TPM Maul vs AOTC Obi Wan and AOTC Anakin

Setting: Where Maul fought Qui Gon and Obi Wan in TPM, aka that palace in Naboo.

1. Sabers
2. Force
3. All out

Maul. Obi-Wan only beat him because of a lucky move, and after Maul had taken down a Jedi far superior to Episode 2 Anakin. Also, none of the three combatants are shown to have a particularly high mastery over the force, so I'd just have an all-out fight and not bother with the first two rounds.

Maul.

Neither Anakin or Kenobi are as good as Qui Gon was. Overall, they're a more powerful group of Jedi, but not nearly as cohesive a team as the TPM duo were. Based on Kenobi's showing against Dooku, he isn't impressive at all. Anakin couldn't dream of taking Maul.

Anakin's got the youth and stamina to keep up with Maul. But not the experience. And double-blades aren't exactly coming facings in the Order those days. They MAY win if Obi-Wan plays it smart enough. But in all likelihood, Maul would kill them.

Kenobi's bladework is a joke at this point. He got tooled by Dooku who was going easy on him. Maul is no Dooku but he's awful close, they use disimilar styles.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Kenobi's bladework is a joke at this point.

I wouldn't say a joke, but yes, Kenobi is not as good as his uber Soresu self.

Maul takes it, but not easily. Unless he has prep time like in TPM.

I think Maul wins, but not ridiculously easily. Kenobi didn't fair too badly blade to blade with Maul in TPM. He got beaten, but he managed to cut Maul's lightsaber in half, and came within a hair of slicing maul in half at one point.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Maul is no Dooku but he's awful close

Originally posted by Galan007
srsly

Maul times 3 ftw

I also made a ROTS Obi Wan vs AOTC Obi Wan and AOTC Anakin thread, and most people supported the duo. I ALSO made a ROTS Obi Wan vs TPM Maul thread and most supported Obi Wan. In this thread, most people support Maul.

😕

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Anakin's got the youth and stamina to keep up with Maul. But not the experience. And double-blades aren't exactly coming facings in the Order those days. They MAY win if Obi-Wan plays it smart enough. But in all likelihood, Maul would kill them.

Just like he had the youth and stamina to keep up with Dooku?

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
I also made a ROTS Obi Wan vs AOTC Obi Wan and AOTC Anakin thread, and most people supported the duo. I ALSO made a ROTS Obi Wan vs TPM Maul thread and most supported Obi Wan. In this thread, most people support Maul.

😕

The lesson you should take from this is that you make too many threads.

Anyway, ROTS kenobi has that duo. And yes, ROTS Kenobi also can beat maul.

However, Maul can also beat the duo. Not that hard.

Originally posted by Shoes
Just like he had the youth and stamina to keep up with Dooku?

Originally posted by truejedi
The lesson you should take from this is that you make too many threads.

Another unjustified and inaccurate insult. The threads I mentioned are months apart from eachother.

Anyway, ROTS kenobi has that duo. And yes, ROTS Kenobi also can beat maul.

However, Maul can also beat the duo. Not that hard.

Perhaps. Maul with a hurt/broken ankle pretty much defeated Qui Gon + Obi Wan and only lost because of his arrogance (although he may act like that in this fight as well). Qui Gon > AOTC Obi Wan, although AOTC Anakin is probably > AOTC Obi Wan. Since the setting is the same for this fight as that one, Maul can use the same seperation tactics, although Obi Wan probably wouldn't fall for being lead into that bad-for-Ataru place like Qui Gon did, assuming that he learned from that fight.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Yes, he did have the youth and stamina to keep up with Dooku.

He was manhandled by Dooku, without any force powers, a man decades older and much less agressive than Maul.

Originally posted by Shoes
He was manhandled by Dooku, without any force powers, a man decades older and much less agressive than Maul.

Stamina and energy=/=power and skill.

Which is completely irrelevant because Maul outclasses him in both areas.

Originally posted by Shoes
Which is completely irrelevant because Maul outclasses him in both areas.

less agressive than Maul.

Maul outclasses him in [power and skill]

Try again