TPM Maul vs AOTC Obi Wan and AOTC Anakin

Originally posted by Shoes
Which is completely irrelevant because Maul outclasses him in both areas.

"him" as in Anakin or Dooku?

Dooku totally outclasses Maul in skill.

Anakin likely outclasses Maul in skill and is close in stamina (adding Anakin's Force prowess into the mix, Anakin is superior in stamina).

AOTC Anakin is basically a rasher version of TPM Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan is not nearly as experienced as Qui-Gon, but he was still a brilliant tactician. I'm sure the duo could hold Maul off long enough to think of something.

It's hilarious how a less experienced TPM Obi beats TPM Maul one v one and yet a more experienced Obi and plus Anakin get wtf pwnd by Maul in this thread. The wonderful reasoning... Ooo Obi got lucky because of Maul arrogance.... Ummmmm and this same arrogance is certain to not appear again in this fight? Let alone adding a more experienced Obi and adding Anakin? Interesting....

Well it is clear that (in both the novel as well as the film) Kenobi is not nearly as powerful as Maul. His victory does not indicate superiority.

From there everything else becomes clear. Being flippant about that one fact doesn't mean that it no longer applies.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
Well it is clear that (in both the novel as well as the film) Kenobi is not nearly as powerful as Maul. His victory does not indicate superiority.

From there everything else becomes clear. Being flippant about that one fact doesn't mean that it no longer applies.

So I say again... is arrogance is certain to not appear yet again in this fight just as it did with a less experienced Kenobi already?

I'd give it to the duo as long as Anakin doesn't recklessly charge himlike an idiot. Yes Dooku did defeat them but he fought them one at a time and Anakin actually faired well against him.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
So I say again... is arrogance is certain to not appear yet again in this fight just as it did with a less experienced Kenobi already?

I hadn't even used the phrase PIS yet, but I will now:
It was PIS.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
I haven't said anything about arrogance.

I hadn't even used the phrase PIS yet, but I will now:
It was PIS.

I haven't used it yet either, but I will now… They all fight… "In character". Arrogance is clearly a characteristic that shows up in Maul, and in fact, cost him his life.

KuRuPT Thanosi
It's hilarious how a less experienced TPM Obi beats TPM Maul one v one and yet a more experienced Obi and plus Anakin get wtf pwnd by Maul in this thread. The wonderful reasoning... Ooo Obi got lucky because of Maul arrogance.... Ummmmm and this same arrogance is certain to not appear again in this fight? Let alone adding a more experienced Obi and adding Anakin? Interesting....

Deal with it.

Originally posted by Eminence
If we factored CIS into every single versus match, they'd all end the same. So we don't.

Deal with it.

Yet they still have to fight In Character correct?

I don't know what that means.

Originally posted by Eminence
I don't know what that means.

That is that they fight with the mindset that a character generally fights in, so Yoda won't use Force lightning.

Id say Maul. Dooku took down Anakin and Obi Wan at this point and I'd say Maul is supereor witht the blade to Dooku.

Going with the duo.

The AotC novelization depicts Anakin doing pretty damn well against Dooku (especially for a Padawan.) I believe the novel said something like: "Dooku had to work furiously to keep Anakin's blade at bay." So if AotC Anakin made Dooku work for his victory, then Maul would have to work damn hard to gain any kind of headway, imo... Then tack on the fact that AotC Obi-Wan will also be present.

...I dunno, it's just hard for me to imagine Maul winning. /shrug

Again, i think maul is supereor to Dooku with the lightsaber. Heres why:
Maul beat Qui Gonn, wo was supposed to be equal to Windu, who was equal to Dooku.

Originally posted by Zack Skywalker
Again, i think maul is supereor to Dooku with the lightsaber. Heres why:
Maul beat Qui Gonn, wo was supposed to be equal to Windu, who was equal to Dooku.

Oh and just so you know: despite what Wookie says, the whole "Qui-Gon=Mace" thing has yet to be confirmed by any canonical sources. So yeah...

It has a source, The New essental Guide to Characters. I might even sya TPM Obi Wan could beat AOTC Obi Wan since he switched to a new form. Maul>Dooku with the lightsaber

But if this is with the force Dooku>Maul. So, the fight would be pretty even

Im pretty sure that Obi-Wans real form even inTPM was Soresu........

Anyways how is Qui-Gon=Mace when Mace holds a title saying he is the best fighter in the Jedi Order? (my source on that is the Star Wars Dictionary,not sure if its canon but if it aint oh well)

Originally posted by Pwned
Im pretty sure that Obi-Wans real form even inTPM was Soresu........

Anyways how is Qui-Gon=Mace when Mace holds a title saying he is the best fighter in the Jedi Order? (my source on that is the Star Wars Dictionary,not sure if its canon but if it aint oh well)

My source(New Essental Guide to characters) says they are equal. Qui Gonn was a amazing duelist as well as Windu, but this is at the time of TPM when Qui Gonn, Windu, and Dooku were equal. And Windu was not the best duelist in the order. Yoda and probally Anakin are supereor to him. And Obi wan's form was Ataru in TPM

Originally posted by Zack Skywalker
It has a source, The New essental Guide to Characters.