Frank Castle vs Steve Rogers

This is human Frank, not Frankensatle.

Frank and Cap each get an army knife, no other weapons. But -
CIS is ON for Cap.
CIS is OFF for Frank, he's going for the kill.

They fight in a junkyard. Who wins and how do you see the fight going?

Frankencastle.

Cap wins.

Originally posted by Deadline
Frankencastle.

Originally posted by SamZED
This is human Frank, not Frankencastle.

Oh duh, cap wins.

Even in the "CIS on for Cap" but "off for Frank" scenario??

Hmm im not so sure then. I like both characters so its a tough one.

Originally posted by Deadline
Hmm im not so sure then. I like both characters so its a tough one.

mm it's not though is it? Cap takes punisher everytime, there is not single physical area including damage soak (which says alot considering it's Punishers biggest strength), where Pun has an edge.

He's slower.
Less agile.
He's less skilled.
Has less experience.
Is weaker by half.
Plus Cap isnt likely to tire facing someone he's so physically superior to. And if Cap knows Franks CIS is off aned knows it's a fight for his life, it's even more of a steamroll.

imo ofcourse

Cap without a doubt. He outclasses Frank in every respect. Steve will take some lumps though.

Probably Captain America.

Originally posted by Juk3n
mm it's not though is it? Cap takes punisher everytime, there is not single physical area including damage soak (which says alot considering it's Punishers biggest strength), where Pun has an edge.

He's slower.
Less agile.
He's less skilled.
Has less experience.
Is weaker by half.
Plus Cap isnt likely to tire facing someone he's so physically superior to. And if Cap knows Franks CIS is off aned knows it's a fight for his life, it's even more of a steamroll.

imo ofcourse

No of course not. As I keep mentiong 100 times Kraven The Hunter has superhuman stats and is a skilled martial artist. Punisher was stalemating him after fighting a gauntlet of supervillians. He fought Daken with a broken leg and other wounds, as you know Daken is superhuman and is also a skilled martial artist. Cap isn't as skilled as any of those guys but he has lower stats.

Yeah Cap wins but if he holds back against a Punisher whos out to kill he just might end up dying.

Stevey.

Originally posted by Deadline
No of course not. As I keep mentiong 100 times Kraven The Hunter has superhuman stats and is a skilled martial artist. Punisher was stalemating him after fighting a gauntlet of supervillians.

Originally posted by Deadline
He fought Daken with a broken leg and other wounds, as you know Daken is superhuman and is also a skilled martial artist. Cap isn't as skilled as any of those guys but he has lower stats.

Daken killed Punisher........

cap beats frank blk and blue... frank gives it his best shot till he pisses cap off by biting off a cheek or ear..

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
...........yea the same issue were Punsiher over powered and choked out a class 100 tiger shark.........

Cap is more skilled then they are........

Daken killed Punisher........

Cap wins, it would be a good fight, I'd love to see it on-panel.

Originally posted by Trackz
Daken was fighting a mentally defeated and physically weak punisher, Daken would probably still win in a straight fight, but it would be a lot harder.

Cap wins, it would be a good fight, I'd love to see it on-panel.

The Captain of course

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
...........yea the same issue were Punsiher over powered and choked out a class 100 tiger shark.........

Hes beaten Kraven before, so thats the end of that.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan

Cap is more skilled then they are........

Daken killed Punisher........

facepalm.

Originally posted by Deadline
Hes beaten Kraven before, so thats the end of that.

facepalm.

hey why dont was uses a little ABC logic. Punisher stalemated Kraven, Kraven got beaten into the ground by beast and Capt pummeled beast.

Capt>>>>Beast>Punisher=Kraven

Yeah sure.