FrankenCastle vs. Wolverine

Started by Deadline12 pages

Originally posted by Creshosk
Running away counts as a loss on these forums you know.

Falls under the "willingly leaving the battlefield" part.

Not if the person gets Koed first.

Originally posted by Deadline
Not if the person gets Koed first.
Cicurlar reasoning fallacy.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Cicurlar reasoning fallacy.

Pathetic. 🙁

Originally posted by Deadline
Pathetic. 🙁
Then change your argument and it won't be.

Ok I'm going to try one last time. If the person is KOed when they leave the field its not leaving the battlefield, because the fight has ended. Its only leaving the battlefield if the fight is still going on.

Originally posted by Deadline
Ok I'm going to try one last time. If the person is KOed when they leave the field its not leaving the battlefield, because the fight has ended. Its only leaving the battlefield if the fight is still going on.
Which doesn't prove that ten seconds is long enough.

"Ten seconds is long enough for a ko, because the person can leave because the person is K.O.ed"

You're using your argument as proof to prove your argument. Hence the circular reasoning, hence your argument is indeed pathetic.

Originally posted by Creshosk
Which doesn't prove that ten seconds is long enough.

"Ten seconds is long enough for a ko, because the person can leave because the person is K.O.ed"

You're using your argument as proof to prove your argument. Hence the circular reasoning, hence your argument is indeed pathetic.

It doesn't have to be long enough the fight ends when the person is Koed period. Obvoulsy 10 seconds is long enough for somebody like Thor, Hulk or any brick that can jump long distances.

If you don't like 10 seconds how about 20 or 30?

Originally posted by Deadline
It doesn't have to be long enough the fight ends when the person is Koed period. Obvoulsy 10 seconds is long enough for somebody like Thor, Hulk or any brick that can jump long distances.

If you don't like 10 seconds how about 20 or 30?

By that same reasoning a charter like flash or Nightcrawler could knock somebody down, and then teleport or run away.

"Because they can leave while the other person is still on the ground." Is a pathetic argument. Anything CLOSE to that argument is likewise pathetic. Though not unexpected in the slightest all things considered.

Originally posted by Creshosk
By that same reasoning a charter like flash or Nightcrawler could knock somebody down, and then teleport or run away.

"Because they can leave while the other person is still on the ground." Is a pathetic argument. Anything CLOSE to that argument is likewise pathetic. Though not unexpected in the slightest all things considered.

It doesn't matter wether you think its running away or not, the fight ends when the opponent is Koed. Just stating its a pathetic argument doesn't make it so.

Thats just part of my argument. The first part is when somebody is KOed the fight is over, so regardless of wether they get up in 10 seconds they have still won the fight. On KMC the fighting ends.

As for in real life if somebody was Koed for 10 seconds the fight would stpp. If the person gets up and then beats his opponent thats winning another fight.

Also you haven't adressed one of my points is 20 seconds or 30 long enough?

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ No. It's not suspect. Because it's happened as many times as Wolverine has tanked a superior beating to the skull.
Uh... No...
You're wrong... Way wrong.

^ Well I think you're wrong... Way wrong. So we sharply disagree, ole chum.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ Well I think you're wrong... Way wrong. So we sharply disagree, ole chum.

K'now I made a thread to prove where you could prove this nonsense.... Some reason it never took off... even though there's apparently a stunningly great amount of examples out there according to you.

^ People reading Wolverine as long as we have know it's not nonsense. I've got dozens of scans lined up just looking at the past year (though they involve all sorts of ko's like stabbing, shooting, etc.). That's just the past year and I haven't even gotten to anywhere near the vast majority of Wolverine comics/appearances.

I'm happy to revisit that thread once I re-download all the Wolverine comics I erased by accident.

Originally posted by Deadline
It doesn't matter wether you think its running away or not, the fight ends when the opponent is Koed. Just stating its a pathetic argument doesn't make it so.
You've got it backwads. My calling it a pathetic argument doesn't make it a pathetic argument, it being a pathetic argument makes me call it a pathetic argument.

Originally posted by Deadline
Thats just part of my argument. The first part is when somebody is KOed the fight is over, so regardless of wether they get up in 10 seconds they have still won the fight. On KMC the fighting ends./
The other person's ability to run away is a pathetic measurment of this. If the person who just took a hit plays possum the other person can escape instead of going after the person. Doesn't mean that the person playing possum is defeated.

Originally posted by Deadline
As for in real life if somebody was Koed for 10 seconds the fight would stpp. If the person gets up and then beats his opponent thats winning another fight.
been over this. there are no spectators to keep entertained you can't use boxing's rules.

Originally posted by Deadline
Also you haven't adressed one of my points is 20 seconds or 30 long enough?
That's beacuse I'm not so stupid as to pick an arbitrary number like that.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ Well I think you're wrong... Way wrong. So we sharply disagree, ole chum.
That's because you hate wolverine.

"Then why do I have so many wolverine comics?"

What better way to lowball the one you hate than to be able to show off his low showings?

Just like carver9 who insists that superman can't take a punch from colossus and claims to have tons of scans showing superman being hurt by people weaker than Colossus.

Sound familiar?