they didn't have to follow the normal laws of physics since the book is basically magical in nature, and that it didn't have infinite weight. Of course it had some weight, and that weight was very large.
Originally posted by Enyalus
When did I claim they didn't have a weight? I just said they didn't have to follow the normal laws of physics since the book is basically magical in nature, and that it didn't have infinite weight. Of course it had some weight, and that weight was very large.
So now you decide how much it weights? Honestly 😬
It had a weight, it was heavy enough that Superman doubted he could lift it alone. The writer provided us with an clear statement, an infinite number of pages. That means infinite weight, there is nothing to argue about it. The magic behind this was surely the fact that those infinite pages didn't collapse the Omniverse.
Infinite weight is a bullshit statement in comics, i agree with this, though it is there to entertain us, the writer wants to impress, to make something worth remembering and he was successfull. We aren't here to judge this, accept it or not, it's canon and it's valid.