Mara vs Jango Fett

Kenobi wasn't the soresu God in AOTC. He is given that title in ROTS.

He gets beaten in a saber battle in which he was using Ataru with Dooku.

Originally posted by truejedi
Kenobi wasn't the soresu God in AOTC. He is given that title in ROTS.

He gets beaten in a saber battle in which he was using Ataru with Dooku.

Doesn't matter. He was obviously skilled with it by AOTC, judging by the fight with Windu, and by ROTS he'd mastered it. Kenobi holding his own against Jango isn't a display of Jango's weakness, but a show of Kenobi's strength. Clearly, his Ataru wasn't enough to take a master of Makashi; and at that point, neither was his Soresu, mainly because he wasn't proficient enough to transform a form designed for redirecting blasters into a practical offensive against a form specifically designed for dueling.

What fight with Windu? Kenobi didn't fight with Windu in AOTC.

...

Jango nearly killed Windu. Jango ran from Obi-Wan.

I wonder in which case is Kenobi > Windu.

Oh right, deflecting blaster bolts.

oh I see, you are saying that Jango almost losing to kenobi is because because he is such a good swordman, and we know He is such a good swordsman because Jango also lost to Windu?

Close.

Jango lost to Kenobi.
Jango lost to Windu.

Only against Windu did he pose a threat.

Kenobi > Windu against blaster bolts.

Seemed like he posed quite a threat to Kenobi. Kenobi was, you know, falling to his death and all.

Course, that was Boba and Jango and the Slave 1 vs. Kenobi...

Either way we still get this:

Jango lost to Windu
Jango lost to Kenobi

Jango posed a threat to both of them. Jango only ran from Kenobi.

Kenobi > Windu against blaster bolts and Slave Is.

Jango's swift decapitation by Windu is a better showing than Kenobi's fall from the roof.

Jango lost.

With a ship.

Indeed. I can clearly see now why he owns this match then. 😐

Kenobi is irrelevant.

Mace > Mara

shoes youre sooooooo dumb!

mara > everyone. prove thats not true

Mace > Mara is also irrelevent.

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
shoes youre sooooooo dumb!

mara > everyone. prove thats not true

Everyone > Mara. Not this again.

Originally posted by SIDIOUS 66
Mace > Mara is also irrelevent.

Kenobi wasn't part of my original point, whereas Windu's undisputable superiority has been the cornerstone of my argument. Jango came close to killing both of them. Kenobi won because of Soresu proficiency, which has been explained twice now. Mace won because

Spoiler:
he found Jango's shatterpoint lol.

On an unrelated note, how do you get your avatar so big? I can't upload anything over 64x pixels, but yours is over 100x. Thanks will be distributed accordingly.

Originally posted by Shoes
Everyone > Mara. Not this again.

no. shut up.

Kenobi won because of Soresu proficiency,

prove it

prove it

I think we can agree that Windu > Kenobi.

I think we can agree that Jango nearly killed both of them.

I think we can agree that makes both of them relatively equal.

But that can't be! We just said that Windu > Kenobi!

Somewhere along this road, Kenobi seems to have gained some sort of skill beyond Windu. Is it saber to saber combat? No. Is it saber to blaster combat? Yes. I wonder which form is specifically desgined for that...

Originally posted by Shoes
[B]I think we can agree that Windu > Kenobi.

I think we can agree that Jango nearly killed both of them.

considering that it only takes one blaster bolt to kill someone, every time a jedi deflects a blaster bolt and fights a gun wielder, they are nearly killed in the process, because theres no room for error.

not good enough noob

Shoes, Kenobi did worse against Jango than Mace did. So if there was an edge, it was gained by Mace.

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
considering that it only takes one blaster bolt to kill someone, every time a jedi deflects a blaster bolt and fights a gun wielder, they are nearly killed in the process, because theres no room for error.

not good enough noob

I guess you can apply that to a lightsaber too, eh? Fitso almost killed Sidious. Ventress almost killed Kenobi.

EDIT:

Originally posted by truejedi
Shoes, Kenobi did worse against Jango than Mace did. So if there was an edge, it was gained by Mace.

They fared equally. Jango lost to both of them. If his ship wasn't available, he would have died.

Thing is, Mace is supposed to be better than Obi-Wan. See what I'm driving at here?