Black Adam and Captain Marvel Vs Thanos and The Champion

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
So now you decide how much it weights? Honestly 😬

It had a weight, it was heavy enough that Superman doubted he could lift it alone. The writer provided us with an clear statement, an infinite number of pages. That means infinite weight, there is nothing to argue about it. The magic behind this was surely the fact that those infinite pages didn't collapse the Omniverse.

Infinite weight is a bullshit statement in comics, i agree with this, though it is there to entertain us, the writer wants to impress, to make something worth remembering and he was successfull. We aren't here to judge this, accept it or not, it's canon and it's valid.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
So now you decide how much it weights? Honestly 😬

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
It had a weight, it was heavy enough that Superman doubted he could lift it alone. The writer provided us with an clear statement, an infinite number of pages. That means infinite weight, there is nothing to argue about it.

And clearly Superman was wrong to doubt himself, anyway, as Ultraman(?) lifted it by himself just fine. Superman needed help because he wanted to be careful with it. I'm betting Superman could have lifted it himself. So could Captain Marvel. So could a top tier from Marvel like Thor or Hercules. It's a good feat, but unquantifiable for one, bullshit for two (since Ultraman lifted it solo), and inadmissible for three because its a shared feat and hence, I have no idea why its being brought up.

Originally posted by Enyalus

Again, when did I say how much it weighs? I didn't. All I did say that that it weighs some weight, call it x. And that x does not equal infinity.

[/b]
Infinite # of pages =/= infinite weight. It just doesn't. Especially when those pages are magical.

And clearly Superman was wrong to doubt himself, anyway, as Ultraman(?) lifted it by himself just fine. Superman needed help because he wanted to be careful with it. I'm betting Superman could have lifted it himself. So could Captain Marvel. So could a top tier from Marvel like Thor or Hercules. It's a good feat, but unquantifiable for one, bullshit for two (since Ultraman lifted it solo), and inadmissible for three because its a shared feat and hence, I have no idea why its being brought up. [/B]

Originally posted by Enyalus

Again, when did I say how much it weighs? I didn't. All I did say that that it weighs some weight, call it x. And that x does not equal infinity.

Infinite # of pages =/= infinite weight. It just doesn't. Especially when those pages are magical.
[/B]

Again, because you say so? I disagree, the writers intention was quite obvious. If he wished to give us an impression that it's weight wasn't infinite he would have done so, but he did the opposite.
Your part is speculation, no offense. You try to apply logic to an story, even worse, to Final Crisis. I think it was pretty clear that it was heavy because it had infinite pages and that those pages defined the weight which indeed is infinite.

And just because i don't like such hyperbolic bullshit myself doesn't mean that I'm right and the comic, the writer, is wrong. Even if i disagree with the writer (deep in my heart) I know I'm wrong to do so, he wrote the story, he made the rules.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Again, because you say so? I disagree, the writers intention was quite obvious. If he wished to give us an impression that it's weight wasn't infinite he would have done so, but he did the opposite.
Your part is speculation, no offense. You try to apply logic to an story, even worse, to Final Crisis. I think it was pretty clear that it was heavy because it had infinite pages and that those pages defined the weight which indeed is infinite.

And just because i don't like such hyperbolic bullshit myself doesn't mean that I'm right and the comic, the writer, is wrong. Even if i disagree with the writer (deep in my heart) I know I'm wrong to do so, he wrote the story, he made the rules.

Thor or any other top tier could have lifted it imo. I don't think Thor would have asked for help.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
Your part is speculation, no offense. You try to apply logic to an story, even worse, to Final Crisis.

Originally posted by quanchi112
He agreed it was heavy so you aren't disagreeing with him. When something is magical then it isn't the same. If I have magical wood would you compare it to real wood?

Thor or any other top tier could have lifted it imo. I don't think Thor would have asked for help.

You already admitted that you didn't understood FC, so stop thinking before you head explodes.

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
You already admitted that you didn't understood FC, so stop thinking before you head explodes.

Originally posted by Blanket
Quan still thinks that cotton candy is cotton. Let him be.

IVE BEEN LIED 2 ALL THEZE YEARZ!!!

Originally posted by Batman-Prime
You already admitted that you didn't understood FC, so stop thinking before you head explodes.

Originally posted by Enyalus
It's not!?

IVE BEEN LIED 2 ALL THEZE YEARZ!!!

Originally posted by Enyalus
It's a good feat, but unquantifiable for one

Then why are you speculating that a top tier from Marvel could replicate said feat?

snap

Originally posted by batdude123
Then why are you speculating that a top tier from Marvel could replicate said feat?

Originally posted by Enyalus
Because a mid-herald from DC did so?

It's OK to think that, but you have to recognize that you contradicted yourself pretty hard in that post.

Originally posted by Blanket
snap

Originally posted by batdude123
It's OK to think that, but you have to recognize that you contradicted yourself pretty hard in that post.

Originally posted by batdude123
Then why are you speculating that a top tier from Marvel could replicate said feat?

You probably haven't read the arguments, but they go through all the stages "it's hyperbole" -insert evidence that it isn't-, "character x replicated it" -insert evidence that he didn't-, "it's some sort of magic, it doesn't prove anything"- etc.

Just sit back, relax and laugh.

Lawlz, true.

Originally posted by Philosophía
He's just spitting all the excuses he can think of in order to dimiss the feat or its impressiveness, not caring whether one contradicts the other. You expect any sort of consistency in these type of 'arguments'?

You probably haven't read the arguments, but they go through all the stages "it's hyperbole" -insert evidence that it isn't-, "character x replicated it" -insert evidence that he didn't-, "it's some sort of magic, it doesn't prove anything"- etc.

Just sit back, relax and laugh.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Thanos solos.