Darth Sidious vs Darth Caedus

Straight up Lightsaber fight with no force powers. This is ROTS Sidious. Who wins the battle?

Sidious.

ROTS Sidious? At this point, I would say Caedus.

Agreed. Sidious hasn't touched his lightsaber in decades.

Except whilst instructing Dooku.

Originally posted by Shoes
Except whilst instructing Dooku.

Yeah, I know Sidious trained Dooku in using the dark side of the force, but I didn't think he furthered his lightsaber combat training. After all, Dooku had already mastered Makashi before he left the Jedi order - hard to improve on that.

But room for improvement on all other forms, as Dooku taught Grievous. This would imply that Dooku had mastery/high end proficiency over multiple forms.

zomg.

Indeed.

Originally posted by Shoes
But room for improvement on all other forms, as Dooku taught Grievous. This would imply that Dooku had mastery/high end proficiency over multiple forms.

Originally posted by Shoes
But room for improvement on all other forms, as Dooku taught Grievous. This would imply that Dooku had mastery/high end proficiency over multiple forms.

Originally posted by Galan007
It's possible, but I'm not sure there's anything to support it.

Irrelevant.

Palpatine wins because of speed.

Originally posted by Shoes
Irrelevant.

Palpatine wins because of speed.

Shoes: It is kinda weird to call your own comment irrelevant.

Caedus wins a saber-only battle, imo.

Shoes, you're retarded. Dooku was a lightsaber master before he met Sidious.

Originally posted by Dr McBeefington
Shoes, you're retarded. Dooku was a lightsaber master before he met Sidious.

A pleasure to make your acquaintance.

If it's Irrelavent why did you bring it up with to begin with?

I lost consciousness and my face hit the keyboard.

What I meant to say is that Dooku's skill is irrelevant; all that matters is if Sidious' skill hasn't diminished. I was under the impression that Dooku was instructed in Dun Moch, and therefore had at least some kind of lightsaber sparring with Sidious, bringing me back to my original point:

Sidious because of speed.

Caedus because of betterness.

I think we can all agree that the moon has either of them beat.

Originally posted by Won Fei Fon
I think we can all agree that the moon has either of them beat.

elaboarate