Originally posted by Borbarad
Actually, Blax was right: I didn't have the necessary freetime to continue this during the last week because of "having a life", which ocassionally keeps me busy enough not to get bored, which is the only reason for me to actually come here. That aside: Where did you defeat my argument?
Ok then, although it's hard to tell if you're telling the truth or not. Still, sorry if I offended you.
Somehow I think you don't get what happened. If Sadow's illusions multiplied the Sith forces a thousandfold, the betrayal took 99,9% of his troops away. The next took away a comeback and finally, the entire governing body of the Sith Empire was either wiped out or forced to retreat, with the actual enemy appearing in the - now undefended - heart of the Empire.
That aside you don't take any psychology into consideration. The Galactic Empire fell apart when the Emperor and the second in command were killed in the Battle of Endor, despite being far superior to the Rebel Alliance. Similar situation, similar outcome.
Basically, the betrayals took away his illusions, and apparently without his illusions the sith got creamed.
I don't care what you find hard to believe. Read the comics and stay with the facts instead of attempting to argue out of ignorance.
Fair enough
Because they would be united and fighting an enemy invading their own Empire.
Since when would an invasion of their homeworld somehow unite them? You and Team Empire claimed that Earth would not unite when the Empire invaded.
Again, you're arguing against the facts. Even Sidious had to search ancient sources to find the location of certain Sith worlds and the man had more resources at his disposal than anybody else. It's not that the location of the Sith worlds was common knowledge...
Maybe, but the same could be said for the reverse.
Care to explain how you are able to read "average Sith" when I'm typing "Ancient Sith Lords"? Care to explain how the Tribe of the Sith apprentices are even remotely compareable to people that studied the Dark Side and Sith Magic for centuries? Apparently you have no idea what the Ancient Sith are capable of. Again, I can only advice you to check the source material instead of arguing out of ignorance.
[quote]
Wtf? I'm referring to Luke, Jaina and Jacen vs 20 average ancient sith. The word "ancient" does not make them more powerful. Sure, the famous and powerful ancient sith were, well, powerful, but not every ancient sith was on the level of Ragnos.
[quote]
Did you, by chance, miss the fact that the Vong don't have force users capable of locating other force users - in contrast to the NJO? That aside: The Meditation Sphere is a mobile ship, semi-sentient and the Vong would need to search it somewhere in Sith space, without even knowing the extend of the Sith space nor that they actually need to search for the sphere.
Sensors anyone?
And the same could be said for the reversed; how are the sith going to track down the YV, who would have vastly superior hyperdrive, sensors and jammers?
This is complete speculation. We know that their ships were superior to Republic ships constructed 1,500 years later. We also know that force enhanced technology can yield results that "normal" invention isn't capable to offer. For example the Aing-Ti-Monks ability to "teleport" their ships through the Galaxy. The Sith, however, do have the means to keep up with armor / weapons thanks to Sith Alchemy.
The sith apparently got creamed when they lost their illusions. Had they really been that superior to the Old Republic forces, they would have won even if they lost their illusions.
You were refuting facts?
Let's be honest: You have no idea, how the technology compares to that of the Vong, neither do I. Who cares? This was never part of my original argument which, much to your dismay, isn't based on "conventional warfare". So I don't really get why everything you say is aimed at that topic. Desperation?
You were stating that the sith had superior technology in terms of superweapons. I was refuting that.
Neither will he be attacked, nor will all planets of the Empire be attacked simultaneously. Why? The Vong don't have his location, don't know that he even exists, don't have the locations of the Sith worlds and don't have the forces to attack them all at once.
Why would the YV invade the sith empire without knowing where the sith are?
And again, the same thing could be said in reverse. The sith would have no idea where the YV worlds are located, and the YV ships would have superior hyperdrive, sensors and jammers.
And you're arguing against the facts once again. I told you before that it doesn't make sense to compare the technology of two different cultures evolving seperated from each other. Centerpoint Station is 100,000 years old and still was the most effective weapon used against the Vong. The Vong are utilizing technology that is a 1,000 years old and still compares to that of the Republic. The Sith had weapons that were totally superior to anything but the Sun Crusher, 5,000 years before the latter was invented. That aside you're once more aiming at conventional warfare here, ignoring the entire purpose of my argument.
You're implying that the technological gap between the sith and the Republic was that big, but it obviously wasn't. The Celestials had already existed for quite a while by the time that they created Centerpoint Station, and the Rakata had already had several milenia to advanced by the time that they created the Star Forge. The sith empire was at about the same technological level as the Republic when the sith empire was founded, and both civilizations coexisted. The sith did not have several more milenia to advance.
No. I'm the one that introduced a quote saying it had "well over a hundred planets"...
And then you kept on mentioning "100 planets" and boasting about that.
Again: Arguing out of ignorance.
The invasion of the YV was coined by genocidal tactics like destroying / terraforming planets and killing all inhabitants. Thusly 1/3 of the Galactic population was killed, which is hardly "a very small proportion of the number of combatants", unless you want to assume that there were more combatants than actual inhabitants of the Galaxy. And stop pulling conclusions out of nowhere. The Battle of Coruscant saw the amassed invasion force of the YV (minus what they had lost before) and many of the warriors did commit suicide, after the death of Shimra. So how does it follow from there that the YV had "billions" of troops?
Good point. However, my point about the sith empire having a limited amount of troops compared to the YV still stands.
The YV neither have the information nor the forces to attack all Sith planets. Even if they could, Sadow would conjure illusional fleets and armies to take it up with them, which would still result in the YV losing by attrition sooner or later.
Again, the same could be applied in reverse. It would be easier for the YV to find 100 planets than for the sith empire to find however many planets the YV have AND their fleets, which would have advanced hyperdrive, sensor and jamming systems superior to that of the sith empire.
The alternative: The Vong show up in Sith space and the Sith Lords detonate the next star to wipe the entire invasion fleet out with a single attack. They could also attack the Vong with illusional fleets, outnumbering them totally and send some of the most powerful Dark Side users in history of the SW universe in for personal confrontation. This is not even mentioning the monsters and other nice gimmics created via Sith Alchemy, with the latter being force enhanced version of plot devices that you can wear as jewelry, sometimes able to wipe out entire armies on their own in the hands of a halfway decent force user. Hell. What stops them from thought-bombing the Vong?
"detonate the next star" - as you said about the YV finding the sith planets, how will the sith locate the YV fleet?
"illusional fleets" - Sadow would have to conjure up a lot of illusional fleets if he is to make up for the numerical and technological gap. Also, would the YV even be affected by the illusions?
In terms of conventional warfare, the Vong would most likely win, maybe even curbstomp the Sith. Adding the Siths abilities to manipulate the force, and they have a decent shot to take down the Vong with their "unnatural" abilities.
Well, your stance is now more defensible since you've changed it. However, your primary defense that the YV would not be able to locate the sith planets works in reverse as well. As soon as the YV locate the sith planets the sith are screwed.