Elder God Set vs Odin

@ Big-C...

What the heck are you talking about dude!? In the Infinity Guantlet arc, Zeus was NOT in the front lines with the Living Tribunal; Zeus was stranded in Asgard with all the rest of the Skyfathers and The Living Tribunal never challenged Thanos when he had the IG either...nor was Thor present when all the major cosmic beings meet to plan their strategy against Thanos.

In additon, the forces assembled to attack Thanos were described as "Eternity's Cosmic Brigade," and as "Eternity's Foot Soldiers." With the implication being that Eternity gathered the best of the best to engage Thanos with...

I think your memory and logic are the ones that are horrible at the moment...

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Isn't that from the What-If?

No, that picture is from the Atlantis Attacks Annuals, I think it's either the Fantastic Four one or Thor.

Originally posted by nicamarvin
whats next....? Odin feats> Demogorge Feats.... roll eyes (sarcastic)

Speaking of Demogorge feats, how about the one when he awakened when the Death Gods attempted to merge their realms. The look of fear on Odin and the other Skyfathers faces was proof that they knew they were finished if he got to them. So Demogorge > any and all Skyfathers. But that's not the point of this thread.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
The "title" Elder God is so overrated.

That's what I'm trying to figure out. This wouldn't have even been of any interest to me but the Marvel Mystic Arcana and the Marvel Tarot series sparked my curiosity. In it, Set, Gaea, Oshtur, and Chthon play a major role. All four are Elder Gods. And we've seen what Oshtur and Chthon are capable of, I'm trying to figure out why they even bothered with Set.

Originally posted by zopzop
[quote= Sr J-Bieb]Isn't that from the What-If?

No, that picture is from the Atlantis Attacks Annuals, I think it's either the Fantastic Four one or Thor.

Originally posted by nicamarvin
whats next....? Odin feats> Demogorge Feats.... roll eyes (sarcastic)

Speaking of Demogorge feats, how about the one when he awakened when the Death Gods attempted to merge their realms. The look of fear on Odin and the other Skyfathers faces was proof that they knew they were finished if he got to them. So Demogorge > any and all Skyfathers. But that's not the point of this thread.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
The "title" Elder God is so overrated.

That's what I'm trying to figure out. This wouldn't have even been of any interest to me but the Marvel Mystic Arcana and the Marvel Tarot series sparked my curiosity. In it, Set, Gaea, Oshtur, and Chthon play a major role. All four are Elder Gods. And we've seen what Oshtur and Chthon are capable of, I'm trying to figure out why they even bothered with Set. [/QUOTE]

set did fight demogorge for a prolonged time in there first encounter until he had to flee...and that was a demogorge that had absorbed an ass ton of other gods

When did this happen?

Originally posted by zopzop

No, that picture is from the Atlantis Attacks Annuals, I think it's either the Fantastic Four one or Thor.

That's what I'm trying to figure out. This wouldn't have even been of any interest to me but the Marvel Mystic Arcana and the Marvel Tarot series sparked my curiosity. In it, Set, Gaea, Oshtur, and Chthon play a major role. All four are Elder Gods. And we've seen what Oshtur and Chthon are capable of, I'm trying to figure out why they even bothered with Set.

Hmm. I was pretty sure it was from a What If. Well, it's not from the Thor annual (#14). I'm not completely sure about the Fantastic Four one however.

srug

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
@ Big-C...

What the heck are you talking about dude!? In the Infinity Guantlet arc, Zeus was NOT in the front lines with the Living Tribunal; Zeus was stranded in Asgard with all the rest of the Skyfathers and The Living Tribunal never challenged Thanos when he had the IG either...nor was Thor present when all the major cosmic beings meet to plan their strategy against Thanos.

In additon, the forces assembled to attack Thanos were described as "Eternity's Cosmic Brigade," and as "Eternity's Foot Soldiers." With the implication being that Eternity gathered the best of the best to engage Thanos with...

I think your memory and logic are the ones that are horrible at the moment...

bbrem123 is right in sets second fight with demogorge he fought him for a millenia on earth before demogorge won.

although iirc set had absorb the energy left in the earth by timaut when he was banished

do you think odin can fight demogorge for a millenia?

either way
chthon oshtur agamotto haggoth gaea are all above skyfather
so elder god>skyfather for the most part

Issue number?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Issue number?

I'll check it out later. This better not be bull.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
I'll check it out later. This better not be bull.

Originally posted by zopzop
[quote= Sr J-Bieb]Isn't that from the What-If?

No, that picture is from the Atlantis Attacks Annuals, I think it's either the Fantastic Four one or Thor.[/quote]

Can't find it in either. Not in the Iron Man Annual as well.

Originally posted by bbrem123

set did fight demogorge for a prolonged time in there first encounter until he had to flee...and that was a demogorge that had absorbed an ass ton of other gods

So had Set. Set was the first to kill and absorb other gods. He started it all long before Gaea gave birth to the Atum.

Also in their second encounter Set had feasted on enough energy to manifest on Earth. Atum shows up and starts reverting to his Demogorge form after absorbing a head of Set. Atum still manages to fight off Set.

Odin can stand up to Set and likely beat him. Elder gods can be way overrated.

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
Can't find it in either. Not in the Iron Man Annual as well.

Ok my bad, it's from Marvel Two-In-One #66, page 5.

Odin can stand up to Set and likely beat him. Elder gods can be way overrated.

This is true. But someone pointed out a page from The Marvel Tarot, that if he's reading it right, means Set is crazy powerful.

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
bbrem123 is right in sets second fight with demogorge he fought him for a millenia on earth before demogorge won.

Yes Set stalemated Atum for a long LONG time. The exact quote "And thus began a battle unlike any since, that threw the earth into chaos for millions of years". That is sorta impressive. Seeing as how Chthon himself never once dared engage Atum in battle.

Originally posted by zopzop

Yes Set stalemated Atum for a long LONG time. The exact quote "And thus began a battle unlike any since, that threw the earth into chaos for millions of years". That is sorta impressive. Seeing as how Chthon himself never once dared engage Atum in battle.

According to real world experience, an asteroid hit the earth and through it into chaos for millions of years.

In terms of comics, the destructive power of their fight could've thrown the world into chaos for a million years. BRB's fight with Stardust could've left have thrown the Earth into chaos for millions of years despite it being likely less than a day in combat. Odin's fight that wrecked galaxies could've laid enough waste to Earth that would throw it into chaos for millions of years.

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing

So had Set. Set was the first to kill and absorb other gods. He started it all long before Gaea gave birth to the Atum.

Also in their second encounter Set had feasted on enough energy to manifest on Earth. Atum shows up and starts reverting to his Demogorge form after absorbing a head of Set. Atum still manages to fight off Set.

Odin can stand up to Set and likely beat him. Elder gods can be way overrated. [/B]

what r u talking about....what make u think odin can stand up to set and beat him...odin shits his pants in the presence of demogorge....and it took atum forever to defeat set....

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
According to real world experience, an asteroid hit the earth and through it into chaos for millions of years.

In terms of comics, the destructive power of their fight could've thrown the world into chaos for a million years. BRB's fight with Stardust could've left have thrown the Earth into chaos for millions of years despite it being likely less than a day in combat. Odin's fight that wrecked galaxies could've laid enough waste to Earth that would throw it into chaos for millions of years.

and as i said earlier seth has wrecked galaxys
his fight didnt last one second with demorgorge
were as set fought him toe to toe for a million years
i really want to hear a reply on this

also why cant set eat odin. as it seems all the elder gods can eat other gods

Intresting debate.

I'll call set for a small majority.

Marvel Team-Up Annual#5 / Fantastic Four Annual#22

the power of a cosmic cube only banishes set
and even the he returned to earth two times after

Set ain't no jobber.

also ghaur , after having stolen the dreaming celestials power had it sucked out of him by set